Table 3.
Geographic distribution and prevalence of P. ovale sp., P. ovale wallikeri and P. ovale curtisi (Sequences submitted to GenBank as P. ovale were assigned to species level post hoc)
| Country | Type | Diagnostic Technique | Prevalence | References | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Afghanistan | P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to Switzerland | Nguyen et al. 2020 | [162] |
| Angola | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: FJ409571; FJ409567 | Duval et al. 2009 | [163] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: MG588149; imported to China | Zhou et al. Unpublished | – | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 0.3% (11/3316) 3 mono + 8 mixed; 2% (11/541) malaria positives | Fançony et al. 2013 | [36] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 0.3% (11/3316) 4 mono + 7 mixed; 2% (11/541) malaria positives | Fançony et al. 2013 | [36] | |
| Bangladesh | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | 0.26% (1/379) symptomatic; 0.45% (10/1867) incl. asymptomatic participants; Mono—36.4% | Fuehrer et al. 2012 | [161] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | 0.79% (3/379) symptomatic; 0.53% (12/1867) incl. asymptomatic participants; Mono—46.1% | Fuehrer et al. 2012 | [161] | |
| Benin | P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: GQ183063; EU266604 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 1 isolate in meta-analysis | Bauffe et al. 2012 | [164] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 2 isolates in meta-analysis | Bauffe et al. 2012 | [164] | |
| Botswana | P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 1.85% (30/1614); 11 mono and 19 mixed | Motshoge et al. 2021 | [165] |
| Brunei | P. ovale sp. | 1 case imported to China | Cao et al. 2016 | [90] | |
| Burkina Faso | P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 3 isolates | Calderaro et al. 2012 | [166] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to Germany | Frickmann et al. 2019 | [167] | |
| Burma/Myanmar | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Various: e.g. KX672039; AB182496 | Win et al. 2004; Li et al. 2016 | [48, 156] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | Various: e.g. AB182497 | Win et al. 2004 | [48] | |
| Burundi | P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 1 isolate, imported to UK | Nolder et al. 2013 | [168] |
| Cambodia | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g. FJ409571 | Duval et al. 2009 | [163] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | Incardona et al. 2005 | [169] | ||
| Cameroon | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Imported to Singapore; GenBank: e.g. KP050401 | Chavatte et al. 2015 | [170] |
| P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Kojom Foko et al. 2021 | [171] | ||
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g. FJ409566 | Duval et al. 2009 | [56] | |
| Central African Republic | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Various GenBank: e.g. FJ409571; KP050465 | Duval et al. 2009; Chavatte et al. 2015 | [163, 170] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | 1.1% (1/95) asymptomatics; 4.3% (1/23) of malaria positives; GenBank: MG241227 | Mapua et al. 2018 | [58] | |
| Chad | P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 1 isolate in meta-analysis | Bauffe et al. 2012 | [164] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 1 isolate in meta-analysis | Bauffe et al. 2012 | [164] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to China | Zhou et al. 2019 | [172] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to China | Zhou et al. 2019 | [172] | |
| China (Yunnan) | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: KX672045; certified malaria free since 2021 | Li et al. 2016 | [48] |
| Comoros | P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 7 isolates | Bauffe et al. 2012 | [164] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 11 isolates | Bauffe et al. 2012 | [164] | |
| Congo DRC | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g. FJ409567 | Duval et al. 2009 | [163] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | 1% (2/198) children < 5 years; GenBank: KT867772 | Gabrielli et al. 2016 | [173] | |
| Congo Republic of the | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Imported to China; GenBank: MT430962 | Chen et al. 2020 | [174] |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 4 clinical cases | Oguike et al. 2011 | [175] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 2 clinical cases | Oguike et al. 2011 | [175] | |
| Cote d’Ivoire | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g. FJ409567; KP050411 | Duval et al. 2009; Chavatte et al. 2015 | [163, 170] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g. GU723538 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] | |
| Djibouti | P. ovale sp. | Rarely, 1 case in 2018/19 season | de Santi et al. 2021 | [176] | |
| East Timor (Timor-Leste) | P. ovale sp. |
Present according to WHO; Documented in West Timor |
Gundelfinger 1975 | [177] | |
| Equatorial Guinea | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: JF505386 | Unpublished | – |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KP050469 | Chavatte et al. 2015 | [170] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Bioko Island—0.9–1.4% ovale in total population | Oguike et al. 2011 | [175] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Bioko Island—0.9–1.4% ovale in total population | Oguike et al. 2011 | [175] | |
| Eritrea | P. ovale sp. | 1 case—imported to Germany | Roggelin et al. 2016 | [178] | |
| P. ovale sp. | 2.7% (4/146)—imported to Europe | Schlagenhauf et al. 2018 | [72] | ||
