Skip to main content
. 2022 Apr 22;54(4):466–482. doi: 10.1038/s12276-022-00748-6

Table 4.

Comparison of microbial EV therapy vs. live biotherapeutics (LBP) and human cell EV (exosome) therapies.

Microbial EVs Live biotherapeutics (LBP) Human cell EVs (Exosomes)
Pharmacology (PK/PD)

• Multimodal mechanism of action (MoA)

• Nanosized EVs enter systemic circulation

• Independent of viability

• Targeting of specific organs & cellular organelles

• Targeting of distant organs (esp. brain)

• Efficacious oral application possible

• No penetration of host cells

• Generally restricted to the GI tract

• Dependent on viability

• Targeting of specific organs unfeasible

• Targeting of distant organs unfeasible

• Oral administration unfeasible

Safety

• No proliferation

• Minimal safety concerns (commensal derived)

• Low potential for epigenetic modification

• Uncontrollable proliferation

• Concerns for immune-compromised individuals

• Potential for epigenetic modification
CMC

• Minimal storage & stability issues

• High yield

• Low cost

• Storage & stability hurdles

• Low yield

• High cost

PK pharmacokinetic, PD pharmacodynamic, CMC chemistry, manufacturing, and control.