TABLE 1.
Summary of advantages and limitations of routine detections for Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB).
Detections | Advantages | Limitations |
Culture | • Gold standard; • Low cost; • Drug susceptibility testing. |
• Long growth circle (it takes up to 8 weeks to grow into visible colonies on solid culture media) (16); • Low sensitivity and poor positive rate. |
Acid-fast staining | • Low cost; • Short turnaround time (the average time is 16.6 h) (90). |
• Hard to distinguish between Mycobacterium leprae and non-tuberculous Mycobacteria (NTM) (96); • Tend to receive negative results in HIV-infected patients or children, who bear low bacterial load (97); • Low sensitivity and poor positive rate. |
Imaging examination | • Assist in diagnosis and follow-up (17, 18) | • Atypical when co-infection or low immune status occur (17); • Not specific in extrapulmonary TB (18). |
Xpert MTB/RIF | • Short turnaround time (the average turnaround time is 24.1 h) (90); • Drug resistance detection (against RIF) (98); • High sensitivity and specificity (20) |
• Only specific sites can be detected (20, 99); • Xpert has limited sensitivity in HIV patients with miliary lung infiltrates, mainly due to paucibacillary specimens (20, 99); • Better testing might not improve the outcomes (100, 101). |
TST and IGRA | • Low cost; • Identify LTBI (22). |
• Low sensitivity in immunocompromised populations; • False-positive in patients vaccinated with Bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) via TST (24); • Unable to differentiate between LTBI and active TB (22, 23) |