Skip to main content
. 2019 Aug 21;9(45):26252–26262. doi: 10.1039/c9ra05214c

Outlined characteristics of various biomaterials used to fabricate bone tissue engineering scaffolds.

Biomaterials Characteristics Advantages Disadvantages Ref.
Metal Suitable mechanical properties of biocompatible metallic scaffolds Outstanding mechanical properties Non-biodegradable
Biocompatible Corrosion
Tantalum Bioactive and corrosion resistance Extensively used as implant biomaterials Almost no degradation lead to a second surgery for removing the implant 28–32
Magnesium Good porous and biodegradable implant Mechanical properties similar to human bone Toxicity risk caused by metal ion or particle leaching 33–39
Biodegradable
Titanium and titanium alloys Durable, biocompatible, highly corrosion resistant and very similar modulus of elasticity for trabecular bone High bone affinity Non-biodegradable 40–44
Nickel-titanium alloy (nitinol) Particular mechanical properties (such as the shape memory and superelastic effects) Low modulus of elasticity, pseudo-elasticity, and high damping capacity, better match the properties of natural bone better than any other metals Almost no degradation for nitinol, the relatively high stiffness of titanium can cause stress shielding and implant loosening 45–48
Natural polymer Similarity to ECM, specific degradation rates and good biological properties Biocompatible Low mechanical strength
Degradation
Collagen Important part of natural bone organic materials. Excellent biocompatibility Biodegradable Disinfection and handling are relatively difficult 49–51
Various forms of scaffolds (e.g., sheets)
Gelatin Denaturalized collagen Forming blends through cross-linking 52–55
Silk fibroin Silk fibroin with outstanding mechanical properties 56–58
Chitosan Polysaccharide with positive charge, biocompatibility and resistance to bacteria 59
Alginate Polysaccharide with negative charge, and can crosslink and print by injection 60–62
Hyaluronic acid Glycosaminoglycan with negative charge, biocompatibility, forming hydrogel through cross-linking Ease to chemical functionalization and degradability 58,63–66
Synthetic polymer Changeable mechanical and physical properties Possible adverse tissue reactions caused by acidic degradation
PLA, PGA and PLGA FDA-approved materials for clinical applications Water solubility and crystallinity tunable by changing hydroxylation degree Non-hydrophobic and shortage of cell adhesion 67–69
PCL Excellent crystallinity and mechanical properties An crosslink in situ and print by injection Degradation rate in years 70–73
PVA Hydroxylated synthetic polyvinyl acetate Ability to manufacture implants with various characteristics such as shape, porosity and degradation rate 74–77
PPF Has numerous nonsaturable double bonds and the crosslinks may be toxic Adjustable mechanical strength and rates of degradation 78,79
Polyurethane (PU) Remarkable mechanical properties 80–82
Bioinert ceramic Cannot perform medical reactions with living tissue after implantation
Aluminum, e.g., α-aluminum oxide (Al2O3) Improve mechanical properties; lack of biological activity 83–86
Zirconia Interconnected structures; lack of chemical bonds and biological reactions between living tissues 87–89
Bioactive ceramic Can show medical reactions with living tissue after implantation
HA The main inorganic component of natural bone Highly biocompatible, non-toxic and osteoconductive 6,85,90,91
Tricalcium phosphate (TCP), e.g., beta-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) The ratio of calcium to phosphorus is close to natural bone tissue Biocompatibility, no rejection and can provide calcium and phosphorus for new tissue α-TCP has excessive dissolution and rapid degradation 56,92–95
Degradation rate and osteogenic speed are inconsistent
Calcium sulfate (CaSO4) CaSO4 is a good material to choose after tumor resection 96–99
Akermanite (ca, Si, Mg) Excellent mechanical properties and controllable degradation rate 100–102
Better osteogenic differentiation and increased gene expression compared to β-TCP
Diopside (MgCaSi2O6) Low temperature and fast firing and good thermal expansion properties 103–106
Bioactive glasses (BGs) The main components for Na2O, CaO, SiO2 and P2O5; brittleness 107–113