Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 22;13:841868. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2022.841868

Table 4.

Vaccine efficacy based on symptomatic COVID-19 infection in both scenarios: without censoring for COVID-19 vaccination and with censoring for COVID-19 vaccination.

Scenario All Unvaccinated Revaccinated with BCG
COVID-19 – without censoring for COVID-19 vaccination
Number of COVID-19 cases, n 16 9 7
Cumulative incidence. n/total (%) 16/131 (12.2) 9/67 (13.4) 7/64 (10.9)
Number censored, n (%) 115 (87.8) 58 (86.6) 57 (89.1)
VE based on HR (95.0% CI)* 28.0 (-98.0 to 74.0)
Person-Years 59.8 30.4 29.4
IR per 100 Person-Years (95.0% CI) 26.8 (15.3-43.4) 29.6 (13.5-56.2) 23.8 (9.6-49.1)
VE based on IRR (95.0% CI) 30.0 (-93.0 to 76.0)
COVID-19 – with censoring for COVID-19 vaccination
Number of COVID-19 cases, n 14 7 7
Cumulative incidence, n/total (%) 14/131 (10.7) 7/67 (10.4) 7/64 (10.9)
Number censored, n (%) 117 (89.3) 60 (89.6) 57 (89.1)
VE based on HR (95.0% CI)* 8.0 (-173.0 to 69.0)
Person-Years 42.2 21.2 21.0
IR per 100 Person-Years (95.0% CI) 33.2 (18.1-55.7) 33.0 (13.3-68.0) 33.3 (13.4-68.7)
VE based on IRR (95.0% CI) 16.0 (-155.0 to 72.0)

Symptomatic COVID-19 defined as the presence of RT-PCR or IgM or IgG serology positive test and presence of flu-like symptoms. IRR, incidence rate ratio; HR=hazard ratio; VE, vaccine efficacy; CI, confidence interval. *Vaccine efficacy based on 1-HR obtained in Cox proportional model adjusted for age and sex; Vaccine efficacy based on 1-IRR obtained in Poisson model adjusted for age and sex, with the natural logarithm (log[n]) of time at risk as offset variable.