qADD |
AUC |
0.847±0.002
|
0.842±0.002
|
0.810±0.001
|
|
Selected features |
μ-Solid, σ-Solid, μ-SS, ρ-SS |
σ-Solid, μ-SS, S-Nodule, S-LP |
σ-Solid, μ-SS, S-LP |
|
|
AUC |
0.867 ±0.002
|
0.888±0.001
|
0.852±0.001
|
qADD+ |
Selected features |
μ-Solid, σ-Solid, μ-SS, ρ-SS, E-COPD |
σ-Solid, μ-SS, S-Nodule, S-LP, Gender, Smoke-years, Upper-lobe |
σ-Solid, μ-SS, S-LP, ρ-SS, Gender, Smoke-years, E-COPD |
|
vs qADD |
P = 0.208
|
P =0.089
|
P =0.280
|
|
qADD++ |
AUC |
0.901±0.001
|
0.909±0.001
|
0.877±0.001
|
Selected featu s |
μ-Solid, σ-Solid, μ-SS, ρ-SS, E-COPD, GGO, Spiculated |
σ-Solid, μ-SS, S-Nodule, S-LP, Smoke-years, E- COPD, Size, Spiculated |
σ-Solid, μ-SS, S-LP, ρ-SS, Smoke-years, E-COPD, Size |
vs qADD |
P = 0.046
|
P =0.027
|
P =0.069
|
vs qADD+ |
P = 0.102
|
P =0.159
|
P =0.096
|
|
|
AUC |
0.741±0.033 |
0.855±0.031 |
0.843±0.031 |
|
Risk factors |
Age, Gender, Family, Emphysema, Size, Attenuation, Upper-lobe, Spiculated. |
Brock Model |
vs qADD |
P=0.121
|
P=0.185
|
P=0.469
|
vs qADD+ |
P=0.039
|
P =0.167
|
P=0.770
|
|
Mayo Clinic Model |
AUC |
0.693±0.030 |
0.821±0.032 |
0.771±0.032 |
Risk factors |
Age, Smoker, Non-Lung-Cancer, Size, Upper-lobe, Spiculated. |
vs qADD |
P =0.033
|
P =0.681
|
P =0.523
|
vs qADD+ |
P =0.014
|
P =0.042
|
P =0.028
|
vs Brock |
P=0.242
|
P=0.341
|
P=0.012
|