TABLE 1.
Summary table of the respective advantages of imaging and microscopy for different applications requiring taxonomic identification of phytoplankton.
| APPLICATION |
|||
| Species Identification Training | HAB Tracking and Monitoring | Phytoplankton Ecology | |
| IMAGING | • Speeds up the training process. • Trainees can work with samples non-destructively. • Trainees can be tasked with identification of a subset of species of interest. • Trainers and trainees can interact and work remotely and asynchronously. |
• Higher frequency of sampling in time and space is possible. • Enables inter-calibration between regional and global laboratories. • Allows rapid counts of a small suite of target species without losing information on other species present. • Allows for real time results to inform regulatory actions even if field staff or citizen scientists are not trained taxonomic analysts (i.e., through automated classification of images). |
• Can generate large image libraries which enables regional and global inter-comparisons. • Images can be archived for re-examination and analysis at a later date. • Allows for easier estimation of cell size and biovolume, useful for model validation and comparison. • Images cells from multiple orientations allowing more accurate estimates of biovolume. |
| MICROSCOPY | • Allows for better optical resolution and precise focus to investigate morphological features of a cell that occur on different focal planes. • Allows for the use of specialized methods, such as fluorescent dyes to facilitate identification based on specific morphological features. |
• Allows for detection of emerging HAB taxa that may be unexpected in the area or not previously detected. • Allows for better optical resolution and precise focus to investigate different focal planes. • Allows for the use of specialized methods, such as fluorescent dyes. |
• Allows for more reliable enumeration of rare species as sample volumes may be larger. • Allows for finer distinction between similarly structured species. • Allows for better resolution of small celled taxa (<5 μm) that are mostly missed by imaging instruments. |