Table 2.
Comparison of the Three Viscoelastic Point-of-Care Tests.
Step of Clot Formation | Factors Affecting Clot Stability | TEG | Sonoclot | ROTEM | Therapeutic Options |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Initial clot formation/fibrin formation | Factors XII and XI of the intrinsic pathway or factors VII and VIII if a tissue factor activator is used | R | SonACT | CT | Administration of plasma, coagulation factors |
Clot kinetics | Factor II and VIII activity, platelet, and fibrinogen function | Kinetics (K) and angle α | CR | Clot formation time (CFT) and angle α | Fresh frozen plasma (FFP) Cryoprecipitate |
Maximum clot strength | Platelet functionand number, thrombin generation, fibrinogen | Maximum amplitude (MA) | Peak amplitude | Maximum clot firmness (MCF) | Cryoprecipitate/platelet concentrate |
Maximum lysis | Fibrinolysis | LY30, LY45, LY60 | R3 curve | CL30, CL45, CL60 | Antifibrinolytic drugs Assessment of disseminated intravascular coagulation |
Advantages | Rapid interpretation at 30 min; rapid TEG yields results even earlier and is useful in transplantation | Rapid results in 15–20 min, decision for FFP and platelet concentrate use can be taken early. | Stable system as movement does not impair the graphical output. Can clearly differentiate between fibrinogen defects and platelet dysfunction. |
All 3 systems provide good guidance for FFP usage. | |
Disadvantages | Decision pathways for platelet dysfunction and fibrinogen defects show overlap. (K time, α angle, and maximum amplitude). Movement of the system impairs results |
Differentiation of the contribution by platelets and fibrinogen defects to clot rate is difficult to assess. Movement of the system impairs results |
Expensive as multiple tests are run simultaneously | All 3 systems are validated for use in liver transplantation with increasing evidence for restricted use in intensive care practice in acute variceal bleeding. |
Abbreviations: TEG, thromboelastography; ROTEM, rotational thromboelastometry; Ly, lysis; ACT, activated clotting time; CT, clotting time; CL, clot lysis.