TABLE 1.
Body of work | Primary element | # | Secondary element | # |
---|---|---|---|---|
Organizational learning, innovation, and continuous quality improvement | Quality improvement processes are standard practice | 46 | Continuous (or CQ) Improvement processes are used | 16 |
Rapid (or Rapid‐Cycle) learning processes are used | 10 | |||
Plan‐Do‐Study‐Act (PDSA) cycles are used | 5 | |||
Learning is done according to particular principles, processes, practices, and/or models | 33 | Collaborative or team‐based learning | 16 | |
Systems science | 8 | |||
The Learning Cycle proposed by Friedman | 5 | |||
Collective “sensemaking” | 2 | |||
Positive deviance | 2 | |||
Triple‐loop learning (“learning how to learn”) | 2 | |||
“Emergent learning” or learning in support of “emergent strategy” | 0 | |||
Learning is driven/guided by specific goals | 13 | Equity | 6 | |
Improving the quality of care | 4 | |||
Efficiency | 3 | |||
Patient safety | 2 | |||
Learning takes place throughout the organization | 8 | |||
Translating knowledge and evidence into improved practices |
Research is translated into practice | 26 | Research conducted within the organization is translated | 7 |
Research findings from the literature are translated | 2 | |||
The organization adopts or implements evidence‐based treatments | 18 | |||
There is a reciprocal relationship between research and practice | 17 | |||
The organization is systematic in its implementation processes | 13 | Interventions should be adapted or tailored to the specific context | 6 | |
Allows for learning and refinement in implementation | 5 | |||
Systematically de‐implements practices that no longer serve the organization | 3 | |||
Follows the principles of implementation science | 3 | |||
Implements with fidelity | 0 | |||
Building new knowledge and evidence | The organization builds knowledge or evidence | 54 | ||
The organization conducts “research” | 28 | |||
The research conducted by the organization is practical or needs to balance practical with rigorous | 26 | |||
Findings from the research are shared or disseminated | 14 | Internally | 7 | |
Externally | 6 | |||
Research conducted by the organization answers questions that are directly relevant to the organization | 11 | Answers questions posed by clinicians (relevant to clinical practice) | 5 | |
Answers questions by organizational leaders (relevant to larger organizational goals) | 1 | |||
Data are translated into information | 6 | |||
Internal knowledge and external knowledge are integrated | 5 | |||
The research conducted by the organization is rigorous | 4 | |||
Analyzing clinical data | Patient data are captured and organized into a system, which is then used for analysis (research, QI, or other forms of learning) | 37 | ||
Clinical and/or informatics data are used in diagnosing and treating individual patients | 34 | Clinical decision support systems are in place | 22 | |
Personalized treatment (eg, using genomics data) | 12 | |||
Precision medicine | 7 | |||
Aggregated clinical data is shared between institutions | 14 | The clinical data systems of different institutions are networked | 3 | |
Clinical data are analyzed to develop research questions and design studies | 3 | |||
Engaging clinicians, patients, and other stakeholders | Patients and family members are actively engaged | 40 | … engaged in the learning process | 18 |
… engaged in clinical decision making | 13 | |||
Stakeholders (beyond researchers) are engaged in the learning process | 37 | Stakeholders from within the organization (beyond researchers) are engaged in the learning process | 20 | |
Community members or community‐based organizations are engaged | 17 | … engaged in the learning process | 4 | |
… engaged in improving the organization | 0 | |||
Clinicians are actively engaged in research | 7 | |||
Payors are engaged in the learning process | 1 |
Note: Elements mentioned in at least 20 publications are highlighted in dark yellow. Elements mentioned in 10‐19 publications are highlighted in light yellow.