TABLE 4.
Year (Y) | Treatment (T) | LAI at FL | IR (MJ m–2) | IPAR (MJ m–2) | LIP (%) | TDW (g m–2) | RUE (g MJ–1) |
2017 | CK | 3.49 c | 1,820 | 487.7 d | 78.4 d | 1,153.5 d | 2.37 d |
FP | 6.45 b | 1,836 | 639.0 c | 81.5 c | 1,580.0 c | 2.47 c | |
OPT–N | 6.60 b | 1,836 | 661.8 b | 84.5 b | 1,675.2 b | 2.53 b | |
OPT+N | 7.08 a | 1,847 | 722.3 a | 87.4 a | 1,876.6 a | 2.60 a | |
Mean | 5.9 | 1,835 | 627.7 | 83 | 1571.3 | 2.49 | |
2018 | CK | 3.71 c | 1,753 | 723.7 d | 68.5 d | 1,516.0 d | 2.09 c |
FP | 5.90 b | 1,755 | 788.1 c | 76.8 c | 2,013.8 c | 2.56 b | |
OPT–N | 6.63 b | 1,795 | 822.4 b | 84.3 b | 2,134.8 b | 2.60 ab | |
OPT+N | 8.49 a | 1,847 | 853.3 a | 87.9 a | 2,288.6 a | 2.68 a | |
Mean | 6.18 | 1,509 | 796.9 | 79.4 | 1,988.3 | 2.48 | |
2019 | CK | 2.52 d | 1,943 | 554.3 c | 51.1 d | 1,201.4 d | 2.17 c |
FP | 5.52 c | 1,962 | 743.7 b | 75.2 c | 2,039.0 c | 2.74 b | |
OPT–N | 7.34 b | 1,987 | 764.2 ab | 82.8 b | 2,155.5 b | 2.82 a | |
OPT+N | 8.66 a | 2,163 | 783.3 a | 86.2 a | 2,240.5 a | 2.86 a | |
Mean | 6.01 | 2,000 | 711.4 | 73.8 | 1,909.1 | 2.65 | |
2020 | CK | 2.72 c | 1,630 | 533.1 d | 59.0 d | 1,193.2 d | 2.24 c |
FP | 4.79 b | 1,716 | 650.2 c | 77.6 c | 1,700.0 c | 2.61 b | |
OPT–N | 5.78 a | 1,741 | 737.0 b | 83.5 b | 1,993.2 b | 2.70 ab | |
OPT+N | 6.10 a | 1,763 | 770.4 a | 86.5 a | 2,147.5 a | 2.79 a | |
Mean | 4.85 | 1,711 | 672.6 | 76.7 | 1,758.5 | 2.59 | |
Analysis of variance | Year (Y) | 1.82* | – | 8.48** | 5.88* | 3.22* | 7.85** |
Treatment (T) | 12.33** | – | 20.55** | 12.54** | 51.21** | 61.77** | |
Y × T | 21.01* | – | 55.88** | 28.20** | 11.24** | 32.34** |
IR, total solar radiation; IPAR, intercepted photosynthetically active radiation; LIP, light interception percentage; ns, not significant. Different lowercase letters within columns indicate significant differences at P < 0.05; *P < 0.05; **P < 0.01.