Skip to main content
. 2022 Apr 25;12(4):e054678. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-054678

Table 3.

Spring transition, disaggregate spatial and temporal models: RDD results summary

Location Band Time period All casualties Fatalities
BW n Ybefore Yafter τSRD % Change BW n Ybefore Yafter τSRD % Change
Aggregate 1 22 27 145 1260 1507 −0.110 (0.024)*** −0.12 40 12 744 133 81 −0.067 (0.022)** −0.70
4 38 43 472 6565 6597 −0.059 (0.020)** −0.01
5 46 48 906 6918 4456 −0.130 (0.025)*** −0.03
Northing band 1000–2000 1 28 9925 474 591 −0.095 (0.034)** −0.28
3 36 15 992 3880 3623 −0.162 (0.042)*** −0.06
4 38 16 008 2350 2343 −0.067 (0.029)* −0.04
5 48 17 991 2606 1610 −0.146 (0.041)*** −0.08
2000–3000 3 74 19 698 3182 3346 −0.137 (0.047)** −0.06
3000–4000 1 34 8365 315 340 −0.075 (0.035)* −0.33 44 2648 25 19 −0.046 (0.021)* −2.58
3 64 14 496 3197 3044 −0.167 (0.063)** −0.07
5 52 13 233 1342 1073 −0.086 (0.042)* −0.09
Easting band 3000–4000 1 28 8370 324 311 −0.148 (0.056)** −0.64 62 4510 67 34 −0.139 (0.055)* −2.89
4000–5000 1 30 11 814 522 479 −0.069 (0.030)* −0.18
3 74 28 000 6172 6235 −0.171 (0.049)*** −0.04
5 50 20 000 2244 1874 −0.083 (0.038)* −0.05
5000–6000 1 28 8530 428 559 −0.104 (0.039)** −0.34
3 70 24 066 5588 5651 −0.090 (0.037)* −0.02
4 26 8565 1479 848 −0.110 (0.045)* −0.10
5 44 15 453 2235 1388 −0.149 (0.045)*** −0.09

Significance notation: p values 0, ‘***’; 0.001, ‘**’; 0.01, ‘*’; 0.05, ‘.’; 0.1, ‘1’.

SEs in parentheses.

Time periods are as follows: 1, overnight; 2, AM peak; 3, interpeak; 4, PM peak; 5, night.

BW, bandwidth; n, total number of observations; RDD, regression discontinuity design; Yafter, total number of casualties or fatalities after the cut-off; Ybefore, total number of casualties or fatalities before the cut-off; τSRD, sharp RDD average treatment effect due to daylight savings time transition.