Table 4. MSB classification performance of baseline models.
Methods | Magnification | Image_accuracy(%) | Patient_accuracy(%) | Sensitivity(%) | Precision(%) | F1_score(%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AlexNet | 40× | 86.38±3.46 | 87.21±3.85 | 87.48±6.60 | 93.85±2.22 | 90.41±3.16 |
100× | 88.17±3.52 | 88.66±3.35 | 87.23±4.25 | 96.55±1.93 | 91.62±2.82 | |
200× | 89.48±3.38 | 88.67±3.45 | 90.79±5.80 | 94.93±1.28 | 92.72±2.79 | |
400× | 89.13±3.18 | 88.50±3.11 | 91.10±5.21 | 93.87±2.99 | 92.37±2.65 | |
VGG16 | 40× | 90.26±2.75 | 90.50±2.96 | 91.35±4.47 | 95.50±2.48 | 93.30±2.02 |
100× | 90.06±4.83 | 89.40±4.54 | 91.25±4.96 | 95.11±2.75 | 93.11±3.64 | |
200× | 93.87±2.00 | 93.15±2.88 | 93.88±2.51 | 97.84±1.08 | 95.80±1.50 | |
400× | 90.82±2.62 | 89.83±1.99 | 93.74±2.31 | 93.75±3.43 | 93.71±1.92 | |
ResNet50 | 40× | 90.24±4.27 | 90.39±4.54 | 90.64±5.32 | 95.87±2.08 | 93.14±3.52 |
100× | 92.09±3.28 | 92.17±3.21 | 94.10±3.16 | 95.13±2.63 | 94.60±2.52 | |
200× | 91.04±2.42 | 89.57±2.28 | 93.01±3.09 | 94.94±1.33 | 93.94±1.80 | |
400× | 88.75±2.56 | 87.96±2.55 | 91.23±5.79 | 93.42±3.35 | 92.15±2.28 | |
GoogLeNet | 40× | 91.61±3.16 | 91.29±3.30 | 91.66±3.83 | 96.87±2.14 | 94.16±2.47 |
100× | 91.73±3.42 | 91.97±3.76 | 91.82±5.03 | 96.82±0.90 | 94.20±2.79 | |
200× | 92.00±2.31 | 90.72±2.47 | 92.90±3.96 | 96.32±2.33 | 94.52±1.88 | |
400× | 90.39±2.28 | 89.61±2.45 | 90.74±3.32 | 96.04±4.07 | 93.22±1.82 | |
SqueezeNet | 40× | 86.99±1.53 | 85.69±3.06 | 87.91±5.38 | 94.54±3.19 | 90.94±1.46 |
100× | 91.35±3.99 | 91.04±4.22 | 93.73±3.74 | 94.51±2.84 | 94.10±2.98 | |
200× | 93.09±1.22 | 92.57±2.37 | 94.59±1.98 | 96.20±2.40 | 95.36±0.92 | |
400× | 88.89±4.20 | 87.93±4.30 | 89.76±7.25 | 94.70±1.72 | 92.01±3.68 | |
DenseNet201 | 40× | 88.23±2.84 | 88.62±2.95 | 87.45±3.70 | 96.36±1.89 | 91.66±2.46 |
100× | 90.38±3.83 | 90.84±3.70 | 90.49±5.99 | 96.40±2.29 | 93.24±3.16 | |
200× | 91.03±2.46 | 90.14±2.72 | 90.69±3.92 | 97.14±1.63 | 93.76±2.01 | |
400× | 89.23±2.43 | 88.78±2.44 | 89.55±4.38 | 95.48±2.22 | 92.34±2.09 | |
Inception-ResNet-V2 | 40× | 88.14±2.44 | 88.29±4.15 | 93.05±3.09 | 91.43±4.23 | 92.14±1.67 |
100× | 91.27±0.90 | 91.16±0.76 | 95.21±2.55 | 93.33±3.18 | 94.20±0.76 | |
200× | 90.66±0.66 | 89.74±1.38 | 95.11±3.46 | 92.86±3.34 | 93.88±0.34 | |
400× | 87.93±1.90 | 87.25±2.12 | 91.80±2.43 | 91.91±4.38 | 91.76±1.34 |