2. Summary of clinical characteristics and conflicts of interest of included studies.
Study ID | Disease type | Definition of refractory | Definition of clinical remission/improvement | Conflicts of interest |
Aoki 2012 | UC | NR |
Clinical remission: participants who achieved a CAI score of ≥ 3 were considered to have achieved remission. Clinical improvement: a decrease in CAI by ≥ 4 points was considered clinical improvement. |
NR |
Lawrance 2017 | UC | People who failed conventional therapies of oral or rectal (or both) 5‐aminosalicylate or oral and rectal steroids (or both), or were intolerant of these medications. |
Clinical remission: observed by a Mayo score ≤ 2 with no subscore > 1. In addition to endoscopic score of 0 or 1 indicating mucosal healing. Clinical improvement: a reduction in Mayo score ≥ 3 points and a decrease of > 30% from the baseline score. In addition, a reduction of ≥ 1 on the rectal bleeding subscale, or alternatively an absolute rectal score of 0 or 1. |
Authors declared no conflicts of interest. |
Lie 2020 | UP | Mesalamine‐refractory UP (defined as a failure to at least the use of mesalamine suppositories of a maximum of 1 g for ≥ 21 days) or recurring UP (defined as a relapse within 3 months after stopping adequate local mesalamine therapy). |
Clinical remission: defined as a Mayo score ≤ 2, and endoscopic remission as no visible inflammation (i.e. Mayo subscore 0). Clinical response: defined as an absolute decrease in Mayo score of 3 points, with a relative decrease of 30% of the total score and ≥ 1 point decrease in the rectal bleeding subscore or an absolute rectal bleeding subscore of 0 or 1. |
Authors declared no conflicts of interest. |
Ogata 2006 | UC | Steroid resistance defined as unresponsiveness to oral or intravenous corticosteroid therapy. Steroid dependency was defined as either chronic active UC for > 6 months or frequent recurrence (> once a year, or ≥ 3 times every 2 years regardless of intensive medical therapy). |
Clinical remission: defined as a DAI score ≤ 2, with no individual subscore > 1, and mucosal healing was defined as an endoscopy subscore (≥ 2 at entry) of 0 or 1. Clinical improvement: defined as combination of partial and complete response. Partial response was defined as a reduction of > 4 points on DAI with improvement in all categories. Complete response was defined as resolution of all symptoms (all assessment scores 0). |
Authors declared no conflicts of interest. |
Ogata 2012 | UC | Steroid resistance was when the disease failed to respond to a systemic daily dose of 1 mg/kg bodyweight, or ≥ 40 mg of prednisolone given over ≥ 7 days, or the equivalent of a daily dose of prednisolone of ≥ 30 mg over ≥ 2 weeks. Steroid‐dependent participants were defined as people with active UC in whom attempts to taper steroids had been unsuccessful. |
Clinical remission: defined as a DAI score ≤ 2, with an individual subscore 0 or 1, and mucosal healing defined as an endoscopy subscore of 0 or 1. Clinical response: defined as a reduction in DAI by ≥ 4 points and improvements in all categories (stool frequency, rectal bleeding, mucosal appearance, and physician’s overall assessment). |
Authors declared no conflicts of interest. |
CAI: Clinical Activity Index; DAI: Disease Activity Index; NR: not reported; UC: ulcerative colitis; UP: ulcerative proctitis.