Table 2.
Ranking Metric | Method of Calculation | Treatment Hierarchy Question(s) |
---|---|---|
Point estimate of the mean absolute estimand or relative treatment effect () | The center of the distribution of the absolute estimand or relative treatment effect | Which treatment has the smallest estimated mean value on the studied outcome? Which treatment has the largest estimated mean advantage compared with all other competitors? |
Probability of a treatment’s having the best mean outcome value () | Which treatment is most likely to have the best (most desirable) mean value on the studied outcome? | |
SUCRA for treatment i () | a | Which treatment has the largest fraction of competitors that it beats?b |
Mean rank () | c | In the distribution of treatment effect ranks, which treatment has the largest mean rank? |
Median rank () | The value satisfying and | In the distribution of treatment effect ranks, which treatment has the largest median rank? |
Abbreviations: BV, best value; SUCRA, surface under the cumulative ranking curve.
a represents the number of competing treatments.
b Assuming a harmful outcome, we consider that a treatment “beats” treatment when the true mean values of the outcome fulfill .
c represents the probability that treatment i will produce the rth most favorable value (or will “beat” exactly r treatments).