Skip to main content
. 2022 Apr 12;19(8):4638. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19084638

Table 4.

Subgroup analysis for HIIT + fasting in overweight and obese adults.

Outcomes Intervention N ES (95% CI) Heterogeneity p
I2 (%) p
Body mass Long term 4 MD: −4.28 0 0.45 0.008
(−7.44, −1.13)
Short term 4 MD: 2.91 0 1 0.39
(−3.78, 9.06)
Long interval 6 MD: −2.93 7 0.37 0.16
(−6.99, 1.13)
Short interval 3 MD: −0.81 0 0.91 0.77
(−6.20, 4.58)
LCD 6 MD: −2.31 12 0.34 0.3
(−6.69, 2.07)
Low-carbohydrate diet 3 MD: −1.02 0 0.96 0.71
(−6.5, 4.45)
BMI Long term 3 MD: −1.56 0 0.39 0.01
(−2.76, −0.36)
Short term 4 MD: 0.36 0 0.98 0.78
(−2.22, 2.94)
Long interval 5 MD: −1.23 0 0.7 0.03
(−2.55, 0.09)
Short interval 2 MD: −1.43 40 0.2 0.29
(−4.08, 1.22)
LCD 5 MD: −1.23 0 0.7 0.03
(−2.55, 0.09)
Low-carbohydrate diet 2 MD: −1.43 40 0.2 0.29
(−4.08, 1.22)
WC Long term 3 MD: −5.14 0 0.7 0.002
(−8.33, −1.96)
Short term 3 MD: −1.73 0 0.76 0.55
(−7.43, 3.97)
Long interval 4 MD: −4.22 0 0.65 0.01
(−7.54, −0.89)
Short interval 2 MD: −4.6 0 0.42 0.07
(−9.66, 0.46)
LCD 4 MD: −4.22 0 0.65 0.01
(−7.54, −0.89)
Low-carbohydrate diet 2 MD: −4.6 0 0.42 0.07
(−9.66, 0.46)
BFP Long term 3 MD: −1.04 0 0.67 0.26
(−2.84, 0.76)
Short term 3 MD: −1.05 0 0.58 0.31
(−3.09, 0.98)
Long interval 4 MD: −1.08 0 0.78 0.14
(−2.5, 0.35)
Short interval 2 MD: −0.78 0 0.37 0.72
(−5.02, 3.46)
LCD 5 MD: −0.96 0 0.8 0.18
(−2.35, 0.43)
Low-carbohydrate diet 1 MD: −2.4 NA NA 0.4
(−7.95, 3.15)
FM Long term 2 MD: −2.47 2 0.31 0.01
(−4.45, −0.5)
Short term 3 MD: 0.65 0 0.86 0.8
(−4.42, 5.71)
Long interval 5 MD: −2.33 0 0.69 0.007
(−4.02, −0.63)
Short interval 1 MD: 2 NA NA 0.66
(−6.94, 10.94)
LCD 5 MD: −2.45 0 0.54 0.01
(−4.17, −0.73)
Low-carbohydrate diet 1 MD: −2 NA NA 0.65
(−10.59, 6.59)
FFM Long term 2 MD: −2.28 0 0.58 0.28
(−6.38, 1.82)
Short term 5 MD: 1.57 0 0.99 0.28
(−1.27, 4.41)
Long interval 6 MD: 0.48 0 0.74 0.7
(−2.01, 2.98)
Short interval 1 MD: −0.8 NA NA 0.81
(−7.41, 5.81)
LCD 6 MD: 0.16 0 0.77 0.9
(−2.24, 2.57)
Low-carbohydrate diet 1 MD: 3 NA NA 0.55
(−6.82, 12.82)
VO2peak Long term 3 SMD: 0.67 58 0.09 0.04
(0.03, 1.32)
Short term 4 SMD: 0.85 29 0.24 0.0006
(0.37, 1.34)
Long interval 5 SMD: 0.77 13 0.33 0.0001
(0.41, 1.13)
Short interval 2 SMD: 0.89 77 0.04 0.15
(−0.32, 2.09)
LCD 5 SMD: 0.77 13 0.33 0.0001
(0.41, 1.13)
Low-carbohydrate diet 2 SMD: 0.89 77 0.04 0.15
(−0.32, 2.09)
FPG Long term 3 SMD: −0.61 0 0.42 0.01
(−1.09, −0.13)
Short term 4 SMD: 0.22 0 0.84 0.22
(−0.19, 0.63)
Long interval 4 SMD: 0.22 0 0.84 0.22
(−0.19, 0.63)
Short interval 3 SMD: −0.61 0 0.42 0.01
(−1.09, −0.13)
LCD 4 SMD: 0.23 0 0.84 0.29
(−0.19, 0.65)
Low-carbohydrate diet 3 SMD: −0.58 4 0.35 0.02
(−1.06, −0.09)
FPI Long term 2 SMD: −0.05 0 0.97 0.87
(−0.67, 0.57)
Short term 4 SMD: 0.21 0 0.7 0.32
(−0.2, 0.62)
Long interval 4 SMD: 0.21 0 0.7 0.32
(−0.2, 0.62)
Short interval 2 SMD: −0.05 0 0.97 0.87
(−0.67, 0.57)
LCD 4 SMD: 0.17 0 0.64 0.43
(−0.25, 0.59)
Low-carbohydrate diet 2 SMD: 0.05 0 0.74 0.87
(−0.55, 0.65)