Table 1.
Assay | D.Ultra [32] | MICSSS [33] | Vectra/Polaris [35] | Opal [39] | CODEX [41,42] | InSituPlex [43] | GeoMx DSP [44,45] | MIBI-TOF [46,47] | Cy-TOF [48] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vendor | Roche | Remark et al. | Akoya Biosciences | Roche and Akoya Biosciences |
Akoya Biosciences | Ultivue | Nanostring | IonPath | Bodenmiller et al. |
Antibody
Conjugate |
chromogen | chromogen | fluorescent | Opal fluorescent |
DNA barcode |
DNA barcode |
DNA barcode |
Metal isotope |
Metal isotope |
Tissue
disruption |
no | no | no | no | no | no | no | Yes (adjustable) |
yes |
Biomarkers | 5 | 10+ | ∼9 | ∼8 | 40+ | ∼5 | 70+ | 30+ | 30+ |
Staining
cycles |
Iterative | Iterative | Iterative | Iterative | Iterative | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
Scanning | camera | camera | Vectra Polaris | Vectra Polaris | CODEX fluidics | compatible with various systems |
GeoMx | TOF spectrometer |
TOF spectrometer |
Profiling
area |
Whole slide | Whole slide | adjustable (660 m → whole slide) |
adjustable (660 μm → whole slide) |
660 m | NA | adjustable (280 μm → 800 m) |
800 m | 1 mm |
Software | NA | NA | InForm | InForm QuPath |
CODEX analysis manager & viewer |
compatible with various systems |
GeoMx data analysis suite |
MIBIAnalysis | HistoCat, Cell Profiler |
Resolution | Human vision |
Human vision |
0.25–0.9 m | 0.25–0.9 m | 0.26 m | NA | 10 m | 0.26 m | 1 m |
Spatial
information |
yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | limited | yes | yes |
Single-cell
information |
yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | limited | yes | yes |
Disadvantages | Human Vision Limits, Semi- Quantitative |
time- consuming, coverslip removal errors |
costly, limited marker numbers |
costly, limited marker numbers |
costly, time- consuming, difficult cell segmentation, difficult panel validation |
limited marker numbers |
costly, limited spatial information, limited single cell information |
special training, costly, time- consuming, difficult cell segmentation, difficult panel validation |
special training, costly, time- consuming, difficult cell segmentation, difficult panel validation |