Table 2.
A comparison study between the proposed MTM sensor and others was reported in the literature.
References | Material sensing | Operating frequency (GHz) | Dielectric constant (DK) value | Shift of (MHz) | Amplitude change of (dB) | Q-factor | FOM |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
20 | Transformer oil | 2–6 | 2.7 for clean and 2.9 for waste transformer oil | 40 | − 1.5 | 60 | 34 |
23 | Oil | 1–8 | 2.74 for clean oil and 2.87 for waste oil | 63 | − 0.9 | 90 | 32 |
27 | Diesel | 8–12 | 2.72 for branded diesel and 2.48 for unbranded diesel | 60 | − 2.5 | 110 | 37 |
28 | Diesel | 8–12 | 2.73 for branded and 2.47 for unbranded diesel | 120 | − 3.2 | 105 | 41 |
36 | Transformer oil | 8–12 | 2.8 for clean and 2.7 for waste transformer oil | 70 | − 4.5 | 100 | 48 |
Oil | 8–12 | 2.78 for olive oil and 2.6 for corn oil | 50 | − 0.8 | |||
37 | Diesel | 10–12 | 2.07 for branded and 2.68 for unbranded diesel | 72 | − 4 | 90 | 52 |
Gasoline | 10–11 | 2.43 for branded and 2.52 for unbranded gasoline | 12 | − 6 | |||
38 | Diesel | 8–12 | 2.08 for pure and 2.7 for adulterated diesel | 100 | − 10 | 95 | 38 |
44 | Gasoline | 8–12 | 2.43 for branded and 2.51 for unbranded gasoline | 28 | − 8 | 105 | 43 |
Diesel | 8–12 | 2.07 for branded and 2.68 for unbranded diesel | 92 | − 20 | |||
47 | Transformer oil | 8–12 | 2.9 for clean and 2.7 for waste transformer oil | 70 | − 3.7 | 75 | 36 |
Lubricant | 8–12 | 2.5 for clean and 2.3 for waste lubricant | 60 | − 4.1 | |||
Proposed work | Olive and corn oils | 8–12 | 2.56 for olive oil and 3.07 for corn oil | 100 | − 10.74 | 135 | 76 |
Sunflower oil and palm oil | 8–12 | 2.93 for sunflower oil and 2.81 for palm oil | 80 | − 5.99 | |||
Clean and waste brake oil | 8–12 | 2.78 for clean and 2.69 for wase brake oil | 70 | − 3.97 | |||
Benzene and carbon-tetrachloride | 8–12 | 2.55 for benzene and 2.51 for carbon-tetrachloride | 90 | − 3.62 |