| Ethiopia | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | 0.7% (2/300) of symptomatic patients; 1.1% (2/184) of malaria positives, GenBank: e.g. KF536874 | Alemu et al. 2013 | [179] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | 2.3% (7/300) of symptomatic patients; 3.8% (7/184) of malaria positives, GenBank: e.g. KF536876 | Alemu et al. 2013 | [179] | |
| Gabon | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: FJ409571; MG869603 | Duval et al. 2009; Groger et al. 2019 | [163, 180] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KJ170104; MG869598 | Groger et al. 2019 | [180] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Rural Gabon—8.9% of malaria positives; 7 of 74 mono infection | Woldearegai et al. 2019 | [76] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Rural Gabon—4.6% of malaria positives; 1 of 38 mono infection | Woldearegai et al. 2019 | [76] | |
| Gambia, The | P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 0.16% (1/604) pregnant | Williams et al. 2016 | [44] |
| Ghana | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723554 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KP725067 | Oguike and Sutherland 2015 | [181] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Ashanti Region, 4% (15/284) malaria positives | Heinemann et al. 2020 | [182] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Ashanti Region, 3% (12/284) malaria positives | Heinemann et al. 2020 | [182] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 27 cases—Children 5–17 | Dinko et al. 2013 | [27] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 7 cases—Children 5–17 | Dinko et al. 2013 | [27] | |
| Guinea | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: FJ409571 | Duval et al. 2009 | [181] |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to China and France | Zhou et al. 2018; Joste et al. 2021 | [183, 184] | |
| Guinea-Bissau | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: EU266611 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Saralamba et al. 2019 | [185] | ||
| India | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KU510234; KP050460 | Chavatte et al. 2015; Krishna et al. 2017 | [170, 186] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | Mono infection, Bastar division of Chhattisgarh state, GenBank: KM873370 | Chaturvedi et al. 2015 | [83] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Mono infection, Bastar division of Chhattisgarh state, GenBank: KM288710 | Chaturvedi et al. 2015 | [83] | |
| Indonesia | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Sumatra,—GenBank: e.g.: KP050463 | Chavatte et al. 2015 | [170] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: AB182497 | Win et al. 2004 | [167] | |
| Kenya | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KM494987 | Miller et al. 2015 | [186] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KM494986 | Miller et al. 2015 | [186] | |
| Laos | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Toma et al. 1999 | [188] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | Toma et al. 1999 | [188] | ||
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 0.04% (1/2409) participants | Iwagami et al. 2018 | [189] | |
| Liberia | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KP050457 | Chavatte et al. 2015 | [170] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KP050382 | Chavatte et al. 2015 | [170] | |
| Madagascar | P. ovale curtisi | Randriamiarinjatovo 2015 | [190] | ||
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: FJ409570 | Duval et al. 2009 | [163] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 1.4% (8/559) of malaria positives; 2 mono infections | Mehlotra et al. 2019 | [91] | |
| Malawi | P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 2 isolates | Oguike and Sutherland 2015 | [181] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 2 isolates | Oguike and Sutherland 2015 | [181] | |
| Malaysia | P. ovale sp. (P. ovale curtisi) | PCR | 0.17% (1/585) asymptomatic; 5.3% (1/19) of malaria positives; primers rOVA1/rOVA2 | Noordin et al. 2020 | [191] |
| P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | Pahang; GenBank: MK351321 | unpublished | – | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 0.4% (2/457) malaria positives | Yusof et al. 2014 | [192] | |
| Mali | P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g. FJ409566 | Duval et al. 2009 | [163] |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 0.49% (3/603) in pregnant women; 1 mono + 2 mixed | Williams et al. 2016 | [44] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 0.49% (3/603) in pregnant women; 3 mixed | Williams et al. 2016 | [44] | |
| Mauritania | P. ovale sp. | Microscopy | Asymptomatic; Sahelian zone 0.47% (5/1056); Saharan zone 0.18% (2/1059); Sahelo-Saharan zone 0.37% (5/1330) | Ouldabdallahi Moukah et al. 2016 | [97] |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| Mayotte | P. ovale sp. | Regional Health Agency | 0.4% of malaria cases | Maillard et al. 2015 | [99] |
| Mozambique | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g. GU723517 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to China | Cao et al. 2016 | [90] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to France and Spain |
Rojo-Marcos et al. 2014, Joste et al. 2021 |
[183, 193] | |
| Namibia | P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 0.31% (of 952) children < 9 years | Haiyambo et al. 2019 | [194] |
| Niger | P. ovale sp. | Microscopy | 1 case | Doudou et al. 2012 | [102] |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| Nigeria | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723534; KP050374 |
Sutherland et al. 2010; Chavatte et al. 2015 |
[159, 170] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723579 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 24% of malaria positives | Abdulraheem et al. 2019 | [106] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 1.1% (4/365) malaria positive children | Oyedeji et al. 2021 | [195] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to China, France and Spain |
