Table 2.
Performance verification of the proposed scheme for different number of color watermark insertion with watermark image size of 32 × 32
| No. of Watermarks | Parameter | Img1 | Img2 | Img3 | Img4 | Img5 | Img6 | Img7 | Img8 | Img9 | Img10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24 | NC | 0.997941 | 0.997928 | 0.997851 | 0.997923 | 0.997842 | 0.997857 | 0.99787 | 0.99781 | 0.99789 | 0.99791 |
| Q | 0.998690 | 0.998844 | 0.998621 | 0.998721 | 0.998857 | 0.998798 | 0.99879 | 0.99876 | 0.99882 | 0.99864 | |
| PSNR | 45.98547 | 45.98451 | 45.98143 | 45.97991 | 45.98149 | 45.97995 | 45.98342 | 45.97362 | 45.97856 | 45.98149 | |
| SNR | 36.1479 | 35.99848 | 35.98551 | 36.41674 | 35.95718 | 36.43421 | 35.97845 | 35.98551 | 36.31628 | 35.96485 | |
| 16 | NC | 0.998021 | 0.998752 | 0.998864 | 0.998064 | 0.998954 | 0.998038 | 0.99832 | 0.99828 | 0.99841 | 0.99865 |
| Q | 0.999047 | 0.999159 | 0.999138 | 0.999058 | 0.999178 | 0.999177 | 0.99923 | 0.99919 | 0.99921 | 0.99915 | |
| PSNR | 47.75425 | 47.65251 | 47.74841 | 47.86587 | 47.45854 | 47.54789 | 47.66431 | 47.64876 | 47.86752 | 47.57431 | |
| SNR | 37.71864 | 38.16217 | 37.94785 | 37.87554 | 38.08713 | 37.97098 | 38.26235 | 37.94785 | 37.76526 | 38.29564 | |
| 12 | NC | 0.998123 | 0.998764 | 0.998897 | 0.998342 | 0.998970 | 0.998351 | 0.99854 | 0.99849 | 0.99866 | 0.99875 |
| Q | 0.999221 | 0.999319 | 0.999398 | 0.999433 | 0.999598 | 0.999391 | 0.99953 | 0.99949 | 0.99956 | 0.99932 | |
| PSNR | 48.83774 | 48.91647 | 48.89631 | 48.86657 | 48.97125 | 48.88963 | 48.45291 | 48.89872 | 48.96657 | 48.98325 | |
| SNR | 38.92147 | 39.75821 | 38.96587 | 38.95487 | 39.87417 | 38.97546 | 39.65832 | 38.96587 | 38.85349 | 39.94426 | |
| 8 | NC | 0.998467 | 0.998841 | 0.998943 | 0.998687 | 0.999012 | 0.998558 | 0.99879 | 0.99876 | 0.99883 | 0.99886 |
| Q | 0.999358 | 0.999469 | 0.999447 | 0.999685 | 0.999686 | 0.999562 | 0.99981 | 0.99974 | 0.99986 | 0.99941 | |
| PSNR | 49.84613 | 49.92547 | 49.99647 | 49.97584 | 49.99527 | 49.97657 | 49.93657 | 49.89773 | 49.87685 | 49.99876 | |
| SNR | 40.06542 | 39.95462 | 40.03982 | 40.07589 | 40.64187 | 40.95647 | 39.87652 | 40.03982 | 40.12495 | 40.59874 | |
| 6 | NC | 0.998765 | 0.998976 | 0.999011 | 0.998982 | 0.999238 | 0.998908 | 0.99897 | 0.99895 | 0.99898 | 0.99899 |
| Q | 0.999498 | 0.999573 | 0.999561 | 0.999812 | 0.999801 | 0.999791 | 0.99985 | 0.99982 | 0.99989 | 0.99977 | |
| PSNR | 50.97882 | 51.03091 | 51.14586 | 51.07362 | 51.08758 | 51.07421 | 51.02159 | 51.24685 | 51.27451 | 51.15473 | |
| SNR | 41.07548 | 40.99854 | 41.04844 | 41.09532 | 41.75249 | 41.96214 | 40.97623 | 41.04844 | 41.29492 | 41.79526 | |
| 4 | NC | 0.999036 | 0.999114 | 0.999719 | 0.999125 | 0.999421 | 0.999125 | 0.99909 | 0.99902 | 0.99923 | 0.99935 |
| Q | 0.999534 | 0.999628 | 0.999712 | 0.999948 | 0.999972 | 0.999969 | 0.99997 | 0.99995 | 0.99996 | 0.99991 | |
| PSNR | 53.18975 | 53.40738 | 53.67553 | 53.58336 | 53.65627 | 53.59902 | 53.20743 | 53.57687 | 53.48643 | 53.75624 | |
| SNR | 43.12137 | 42.91684 | 43.09791 | 43.41576 | 43.89273 | 43.99755 | 42.90845 | 43.09791 | 43.31486 | 43.95423 | |
| 2 | NC | 0.999798 | 0.999813 | 0.999892 | 0.999445 | 0.999681 | 0.999485 | 0.99944 | 0.99939 | 0.99962 | 0.99973 |
| Q | 0.999983 | 0.999976 | 0.999969 | 0.999945 | 0.999981 | 0.999980 | 0.99998 | 0.99997 | 0.99998 | 0.99997 | |
| PSNR | 56.76161 | 56.92657 | 57.27539 | 57.06924 | 56.82357 | 56.98985 | 56.95649 | 57.27628 | 57.15844 | 56.92342 | |
| SNR | 46.78156 | 45.83358 | 45.99845 | 46.65178 | 47.05498 | 46.72421 | 45.75346 | 45.88567 | 46.51843 | 46.98743 |