Table 4. Statistical comparisons of flight behaviors according to experimental conditions and sound signal attributes.
The seven flight metrics (described in Table 2) were compared using three-factor Type III ANOVA to determine whether flight behaviors differed according to the frequency level of the sound signal and/or the sound shape. F statistics, p-values, and generalized effect sizes () are given for each factor. Values are reported to three significant digits with the exception of those smaller than 0.01, which are denoted by “<0.01” or by “<<0.01” if the difference is greater than one order of magnitude. Significant comparisons are shown with bolded p-values and a single asterisk (*).
Flight metric | Comparisons between control and treatment flights | Comparisons among sound signals by frequency level | Comparisons among sound signals by sound shape | Comparisons among sound signals by interaction of frequency and shape |
---|---|---|---|---|
1. Within-flight change in velocity (m/s) | F1,18 = 0.41p= 0.53 <0.01 | F1,18 = 0.80p= 0.38 | F1,18 = 3.15p= 0.09 | F1,18 = 0.54p= 0.47 <0.01 |
2. Average velocity (m/s) | F1,18 = 3.02p= 0.10 | F1,18 = 0.45p= 0.51 <<0.01 | F1,18 <0.01 p= 0.96 <<0.01 | F1,18 = 1.37p= 0.26 |
3. Minimum distance from obstacle (m) | F1,18 = 21.4p<<0.01 (*) | F1,18 = 0.60p= 0.45 <0.01 | F1,18 = 0.11p= 0.75 <0.01 | F1,18 = 2.38p= 0.14 |
4. Minimum distance from speaker (m) | F1,18 = 28.6p<<0.01 (*) | F1,18 = 0.10p= 0.76 <<0.01 | F1,18 = 0.04p= 0.85 <<0.01 | F1,18 = 1.94p= 0.18 |
5. Distance from obstacle when bird makes greatest adjustment in flight trajectory (m) | F1,18 = 17.7p<<0.01 (*) | F1,18 = 0.01p= 0.91 <<0.01 | F1,18 = 2.36p= 0.14 | F1,18 = 2.54p= 0.13 |
6. Distance from speaker when bird makes greatest adjustment in flight trajectory (m) | F1,18 = 21.7p<<0.01 (*) | F1,18 = 0.27p= 0.61 <<0.01 | F1,18 = 3.36p= 0.08 | F1,18 = 3.16p= 0.09 |
7. Proportion of flight completed when bird makes greatest adjustment in flight trajectory | F1,18 = 2.55p= 0.13 | F1,18 <0.01 p= 0.94 <<0.01 | F1,18 = 2.78p= 0.11 | F1,18 = 1.31p= 0.27 |