Cao et al. 2016; Joste et al. 2021; Rojo-Marcos et al. 2014 |
[90, 183, 193] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to China, France and Spain |
Cao et al. 2016; Joste et al. 2021; Rojo-Marcos et al. 2014 |
[90, 183, 193] | |
| Pakistan | P. ovale sp. | PCR | Imported to China | Cao et al. 2016 | [90] |
| Papua New Guinea | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: AF145337 | Mehlotra et al. 2002 | [196] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: EU266603 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 3.4% of 504 children aged 5–10 y from East Sepik Province | Robinson et al. 2015 | [197] | |
| Philippines | P. ovale sp. | Rare, Palawan only until 1977 | Cabrera and Arambulo 1977 | [200] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | Palawan—0.3% (2/613) | Reyes et al. 2021 | [199] | |
| Rwanda | P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: FJ409570 | Duval et al. 2009 | [163] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 4.9% (53/1089) schoolchildren | Sifft et al. 2016 | [200] | |
| Sao Tome and Principe | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GQ231520 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: EU266603 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 2.8% of 661 | Pinto et al. 2000 | [201] | |
| Senegal | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KX417703 | unpublished | – |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KX417699 | unpublished | – | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 4.91% (6/122) | Badiane et al. 2021 | [116] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| Sierra Leone | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723523 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723571 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 0.4% (2/534) febrile patients | Leski et al. 2020 | [118] | |
| Solomon Islands | P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Echeverry et al. 2016; Echeverry et al. 2017 | [202, 203] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 0.05% (1/1914) | Russell et al. 2021 | [204] | |
| Somalia | P. ovale sp. | Imported to USA (military) | CDC 1993 | [205] | |
| South Africa | P. ovale sp. | PCR | Imported to China | Cao et al. 2016 | [90] |
| South Sudan | P. ovale sp. | Microscopy | Bor; 1.2% of 392 | Omer et al. 1978 | [121] |
| Sri Lanka | P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 1 isolate in meta-analysis; Sri Lanka malariafree since 2016 | Bauffe et al. 2012 | [164] |
| Sudan | P. ovale sp. | Microscopy | New Halfa, 2% of 190 malaria positives | Himeidan et al. 2005 | [206] |
| P. ovale sp. | Microscopy | Khartoum; 0.32% of 3791 participants | El Sayed et al. 2000 | [207] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | Imported to China | Cao et al. 2016 | [90] | |
| Tanzania | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723515 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 1 isolate | Calderaro et al. 2013 | [208] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 2 cases, Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | Zanzibar; 16.2% (30/185) malaria PCR positives; 10 mono + 20 mixed infections | Cook et al. 2015 | [209] | |
| Thailand | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: KC137349; KF018432 | Putaporntip et al. 2013; Tanomsing et al. 2013 | [210, 211] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GQ231519; KC137344; KF018430 | Sutherland et al. 2010; Putaporntip et al. 2013; Tanomsing et al. 2013 | [159, 210, 211] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 0.3% (4/1347) asymptomatic participants; 4 mixed infections | Baum et al. 2016 | [212] | |
| Togo | P. ovale sp. | 2.8% | Gbary et al. 1988 | [213] | |
| P. ovale sp. | 2% of malaria positives | MSPS 2017 | [214] | ||
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | 12 cases, Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 14 cases, Imported to France | Joste et al. 2021 | [183] | |
| Uganda | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723521 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723573; KP050464 |
Chavatte et al. 2015; Sutherland et al. 2010 |
[159, 170] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | PCR | Apac District; Buliisa District; Mayuge District | Oguike et al. 2011 | [175] | |
| P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | Apac District; Buliisa District; Mayuge District | Oguike et al. 2011 | [175] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 0–6.7% of all malaria; 0–4.3% of population | Oguike et al. 2011 | [175] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | Imported to China | Cao et al. 2016 | [90] | |
| Vietnam | P. ovale curtisi | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: GU723523 | Sutherland et al. 2010 | [159] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: AF387041 | Unpublished | – | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | 0.8% (19/2303) of population | Nguyen et al. 2012 | [137] | |
| Yemen | P. ovale sp. | Microscopy | 1 symptomatic case, Beni-Hussan village | Al-Maktari and Bassiouny 1999 | [215] |
| Zambia | P. ovale wallikeri | PCR | 1 case | Nolder et al. 2013 | [168] |
| P. ovale wallikeri | LAMP | eastern Zambia | Hayashida et al. 2017 | [216] | |
| P. ovale curtisi | LAMP | eastern Zambia | Hayashida et al. 2017 | [216] | |
| P. ovale sp. | LAMP | 10.6% in asymptomatic participants | Hayashida et al. 2017 | [216] | |
| P. ovale sp. | PCR | Western province (cross-sectional survey); 12.4% (32/259); 6 mono + 26 mixed | Sitali et al. 2019 | [141] | |
| Zimbabwe | P. ovale wallikeri | Sequence | GenBank: e.g.: FJ409570 | Duval et al. 2009 | [163] |
| P. ovale sp. | < 2% of malaria positives | Taylor 1985 | [217] |