Skip to main content
. 2021 Nov 2;23(4):563–586. doi: 10.1007/s11121-021-01316-6

Table 2.

Quality assessment and risk of bias of included studies

STUDY ID SELECTION BIAS STUDY DESIGN CONFOUNDERS BLINDING DATA COLLECTION METHODS WITHDRAWALS AND DROP-OUTS OVERALL RATING Funding COI
Alvirde-Garcia et al. (2013) Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Weak MODERATE Funded by public national hospital and Metabolic Syndrome Institute NR
Arroyo and Carrete (2018) Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Moderate Weak WEAK No funding obtained NR
Bacardi-Gascon and Jiménez-Cruz (2012) Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Moderate Strong MODERATE Funded by a public university NR
Balas-Nakash et al. (2010) Weak Moderate Strong Moderate Strong Moderate MODERATE NR Nothing to declare
Benitez-Guerrero et al. (2016) Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Strong Weak WEAK Funded by a public university NR
Caballero-Garcia et al. (2017) Moderate Moderate Strong Moderate Moderate Weak MODERATE NR NR
Costa-Urrutia et al. (2019) Moderate Moderate Strong Moderate Strong Weak MODERATE Funded by a local authority Nothing to declare
Cruz-Bello et al. (2019) Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Moderate Weak WEAK NR NR
Elizondo-Montemayor et al. (2014) Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Moderate Weak WEAK Funded by a private university NR
Gatica-Dominguez et al. (2019) Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Strong Weak WEAK Funded by food industry (Tresmontes lucchetti Mexico) NR
Macias et al. (2014) (Abstract) Weak Strong Weak Moderate Moderate Weak WEAK NR NR
Martinez-Andrade et al. (2014) Strong Strong Strong Strong Moderate Moderate STRONG Funded by a public hospital Nothing to declare
Mejia et al. (2016) (Abstract) Weak Strong Weak Moderate Moderate Weak WEAK Local health authorities NR
Padilla-Raygoza et al. (2013) Moderate Strong Moderate Moderate Moderate Weak MODERATE National Ministry of Education Nothing to declare
Perichart-Perera et al. (2008) Moderate Moderate Strong Moderate Strong Weak MODERATE Funded by food industry (PepsiCo) NR
Polo-Oteyza et al. (2017) Moderate Moderate Strong Moderate Strong Weak MODERATE Funded by food industry (Nestle) and National public University NR
Ponce et al. (2016) Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Strong Weak WEAK NR NR
Radilla-Vazquez et al. (2019) Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Moderate STRONG NR NR
Ramirez-Lopez et al. (2005) Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Strong Weak WEAK Local authorities funding NR
Rios-Cortazar et al. (2013) Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak WEAK NR Nothing to declare
Vazquez et al. (2017) Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Moderate Weak WEAK NR NR
Rodriguez-Ventura et al. (2018) Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Moderate Moderate MODERATE Science Mexican Council Nothing to declare
Safdie et al. (2013a, b) Strong Strong Moderate Moderate Strong Strong STRONG Supported by the Pan American Health Organization, Program of The International Life Science Institute, Science Mexican Council, Health Ministry, and global health Research Initiative Nothing to declare
Salazar-Vazquez et al. (2016) Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Weak MODERATE National Funds Nothing to declare
Saucedo-Molina et al. (2018) Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak WEAK Funded by two private foundations NR
Levy et al. (2012a, b) Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong STRONG Local authorities Nothing to declare
Vega et al. (2019) Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Weak MODERATE NR NR
Vilchis-Gil et al. (2016) Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong STRONG Public Paediatric Hospital Nothing to declare
Zacarias et al. (2019) Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Strong MODERATE Science Mexican Council and public university Nothing to declare

NR not reported, COI conflict of interest