Table 5.
Quality assessment checklist.
Criteria | Additional description for clarity when needed |
---|---|
1. Clear objectives and methodology of proposed study | |
2. Masked assessment of outcome (analysis blinded) | |
3. Details of formulation, dosage, and route of vaccine being administered | |
4. Negative immunization controls included | |
5. Positive immunization controls included | |
6. Timing of specimen collection stated | Did the study describe the schedule of blood and/or organ collection? |
7. Duration of the study stated | Did the study explicitly state the period of observation or indicate the sacrifice of the study animals? |
8. Toxicity evaluation of the vaccination | Did the study evaluate the safety of the vaccine tested in the study animals? |
9. Sample size calculation or N=5/group | |
10. Retrievable neutralization assay data | |
11. Titer/infectivity information for virus used for neutralization provided | Did the study provide any infectivity information of the EBV batch used for in vitro neutralization assays or for in vivo challenge experiments? |
12. Neutralization concentrations/dilutions provided | Did the study provide information regarding serum/plasma/antibody concentration or dilution used in neutralization assays? |
13. Neutralization timepoint provided | Did the study indicate the timepoint of antibody/serum/plasma sample(s) used in reference to the study schedule? |
14. Statistical analysis performed | |
15. Statistical analysis methods provided | |
16. Statement of compliance with regulatory requirements | |
17. Statement regarding possible conflict of interest | |
18. Publication in a peer-reviewed journal |