Skip to main content
. 2022 May 3;17:102. doi: 10.1186/s13019-022-01859-x

Table 1.

Characteristics of studies included in meta-analysis

Studies Year Design Blind Sample size M/B Reference standard PET/CT Tumor markers
Cao [11] 2021 Retrospective Unclear 80 55/25 S No Yes
Chen [12] 2020 Retrospective Unclear 216 160/56 S No No
Chen [13] 2016 Retrospective Unclear 289 207/82 S No No
Chen [14] 2013 Retrospective Unclear 109 67/42 S, B Yes No
Cheng [15] 2019 Retrospective Unclear 362 291/71 S, B Yes No
Dong [16] 2014 Retrospective Unclear 1679 1296/383 S, B No Yes
Hu [17] 2016 Retrospective Yes 112 82/30 S No No
Lin [18] 2015 Retrospective Yes 186 123/63 S, B Yes No
Ma [19] 2020 Retrospective Unclear 161 131/30 S, B Yes No
Tian [20] 2012 Retrospective Unclear 105 61/44 S, B Yes No
Wang [21] 2018 Retrospective Yes 268 156/112 S No No
Xiang [22] 2016 Retrospective Yes 110 80/30 S Yes Yes
Xiao [23] 2019 Retrospective Unclear 242 209/33 S, B No Yes
Xu [24] 2020 Retrospective Unclear 160 122/38 S Yes Yes
Yang [25] 2012 Retrospective Unclear 145 98/47 S No No
Yu [26] 2016 Retrospective Unclear 139 73/66 S No No
Zhang [27] 2015 Retrospective Unclear 120 72/48 S, B No Yes
Zhang [28] 2016 Retrospective Unclear 270 110/160 S No No
Zhao [29] 2021 Retrospective Yes 250 156/94 S, B No Yes
Zhong [30] 2017 Retrospective Unclear 168 113/55 S, B No No

M: malignant; B: benign; S: surgery; B: biopsy; PET/CT: positron emission tomography/computed tomography