Table 2.
# | Study and year | Country | Design | Condition | Type of telemonitoring | Analysis | Outcome measures for adoption |
1 | Aamodt et al21 2019 | Norway and Lithuania | Cross-sectional survey | Heart failure care | Body weight, blood pressure, heart rate, dyspnoea | Summative content analysis | Reported as not part of routine care/standard care |
2 | Alkmim et al22 2019 | Brazil | Survey | Cardiology | Tele-ECG | Descriptive statistics | Utilisation >3 dys per week |
3 | Chronaki et al24 2013 | Europe | Narrative review | Diverse | Tele-ECG | n.a. | Healthcare costs+number of clinics engaging in TM |
4 | Cook et al39 2016 | UK | Qualitative semistructured interviews | COPD | Telehealth: Pulse oximetry, temperature, pulse, blood pressure | Framework method | n.a. |
5 | Diaz-Skeete et al40 2019 | Ireland | Workshop report | Cardiac care | n.a. | n.a. | n.a. |
6 | Faber et al25 2017 | Netherlands | Survey | Heart failure +diabetes | n.a. | Structured equation modelling approach | Extent of adoption in percentages |
7 | Fraiche et al26 2017 | USA | Narrative review | Heart failure | Blood pressure, weight, ECG | n.a. | n.a. |
8 | Hanley et al27 2018 | Scotland | Qualitative interview +focus groups | COPD, hypertension, Blood pressure, after stroke, COPD, heart failure, diabetes | SpO2, Blood pressure, blood glucose, | Interpretive description approach and thematic analysis | N.a. |
9 | Kato et al28 2015 | Japan and Sweden | Cross-sectional survey | Heart failure | Monitoring physical condition and noticing a decline | Descriptive analysis and content analysis methodology | Four domains Reported as not part of routine care |
10 | Klack et al29 2013 | Germany | Survey | Heart patient | Weight, temperature, blood pressure, coagulation | Descriptive statistics | Physician and engineers perspectives Extent of adoption in percentages |
11 | Kristensen et al30 2019 | Denmark | Email survey | Chronic heart failure, atrial fibrillation, COPD, ADHD, Pregnant with complications, hypertension, patients with an ICD | Blood pressure, heart rhythm, body weight, heart rate, blood glucose | Number of initiatives in interactive map online | Number of projects registered |
12 | MacNeill, 201431 | UK | Semistructured qualitative interviews | Chronic heart disease, COPD and diabetes | Blood pressure, weight, oxygen, blood glucose | Modified grounded theory | |
13 | McGillion et al32 2018 | Canada | Narrative review | Surgical population | Respiratory rate, blood pressure, heart rate, SpO2, temperature | n.a. | n.a. |
14 | Muigg 201933 | Austria | Cross-sectional survey | Diabetes | Blood pressure and blood glucose | Qualitative content analysis | Reported as not part of routine care |
15 | Okazaki et al34 2013 | Japan and Spain | Survey | Not specified | Not specified | Causal modelling | n.a. |
16 | Taylor et al35 2014 | UK | Qualitative interviews | COPD and chronic heart failure | Not specified | Thematic analysis | n.a. |
17 | de Vries et al36 2013 | The Netherlands | Survey | Heart failure | Blood pressure, weight, heart frequency, ECG | Descriptive statistics | Usage |
18 | Van den Heuvel et al38 2020 |
The Netherlands | Survey | Women with pregnancy complications | Cardiotocography | Descriptive statistics | Provision of telemonitoring and perspectives of respondents |
19 | Gawalko et al37 2021 |
Europe | Survey | Management of atrial fibrillation | Remote PPG or 1-lead ECG | Descriptive statistics | Centre experience and patient experience. |
ADHD, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder; COPD, Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease; ECG, ElectroCardioGram; ICD, Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator; n.a., not available; PPG, Photoplethysmography; SpO2, peripheral capillary oxygen saturation; TM, Telemonitoring.