Table 1.
Organoid culture techniques | |||
---|---|---|---|
Submerged Matrigel culture | Air-liquid interface culture | Microfluidic 3D culture | |
Tissue processing before culture | Tissues are dissociated mechanically or/and enzymatically | Tissue is minced into small fragments | Tissues are dissociated mechanically or/and enzymatically; by filtering 40–100 μm-sized tumor fragments are collected and pelleted in ultra-low-attachment plates |
Culture matrix
And Culture equipment |
Matrigel Dish or plate |
Collagen Inner dish, Outer dish (Transwell plates with permeable membrane inserts) |
Collagen Microfluidic device |
Plating condition | Cells culture underneath medium in mixture with 3D Matrigel | Mixture of tissue fragments and collagen plated on the inner dish with a bottom collagen layer; medium is added into an outer dish that can diffuse into the inner trans-well dish through a permeable membrane; top of collagen layer is exposed to air | Spheroid-collagen mixture is inoculated into central gel region of the device; medium is added into media channels on both sides |
Preserved cell types of original tumor tissue in culture | Cancer cells exclusively | Cancer cells, tumor-infiltrating myeloid and lymphoid cells, native immune cells, and stromal cells | Cancer cells, tumor-infiltrating myeloid and lymphoid cells, native immune cells, and stromal cells |
Modeling the tumor immune microenvironment | PBMCs, DCs and other immune cells can be added to the culture | Immune cells of tumor tissue are faithfully preserved | Immune cells can be added in the medium; immune cells of tumor tissue are faithfully preserved |
Advantages | Organoid expansion is convenient | Cellular complexity and architecture of the tumor tissue are maintained as an intact en bloc unit without reconstitution | Cellular diversity and architecture of the tumor tissue are maintained; small amount of medium/reagents and small number of cells are required; it can be automated; mimicking physiological shear flow |
Limitations | Stromal components and immune cells are usually not preserved in tissue processing stage, determining the growth factors and/or inhibitors required to maintain all subclones is the laborious and time-consuming process; does not reflect the native tumor-infiltrating immune cells, lack of immune components hinders immunotherapy assessment; allogeneic cultures will result in high background killing compared with autologous systems | Determining the growth factors and/or inhibitors required to maintain all subclones is the laborious and time-consuming process; necrosis and hypoxic cores of organoids; the immune components decline over time and do not persist beyond ~2 months | Determining the growth factors and/or inhibitors required to maintain all subclones is the laborious and time-consuming process; size limitation; requires specialized equipment; the immune components decline over time |
Possible future improvements | Culture duration can be extended; establishing organoid biobanks for model standardization across laboratories; incorporating multiple organoid types into single microchips; using synthetic scaffolds with precise ECM composition that is essential for reproducible research; increase immune cellular complexity by both incorporated into, and preserved in; to overcome to the formation of a necrotic core, and better recapitulation of native TME organoid vascularization and perfusion are needed | ||
References | (33–41) | (42, 43) | (44–47) |