Skip to main content
. 2022 Apr 29;81(27):39577–39603. doi: 10.1007/s11042-022-12192-9

Table 2.

Performance verification of the proposed scheme for different number of color watermark insertion with watermark image size of 32 × 32

No. of Watermarks Parameter Img1 Img2 Img3 Img4 Img5 Img6 Img7 Img8 Img9 Img10
24 NC 0.997941 0.997928 0.997851 0.997923 0.997842 0.997857 0.99787 0.99781 0.99789 0.99791
Q 0.998690 0.998844 0.998621 0.998721 0.998857 0.998798 0.99879 0.99876 0.99882 0.99864
PSNR 45.98547 45.98451 45.98143 45.97991 45.98149 45.97995 45.98342 45.97362 45.97856 45.98149
SNR 36.1479 35.99848 35.98551 36.41674 35.95718 36.43421 35.97845 35.98551 36.31628 35.96485
16 NC 0.998021 0.998752 0.998864 0.998064 0.998954 0.998038 0.99832 0.99828 0.99841 0.99865
Q 0.999047 0.999159 0.999138 0.999058 0.999178 0.999177 0.99923 0.99919 0.99921 0.99915
PSNR 47.75425 47.65251 47.74841 47.86587 47.45854 47.54789 47.66431 47.64876 47.86752 47.57431
SNR 37.71864 38.16217 37.94785 37.87554 38.08713 37.97098 38.26235 37.94785 37.76526 38.29564
12 NC 0.998123 0.998764 0.998897 0.998342 0.998970 0.998351 0.99854 0.99849 0.99866 0.99875
Q 0.999221 0.999319 0.999398 0.999433 0.999598 0.999391 0.99953 0.99949 0.99956 0.99932
PSNR 48.83774 48.91647 48.89631 48.86657 48.97125 48.88963 48.45291 48.89872 48.96657 48.98325
SNR 38.92147 39.75821 38.96587 38.95487 39.87417 38.97546 39.65832 38.96587 38.85349 39.94426
8 NC 0.998467 0.998841 0.998943 0.998687 0.999012 0.998558 0.99879 0.99876 0.99883 0.99886
Q 0.999358 0.999469 0.999447 0.999685 0.999686 0.999562 0.99981 0.99974 0.99986 0.99941
PSNR 49.84613 49.92547 49.99647 49.97584 49.99527 49.97657 49.93657 49.89773 49.87685 49.99876
SNR 40.06542 39.95462 40.03982 40.07589 40.64187 40.95647 39.87652 40.03982 40.12495 40.59874
6 NC 0.998765 0.998976 0.999011 0.998982 0.999238 0.998908 0.99897 0.99895 0.99898 0.99899
Q 0.999498 0.999573 0.999561 0.999812 0.999801 0.999791 0.99985 0.99982 0.99989 0.99977
PSNR 50.97882 51.03091 51.14586 51.07362 51.08758 51.07421 51.02159 51.24685 51.27451 51.15473
SNR 41.07548 40.99854 41.04844 41.09532 41.75249 41.96214 40.97623 41.04844 41.29492 41.79526
4 NC 0.999036 0.999114 0.999719 0.999125 0.999421 0.999125 0.99909 0.99902 0.99923 0.99935
Q 0.999534 0.999628 0.999712 0.999948 0.999972 0.999969 0.99997 0.99995 0.99996 0.99991
PSNR 53.18975 53.40738 53.67553 53.58336 53.65627 53.59902 53.20743 53.57687 53.48643 53.75624
SNR 43.12137 42.91684 43.09791 43.41576 43.89273 43.99755 42.90845 43.09791 43.31486 43.95423
2 NC 0.999798 0.999813 0.999892 0.999445 0.999681 0.999485 0.99944 0.99939 0.99962 0.99973
Q 0.999983 0.999976 0.999969 0.999945 0.999981 0.999980 0.99998 0.99997 0.99998 0.99997
PSNR 56.76161 56.92657 57.27539 57.06924 56.82357 56.98985 56.95649 57.27628 57.15844 56.92342
SNR 46.78156 45.83358 45.99845 46.65178 47.05498 46.72421 45.75346 45.88567 46.51843 46.98743