Skip to main content
. 2022 Apr 29;122:95–103. doi: 10.1016/j.tranpol.2022.04.016

Table 2.

Between-within model for all periods and different stages.

Model 1: All periods
Model 2: Stage 2- Stage 4
Model 3: Stage 5- Stage 6
Model 4: After Stage 6
Estimate Std Error Estimate Std Error Estimate Std Error Estimate Std Error
Temporal effects (within-effects)
COVID14 −0.146*** −0.017 −0.277*** −0.036 −0.260*** −0.028 −0.061*** −0.014
D_COVID14 −0.127*** −0.027 −0.131** −0.064 −0.973*** −0.049 −0.449*** −0.038
Level1 −0.803*** −0.026 −0.418*** −0.037
Level2 −0.587*** −0.027 0.463*** −0.033 0.075** −0.035
Level3 −0.857*** −0.025 0.590*** −0.041 0.125*** −0.037
Lockdown −3.627*** −0.102 −4.504*** −0.197 −2.457*** −0.073
FreerefundFeb11 −0.605*** −0.011 −1.771*** −0.026
Spatial effects (between-effects)
COVID19 1.467** −0.726 2.492*** −0.627 −0.199 −0.494 0.209 −0.499
D_COVID19 −2.715*** −1.015 −5.459** −2.372 −1.592 −1.246 −1.733*** −0.661
Level1 −16.227 −12.304 −8.031*** −2.873
Level2 −15.571 −12.275 1.375*** −0.481 0.413 −0.468
Level3 −15.584 −12.341 1.399*** −0.441 0.358 −0.413
Lockdown −3.032*** −1.007 −4.164*** −0.526 −1.904 −1.839
FreerefundFeb11
Time-invariant variables
LnPop 0.618*** −0.136 0.558*** −0.119 1.019*** −0.185 0.688*** −0.129
LnGDPpercap 1.192*** −0.162 1.099*** −0.148 1.201*** −0.217 1.246*** −0.17
HubTop10 1.125*** −0.412 1.346*** −0.357 1.525*** −0.558 1.372*** −0.462
Lnalpha −1.242*** −0.015 −1.198*** −0.026 −1.853*** −0.038 −3.676*** −0.042
Constant 13.17 −11.617 7.395*** −2.704 −5.681*** −1.472 −3.337*** −0.952
Observations 16,731 4901 3887 7943
Number of groups 169 169 169 169

Note: ***p < 0.01, **p < 0.05, *p < 0.1.