Table 1.
Characteristics of the included studies.
Study | Subjects | Task | Behavioral performance | EEG measures | Difference between athletes and controls |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Haufler et al. (2000),14 | Athletes: | Shooting task: 40 shootings. Comparative task: 15 trials of dot localization and word finding. | Experts indicated better shooting performance than novices. No significant difference was found in verbal and spatial tasks. | Theta Alpha Beta Gamma | Athletes showed lower cortical activation in shooting task than verbal and spatial tasks. Non-athletes indicated similar cortical activation in both tasks. |
N = 15 | |||||
Age = 26.5 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 21 | |||||
Age = 23.1 | |||||
Janelle et al. (2000),15 | Athletes: | Participants performed 40 shots in standing position. | Athletes indicated significantly better shooting performance than novices. | Alpha Beta | Athletes were characterized by increased hemispheric asymmetry in shooting. |
N = 12 | |||||
Age = 26.4 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 13 | |||||
Age = 24.6 | |||||
Del Percio et al. (2007),26 | Athletes: | Participants stood on a force platform with eyes closed and open. | No significant difference was identified between groups during standing. | Alpha | Athletes indicated stronger alpha ERD than non-athletes during postural control. |
N = 37 | |||||
Age: 19-32 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 10 | |||||
Age: 21-34 | |||||
Baumeister et al. (2008),19 | Athletes: | Participants performed 5 blocks of golf putting. Each block lasted 4 min. | Golfers performed with significantly higher accuracy than novices. | Theta Alpha | Golfers indicated higher theta and alpha powers than novices in golf putting. |
N = 9 | |||||
Age = 26.4 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 9 | |||||
Age = 24.6 | |||||
Doppelmayr et al. (2008),16 | Athletes: | Participants completed 50–70 shots in 60 min. | Experts indicated significantly better performance than novices. | Theta | Experts indicated a stronger theta activity than novices in preparation of shooting. |
N = 8 | |||||
Age = 21.4 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 10 | |||||
Age = 20.8 | |||||
Babiloni et al. (2009),37 | Athletes: | Participants judged rhythmic gymnastic performance presented in videos. | Rhythmic gymnasts indicated higher judgment accuracy than non-athletes. | Alpha | Rhythmic gymnasts indicated lower alpha ERD than non-athletes in judgment. |
N = 15 | |||||
Age = 21.4 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 13 | |||||
Age = 20.8 | |||||
Del Percio et al. (2009a),17 | Athletes: | Participants completed a total of 120 shots. | Elite athletes performed with significantly higher accuracy than novices. | Alpha | Elite athletes indicated lower alpha ERD than non-athletes over the whole scalp. |
N = 8 | |||||
Age = 29.2 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 10 | |||||
Age = 33.1 | |||||
Del Percio et al. (2009b),27 | Athletes: | Participants stood on a force platform with one foot and both feet. | No significant difference was identified between groups during standing. | Alpha | Athletes indicated lower alpha ERD than non-athletes during postural control. |
N = 20 | |||||
Age: 19-32 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 12 | |||||
Age: 21-34 | |||||
Babiloni et al. (2010),22 | Athletes: | Participants judged the expertise level of karate players according to the performance presented in videos. | Karate players indicated higher judgment accuracy than non-athletes. | Alpha | Karate players performed the task with lower alpha ERD than non-athletes. |
N = 17 | |||||
Age = 23.8 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 17 | |||||
Age = 24.6 | |||||
Del Percio et al. (2010),25 | Athletes: | Participants performed repeat wrist extension as fast as possible in 10 s. | Not reported | Alpha | Athletes indicated lower alpha ERD than non-athletes during postural control. |
N = 17 | |||||
Age = 23.8 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 17 | |||||
Age = 24.6 | |||||
Cooke et al. (2014),20 | Athletes: | Participants completed 2 blocks of 60 putts. | No significant difference was found between the two groups. | Theta Alpha Beta | Golfers indicated greater reduction in theta, alpha, and beta powers than novices in golf putting. |
N = 10 | |||||
Age = 20.9 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 10 | |||||
Age = 19.0 | |||||
Wolf et al. (2014),24 | Athletes: | Participants watched videos of a table tennis serve and imagined themselves responding with a specific stroke. | Not reported | Alpha | Alpha (8–10 Hz) ERD is stronger in elite table tennis players compared to amateurs at the<!--Soft-enter Run-on-- > motor cortex. |
N = 14 | |||||
Age = 20.9 | |||||
Amateurs: | |||||
N = 15 | |||||
Age = | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 15 | |||||
Age = 19.0 | |||||
Cooke et al. (2015),21 | Athletes: | Participants completed 120 golf putts. | Not reported | Alpha | Golfers indicated greater reduction in high alpha power after a missed putt than novices. |
N = 10 | |||||
Age = 20.9 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 10 | |||||
Age = 19.0 | |||||
Wang et al. (2015),28 | Athletes: | Participants conducted two cognitive tasks involving working memory and attention. | Badminton players showed similar response accuracy to non-athletes, but significantly faster response than non-athletes. | Theta Alpha Beta | Athletes showed significant increase in theta power and decrease in beta power, which contributed to enhanced working memory and attentional performance, respectively. |
N = 12 | |||||
Age = 20.6 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 13 | |||||
Age = 19.1 | |||||
Duru and Assem. (2018),29 | Athletes: | Participants performed 2 blocks of arithmetical tasks. | No significant difference was found between the groups. | Delta Theta Alpha Beta | Karate players indicated higher posterior alpha power than non-athletes. |
N = 10 | |||||
Age = 22.9 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 10 | |||||
Age = 22.9 | |||||
Del Percio et al. (2019),23 | Athletes: | Participants assessed the distance between football players presented in a video. | No significant difference was found between the groups. | Alpha | Football players indicated greater bilateral parietal alpha ERD than non-athletes during the cognitive task. |
N = 13 | |||||
Age = 25.1 | |||||
Controls: | |||||
N = 8 | |||||
Age = 25.6 |