Table A1.
Liquid or solution culture techniques further subdivided into circulating (closed) and non-circulating (open) techniques. GM, growth medium.
Technique | Description | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|
Circulating methods (closed systems) | Nutrient solution pumped through plant root system, collecting and reusing excess solution. | ||
NFT [23,31,43,110] |
Plants in channels with nutrient solution flowing past roots driven by a slight gradient. Often in substrate-filled net pots. | - low initial costs - reusability of nutrient solution - low probability of blockages |
- control of nutrient concentrations and pH required - difficult for species with short roots - power/pump failures |
DFT [23,31,43,167] |
Growing directly in nutrient solution. Often in substrate-filled net pots. | - efficient water and nutrient use - water-loving and fast-growing plants - can be organic |
- take care regarding sufficient oxygenation - risk of diseases, etc. |
Ebb and flow system [23,31,168,169] |
Plants placed directly in growing trays often filled with medium. Nutrient solution periodically floods planting chamber and returns to reservoir. | - water-loving plants - energy-efficient - easily scalable |
- high demand for reservoir capacities and nutrient medium - risk of anoxia - power/pump failures |
Drip system [23,31,33,43,170] |
Substrate in which roots are supplied with nutrient solution via drip emitter, often periodically. | - simple installation - efficient water and nutrient use and easy control |
- drip lines/emitters susceptible to blockages - control of nutrient concentrations and pH required - power/pump failures |
Wick system [23,43,171] |
Capillary action feeds plants via synthetic fibers such as nylon. Often with absorbent medium. | - suitable for indoor, small or single plants such as herbs and spices - passive; no electricity needed |
- requires a lot of water |
Aeroponic [28,166,172] |
Roots hang in air surrounded by sufficient oxygen and wetted with aerosol of nutrient solution distributed by atomizers. | - excellent aeration - reusability of nutrient solution - absence of GM - water-saving - low risk of diseases - high productivity - vertical usability |
- maintenance effort - atomizers may clog - cleaning of root chambers - high initial costs - power/pump failures - control of nutrient concentrations and pH required |
Aquaponic [28,77,95] | Combining hydroponic culture of plants with aquaculture of fish in closed water cycle and nitrifying bacteria. | - efficient water and nutrient use - no fertilizers required |
- maintenance effort - risk of algae growth - risk of diseases, etc. - power/pump failures - sufficient oxygenation |
Non-circulating methods | Nutrient solution is replaced when nutrient concentration decreases or pH and EC change. | ||
Root dipping technique [173] |
Pots closely spaced submerged in nutrient solution. | - inexpensive - little maintenance - passive; no electricity needed - good aeration |
- less efficient water and nutrient use - risk of diseases, etc. |
Floating technique [27] | Plants in small pots are fixed to Styrofoam sheet (or light plate) and float on nutrient solution. | - inexpensive - little maintenance - passive; no electricity needed |
- less efficient water and nutrient use - risk of diseases, etc. - artificial aeration |
Capillary action technique [174] |
Plant pots with holes at bottom and inert medium placed in shallow containers. Nutrient solution reaches medium by capillary action. | - suitable for ornamental, flower and indoor plants | - aeration depending on medium |