Table 1.
First author | Year | Trial group | Control group | Outcomes | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|||||||||
Therapy | n | Male/female | Age | Therapy | n | Male/female | Age | |||
Han[15] | 2017 | HP+HF+Con | 11 | 6/5 | 38.7±4.3 | HP+Con | 13 | 7/6 | 38.1±4.2 | ➀➁➂➃➄ |
Jiao[16] | 2016 | HP+HF+Con | 37 | 14/23 | 41.9±5.1 | HP+Con | 37 | 17/20 | 42.1±5.2 | ➀➃➄ |
Liu[17] | 2016 | HP+HF+Con | 17 | 9/8 | 43.1±8.0 | HP+Con | 17 | 10/7 | 42.9±8.3 | ➀➁➂➃➄ |
Wang[18] | 2016 | HP+HF+Con | 60 | 21/39 | 68.5±5.3 | HP+Con | 60 | 21/39 | 68.5±5.3 | ➀➂➃ |
Xia[19] | 2013 | HP+HF+Con | 34 | 12/22 | 45.5±9.1 | Con | 32 | 12/20 | 46.5±8.2 | ➀➁➄ |
Xie[20] | 2019 | HP+HF+Con | 55 | 30/25 | 44.4±4.7 | HP+Con | 55 | 32/23 | 44.5±4.8 | ➀➁➃➄ |
Xu[21] | 2014 | HP+HF+Con | 34 | 12/22 | 36.2±2.3 | Con | 32 | 11/21 | 35.6±7.4 | ➀➂➃➄ |
Xue[22] | 2019 | HP+HF+Con | 31 | 10/21 | 66.7±6.2 | HF+Con | 31 | 12/19 | 67.5±5.3 | ➀➃➄ |
Yang[23] | 2014 | HP+HF+Con | 41 | 19/22 | 38.5±6.2 | HP+Con | 40 | 17/23 | 37.8±3.6 | ➀➃ |
Yang[24] | 2016 | HP+HF+Con | 32 | 24/8 | 40.5±3.2 | Con | 30 | 25/5 | 40.4±3.3 | ➀➃➄ |
Yue[25] | 2015 | HP+HF+Con | 56 | 24/32 | 43.2±8.4 | Con | 56 | 28/28 | 44.3±8.2 | ➂➃➄ |
Outcomes: ➀=mortality; ➁=atropine dosing; ➂=duration of mechanical ventilation; ➃=restoration time of cholinesterase; ➄=length of stay. HP=Hemoperfusion; HF=Hemofiltration; Con=Conventional