Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Apr 25.
Published in final edited form as: Health Aff (Millwood). 2021 Jul;40(7):1090–1098. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2021.00059

EXHIBIT 2.

Characteristics and service use of immigrant essential workers and their household members who were at risk for immigration sanctions because of the public charge rule change, 2019

Immigrant essential workers at risk
Household members
of essential workers
at risk
Total at risk
(workers +
household
members)
Noncitizens Citizens in
mixed-status
households
Total workers at risk
Weighted no. Weighted no. Weighted no. Percent Weighted no. Percent Weighted no.
Nationwide total 9,848,137 2,411,052 12,259,189 100.0 18,923,868 100.0 31,183,057
Age, years
 <18 a a a a 9,154,015 48.4 9,154,015
 18–64 9,520,184 2,239,242 11,759,426 95.9 8,705,703 46.0 20,465,129
 65+ 327,953 171,810 499,763 4.1 1,064,150 5.6 1,563,913
Sex
 Male 5,609,095 1,290,516 6,899,611 56.3 9,115,333 48.2 16,014,944
 Female 4,239,042 1,120,536 5,359,578 43.7 9,808,535 51.8 15,168,113
Race/ethnicity
 Asian/Pacific Islander 2,055,757 686,651 2,742,408 22.4 3,180,089 16.8 5,922,497
 Black/African American 737,228 350,773 1,088,001 8.9 1,464,444 7.7 2,552,445
 Hispanic 5,911,823 1,141,337 7,053,160 57.5 11,630,574 61.5 18,683,734
 White 991,102 192,084 1,183,186 9.7 2,196,394 11.6 3,379,580
 Other raceb 152,227 40,207 192,434 1.6 452,367 2.4 644,801
Insurance
 Medicaid 1,219,517 357,020 1,576,537 12.9 6,753,406 35.7 8,329,943
 Medicare 290,574 165,021 455,595 3.7 1,099,429 5.8 1,555,024
 Private 4,992,263 1,540,547 6,532,810 53.3 7,546,073 39.9 14,078,883
 VHA (or other public) 4,430 3,277 7,707 0.1 14,232 0.1 21,939
 Uninsuredc 3,341,353 345,187 3,686,540 30.1 3,510,728 18.6 7,197,268
SNAP recipient 1,253,255 316,563 1,569,818 12.8 3,533,571 18.7 5,103,389
Welfare recipientd 70,494 18,300 88,794 0.7 127,843 1.1 216,637
Primary language at home
 English 1,006,122 254,981 1,261,103 10.3 3,116,888 19.1 4,377,991
 Spanish 5,736,970 1,109,220 6,846,190 55.8 9,425,315 57.7 16,271,505
 Other 3,105,045 1,046,851 4,151,896 33.9 3,802,336 23.3 7,954,232
Family income as percent of federal poverty level
 <201% 3,659,852 603,305 4,263,157 35.1 8,294,095 43.9 12,557,252
 201–400% 3,431,065 953,313 4,384,378 36.1 6,283,152 33.3 10,667,530
 >400% 2,654,911 854,434 3,509,345 28.9 4,307,853 22.8 7,817,198
Citizenship status
 US born a a a a 11,629,850 61.5 11,629,850
 Naturalized citizen a 2,411,052 2,411,052 19.7 1,585,368 8.4 3,996,420
 Noncitizen 9,848,137 a 9,848,137 80.3 5,706,063 30.2 15,554,200

SOURCE Authors’ analysis of data from the 2019 American Community Survey. NOTES Household members of essential workers at risk include any person living in a household with a noncitizen essential worker or in a household with a naturalized citizen essential worker and at least one noncitizen. Column excludes these essential workers to avoid double counting. Immigrant essential workers are noncitizens and naturalized US citizens employed in essentialjobs. Mixed-status households are those with a naturalized citizen essential worker and at least one noncitizen. Unweighted sample sizes: Noncitizens, 71,483; citizens in mixed-status households, 19,492; total workers at risk, 90,975; household members, 137,686; and total at risk, 228,661. SNAP is Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program. VHA is Veterans Health Administration.

a

Not applicable.

b

Includes Native American/Alaska Native, more than one race, and “other” identified races.

c

Includes people covered only by the Indian Health Service.

d

Asked only for people ages 15 and older.