Skip to main content
. 2022 May 10;10:e13313. doi: 10.7717/peerj.13313

Table 4. Statistical comparisons of flight behaviors according to experimental conditions and sound signal attributes.

The seven flight metrics (described in Table 2) were compared using three-factor Type III ANOVA to determine whether flight behaviors differed according to the frequency level of the sound signal and/or the sound shape. F statistics, p-values, and generalized effect sizes (ηG2) are given for each factor. Values are reported to three significant digits with the exception of those smaller than 0.01, which are denoted by “<0.01” or by “<<0.01” if the difference is greater than one order of magnitude. Significant comparisons are shown with bolded p-values and a single asterisk (*).

Flight metric Comparisons between control and treatment flights Comparisons among sound signals by frequency level Comparisons among sound signals by sound shape Comparisons among sound signals by interaction of frequency and shape
1. Within-flight change in velocity (m/s) F1,18 = 0.41p= 0.53 ηG2 <0.01 F1,18 = 0.80p= 0.38 ηG2=0.01 F1,18 = 3.15p= 0.09 ηG2=0.01 F1,18 = 0.54p= 0.47 ηG2 <0.01
2. Average velocity (m/s) F1,18 = 3.02p= 0.10 ηG2=0.02 F1,18 = 0.45p= 0.51 ηG2 <<0.01 F1,18 <0.01 p= 0.96 ηG2 <<0.01 F1,18 = 1.37p= 0.26 ηG2=0.01
3. Minimum distance from obstacle (m) F1,18 = 21.4p<<0.01 (*)ηG2=0.10 F1,18 = 0.60p= 0.45 ηG2 <0.01 F1,18 = 0.11p= 0.75 ηG2 <0.01 F1,18 = 2.38p= 0.14 ηG2=0.02
4. Minimum distance from speaker (m) F1,18 = 28.6p<<0.01 (*)ηG2=0.11 F1,18 = 0.10p= 0.76 ηG2 <<0.01 F1,18 = 0.04p= 0.85 ηG2 <<0.01 F1,18 = 1.94p= 0.18 ηG2=0.01
5. Distance from obstacle when bird makes greatest adjustment in flight trajectory (m) F1,18 = 17.7p<<0.01 (*)ηG2=0.07 F1,18 = 0.01p= 0.91 ηG2 <<0.01 F1,18 = 2.36p= 0.14 ηG2=0.01 F1,18 = 2.54p= 0.13 ηG2=0.03
6. Distance from speaker when bird makes greatest adjustment in flight trajectory (m) F1,18 = 21.7p<<0.01 (*)ηG2=0.08 F1,18 = 0.27p= 0.61 ηG2 <<0.01 F1,18 = 3.36p= 0.08 ηG2=0.02 F1,18 = 3.16p= 0.09 ηG2=0.03
7. Proportion of flight completed when bird makes greatest adjustment in flight trajectory F1,18 = 2.55p= 0.13 ηG2=0.01 F1,18 <0.01 p= 0.94 ηG2 <<0.01 F1,18 = 2.78p= 0.11 ηG2=0.02 F1,18 = 1.31p= 0.27 ηG2=0.01