Metal
|
Suitable mechanical properties of biocompatible metallic scaffolds |
Outstanding mechanical properties |
Non-biodegradable |
|
Biocompatible |
Corrosion |
Tantalum |
Bioactive and corrosion resistance |
Extensively used as implant biomaterials |
Almost no degradation lead to a second surgery for removing the implant |
28–32
|
Magnesium |
Good porous and biodegradable implant |
Mechanical properties similar to human bone |
Toxicity risk caused by metal ion or particle leaching |
33–39
|
Biodegradable |
Titanium and titanium alloys |
Durable, biocompatible, highly corrosion resistant and very similar modulus of elasticity for trabecular bone |
High bone affinity |
Non-biodegradable |
40–44
|
Nickel-titanium alloy (nitinol) |
Particular mechanical properties (such as the shape memory and superelastic effects) |
Low modulus of elasticity, pseudo-elasticity, and high damping capacity, better match the properties of natural bone better than any other metals |
Almost no degradation for nitinol, the relatively high stiffness of titanium can cause stress shielding and implant loosening |
45–48
|
Natural polymer
|
Similarity to ECM, specific degradation rates and good biological properties |
Biocompatible |
Low mechanical strength |
|
Degradation |
Collagen |
Important part of natural bone organic materials. Excellent biocompatibility |
Biodegradable |
Disinfection and handling are relatively difficult |
49–51
|
Various forms of scaffolds (e.g., sheets) |
Gelatin |
Denaturalized collagen |
Forming blends through cross-linking |
|
52–55
|
Silk fibroin |
Silk fibroin with outstanding mechanical properties |
|
|
56–58
|
Chitosan |
Polysaccharide with positive charge, biocompatibility and resistance to bacteria |
|
|
59
|
Alginate |
Polysaccharide with negative charge, and can crosslink and print by injection |
|
|
60–62
|
Hyaluronic acid |
Glycosaminoglycan with negative charge, biocompatibility, forming hydrogel through cross-linking |
Ease to chemical functionalization and degradability |
|
58,63–66
|
Synthetic polymer
|
|
Changeable mechanical and physical properties |
Possible adverse tissue reactions caused by acidic degradation |
|
PLA, PGA and PLGA |
FDA-approved materials for clinical applications |
Water solubility and crystallinity tunable by changing hydroxylation degree |
Non-hydrophobic and shortage of cell adhesion |
67–69
|
PCL |
Excellent crystallinity and mechanical properties |
An crosslink in situ and print by injection |
Degradation rate in years |
70–73
|
PVA |
Hydroxylated synthetic polyvinyl acetate |
Ability to manufacture implants with various characteristics such as shape, porosity and degradation rate |
|
74–77
|
PPF |
Has numerous nonsaturable double bonds and the crosslinks may be toxic |
Adjustable mechanical strength and rates of degradation |
|
78,79
|
Polyurethane (PU) |
Remarkable mechanical properties |
|
|
80–82
|
Bioinert ceramic
|
Cannot perform medical reactions with living tissue after implantation |
|
|
|
Aluminum, e.g., α-aluminum oxide (Al2O3) |
Improve mechanical properties; lack of biological activity |
|
|
83–86
|
Zirconia |
Interconnected structures; lack of chemical bonds and biological reactions between living tissues |
|
|
87–89
|
Bioactive ceramic
|
Can show medical reactions with living tissue after implantation |
|
|
|
HA |
The main inorganic component of natural bone |
Highly biocompatible, non-toxic and osteoconductive |
|
6,85,90,91
|
Tricalcium phosphate (TCP), e.g., beta-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) |
The ratio of calcium to phosphorus is close to natural bone tissue |
Biocompatibility, no rejection and can provide calcium and phosphorus for new tissue |
α-TCP has excessive dissolution and rapid degradation |
56,92–95
|
Degradation rate and osteogenic speed are inconsistent |
Calcium sulfate (CaSO4) |
CaSO4 is a good material to choose after tumor resection |
|
|
96–99
|
Akermanite (ca, Si, Mg) |
Excellent mechanical properties and controllable degradation rate |
|
|
100–102
|
Better osteogenic differentiation and increased gene expression compared to β-TCP |
Diopside (MgCaSi2O6) |
Low temperature and fast firing and good thermal expansion properties |
|
|
103–106
|
Bioactive glasses (BGs) |
The main components for Na2O, CaO, SiO2 and P2O5; brittleness |
|
|
107–113
|