Table 1. Studies’ descriptive characteristics.
| year | study | no | classification | age (y) | cause of injury | sex (m:f) | hand (d:nd) | follow-up (mo) | Type of functional evaluation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1979 | Pierce at al. | 18 | n/m | 36,7 | 13mva, 1fall, 7unknown | 13m, 8f | n/m | 63,6 (r, 8-120) | objective & functional evaluation |
| 1984 | Rogers et al. | 19 | Rogers classification | 31,0+/-10,87 | 10mva, 3industrila, 2fall,1gsw | 16m, 3f | n/m | 21,84+/-7,37 | ROM |
| 1985 | Lange et al. | 9 | n/m | 27,33+/-10,45 | 7mva, 2industrial | n/m | n/m | 22,33+/-19,03 | Lange & Foster classification, ROM |
| 1998 | Sohn et al. | 13 | n/m | 38,92+/-13,59 | 6mva, 4fall, 3industrial | 7m, 6f | n/m | 18,08+/-6,44 | ROM, Lange & Foster classification |
| 1998 | Yokoyama et al. | 15 | AO/OTA classification | 32,87+/-14,41 | 7mva, 2fall, 6industrial | 13m,2f | n/m | 45,67+/-31,73 | ROM, Khalfayan score |
| 2000 | Capomassi et al. | 10 | Capomassi classification | 27,4+/-15,85 | 6mva, 3industrial, 1fall | 9m, 1f | 7d, 7nd | 33,5 (r, 13-58) | Khalfayan score |
| 2000 | Lerner et al. | 6 | n/m | 30,17+/-16,4 | 4blast, 2gsw | 7m | n/m | n/m | ROM, Khalfayan score, grip strength |
| 2003 | Solomon et al. | 26 | AO/ASIF classification | 36,92+/-15,14 | n/m | 15m, 11f | n/m | 24,33+/-13/01 | ROM, Khalfayan score, grip strength |
| 2006 | Anomou et al. | 7 | Gleizes classification | 39,14 (r, 15-57) | 3mva, 3indutrial | 6m, 1f | n/m | 13,85 (r, 6-25) | Lange & Foster classification |
| 2007 | Stoik et al. | 7 | AO/ASIF classification | 52,86+/-30,60 | 5mva, 1blast, 1fall | 2m, 5f | n/m | 12 (r, 2-22) | ROM |
| 2012 | El Ibrahimi et al. | 12 | Agarwal and Chadha classification | 31,5+/-15,49 | 9fall, 3mva | 8m, 4f | n/m | n/m | Lange & Foster classification |
| 2013 | Lamah et al. | 8 | n/m | n/m | 8mva | 5m, 3f | 3d, 5nd | 10 (r, 6-18) | MEPS |
| 2013 | Jockel et al. | 19 | Jockel classification | 41,53+/-15,42 | n/m | 14m, 5f | 10d, 9nd | 80,46+/-38,45 | ROM, ASES, VAS |
| 2013 | Ditsios et al. | 19 | Ditsios classification | 33,68+/-9,05 | 15mva, 2industrial, 2fall | 16m, 3f | 17d, 2nd | 26 (r, 1-40) | ROM, MEPS, Khalfayan score, grip & elbow strength |
| 2015 | Cho et al. | 6 | n/m | 45,17+/-14,19 | 5roller, 1mva | 5m, 1f | 2d, 4nd | 37,00+/-32,96 | MEPS, ASES, VAS |
| 2016 | Jimenez-Diaz et al. | 23 | AO/OTA & Ditsios classifiaction | 35,87+/-13,18 | 16mva, 5fall, 1gsw, 1blast | 19m, 4f | 4d, 19nd | 19,53+/-11,05 | ROM, MEPS |
| 2018 | Trigui et al | 14 | Rogers classification | 32,07+/-11,52 | 11mva, 2industrial, 1fall | 11m, 3f | n/m | 21,79+/-14,33 | Stewart & Hundley classification modified by Diémé |
| 2018 | Langshong et al. | 10 | n/m | 37,80+/-14,93 | 6mva, 3fall, 1building collapse | 7m, 3f | 6d, 4nd | 5,15+/-0,58 | DASH score |
| 2020 | Marius et al. | 4 | n/m | 31 | 4xmva | 3m, 1f | 3d, 1nd | n/m | MEPS |
| 2019 | Pari et al. | 1 | n/m | 53 | fall | m | n/m | 24 | ROM |
| 2018 | Badia et al. | 1 | n/m | 30 | mva | m | yes | 48 | ROM |
| 2018 | Lee et al. | 1 | n/m | 21 | fall | f | n/m | 12 | ROM |
| 2017 | Ayoubi et al. | 1 | n/m | 24 | fall | m | n/m | 6 | ROM, MEPS |
| 2017 | Kafadar et al. | 1 | n/m | 52 | industrial | m | n/m | 6 | ROM |
| 2015 | Bettuzzi et al. | 1 | n/m | 42 | fall | m | n/m | 12 | ROM, MEPS |
| 2015 | Goni et al. | 1 | n/m | 44 | mva | f | n/m | 24 | ROM |
| 2015 | Bisinella et al. | 1 | AO/OTA classification | 22 | mva | m | n/m | 8 | ROM |
| 2011 | Galasso et al. | 1 | Rogers & Simpson classification | 28 | mva | m | n/m | 18 | ROM, grip strength, LES |
| 2006 | De Carli et al. | 1 | Rogers & Simpson classification | 25 | mva | f | n/m | 24 | ROM |
| 1997 | Sarup et al. | 1 | n/m | 35 | fall | f | n/m | 5 | ROM |
| 1995 | Al-Zahrani et al. | 1 | n/m | 45 | mva | f | n/m | 18 | ROM |
| 1989 | Viegas et al. | 1 | n/m | 59 | industrial | m | n/m | 2 | ROM |
n/m=not mentioned; AO/OTA= Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Osteosynthesefragen/Orthopaedic Trauma Association; AO/ASIF= Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Osteosynthesefragen/Association of the Study of Internal Fixation; mva=motor vehicle accident; gsw=gunshot wound; m=male; f=female; ROM=range of motion; MEPS= Mayo Elbow Performance Score; ASES=American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons Shoulder Score; VAS= Visual Analog Score; DASH= Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand; LES= Liverpool elbow Score