Table 3.
Nuclease | Mechanism | Effect | DM1 Model | Advantages | Limitations | Ref |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ZNF | Induction of DNA double strand breaks at CAG/CTG repeats | Repeat contractions |
Yeast cells carrying CTG repeats | Permanent reduction in CTG repeats; good cleavage efficiency | Repeat rearrangements | [171] |
ZNF | Induction of DNA double strand breaks at CAG/CTG repeats | Repeat contractions and duplications | Mammalian cells carrying CTG repeats | Permanent reduction in CTG repeats; good cleavage efficiency | Repeat duplications | [172] |
TALEN | Induction of DNA double strand breaks at CAG/CTG repeats | Repeat contractions | Yeast cells carrying CTG repeats | Permanent reduction in CTG repeats; good cleavage efficiency, no mutations | Application limited to yeast cells | [173,174] |
TALEN | Insertion of a polyA signal upstream CTG repeats | Production of shorter DMPK transcripts (no CUG) | DM1-patient-derived iPSCs | Elimination of toxic CUG repeats from DMPK transcript | Production of truncated DMPK protein; retention of CTG at DMPK locus | [43,175] |
SpCas9 D10A | Induction of DNA single strand breaks at CAG/CTG repeats | Repeat contractions | Human cells carrying CAG/CTG repeats | Permanent reduction in CTG repeats | Cell-type dependent efficiency | [176] |
dCas9 | Block DNA transcription at CTG repeats | DMPK transcription inhibition | DM1-patient-derived cells; HSALR mice |
Suppression of CUG-repeat-transcript production | Decreased DMPK protein production; retention of CTG at DMPK locus; need of repeated treatment | [124] |
RCas9 | Cleaving single-strand RNA at CUG repeats | CUG-repeated transcript degradation | DM1-patient-derived cells; HSALR mice |
Elimination of CUG-repeat transcript | Decreased DMPK protein production; retention of CTG at DMPK locus; need of repeated treatment | [125,177] |
SpCas9
D10A |
Insertion of a polyA signal upstream CTG repeats | Production of shorter DMPK transcripts (no CUG) | DM1-patient-derived iPSCs | Elimination of toxic CUG repeats from DMPK transcript | Production of truncated DMPK protein; retention of CTG at DMPK locus | [178] |
SpCas9
or SaCas9 |
Induction of two DNA double strand breaks at CTG-repeats flanking regions | Deletion of CTG expanded region | DM1-patient-derived iPSCs | Permanent elimination of toxic CTG repeats; no off-targets | Low efficiency using SpCas9; higher efficiency but frequent inversions using SaCas9 | [178] |
SpCas9 | Induction of two DNA double strand breaks at CTG-repeats flanking regions | Deletion of CTG expanded region | DM1-mouse-derived myoblasts; DM1-patient derived myoblasts |
Permanent elimination of CTG repeats; no off-targets | On-target indels, inversions, large deletions | [179] |
SpCas9 | Induction of two DNA double strand breaks at CTG-repeats flanking regions | Deletion of CTG expanded region | DM1-patient-derived MYOD1-converted fibroblasts | Permanent elimination of CTG repeats; no off-targets | On-target indels, inversions | [40] |
SpCas9 | Induction of two DNA double strand breaks at CTG-repeats flanking regions | Deletion of CTG expanded region | DM1-patient-derived primary myoblasts; DM1-patient-derived iPSCs | Permanent elimination of CTG repeats; good editing efficiency in iPSCs; no off-targets | On-target indels, partial deletions | [180] |
SaCas9 | Induction of two DNA double strand breaks at CTG-repeats flanking regions | Deletion of CTG expanded region | DM1-patient-derived myoblasts; DMSXL mice |
Permanent elimination of CTG repeats; good editing efficiency in DM1 cells; no off-targets | On-target indels; low editing efficiency in mice skeletal muscle | [123] |
eSpCas9 | Induction of two DNA double strand breaks at CTG-repeats flanking regions | Inducible deletion of CTG expanded region | DM1-patient-derived MYOD1-converted fibroblasts; DMSXL mice |
Permanent elimination of CTG repeats; well-regulated editing induction; no off-targets | On-target indels, inversions, large deletions | [122] |
Abbreviations. dCas9 = deactivated Cas9; eSpCas9 = enhanced Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9; RCas9 = RNA-targeting Cas9; SaCas9 = Staphylococcus aureus Cas9; SpCas9 = Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9; SpCas9 D10A = SpCas9 nickase.