Apple pomace |
|
|
|
Dried apple pomace (DAP) |
4, 8, and 12 8, 12, and 16 12, 16, and 20 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Incremental DAP at 4% and 8% improved daily FI and DWG of birds DAP at starter and grower phases, respectively, better than those fed 12% and 16% DAP.
-
ii.
Improved gut morphology parameters.
-
iii.
Increased antibody titre against Newcastle disease virus (NDV) and sheep red blood cell
-
iv.
Increased IgG and IgM titre and total antioxidant capacity.
|
Aghili et al. (2019) |
Apple pomace (AP) |
10, 15, and 20 |
Broiler chickens |
|
Matoo et al. (2001) |
AP |
3 and 6 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
No effect was observed for growth performance, gut histomorphometry, and histopathology.
-
ii.
Significant increase in the intestinal Short-chain fatty acid concentrations among birds fed fruit pomace diets.
-
iii.
In AP-fed birds, beta-diversity was significantly increased while alpha-diversity was unaffected. AP reduced the population of genus Lactobacillus, while the Streptococcaceae family was increased compared to the control treatment.
|
Colombino et al. (2020) |
AP |
10 and 20 |
Broiler chickens |
|
Bhat et al. (2000) |
AP ± molasses |
15 |
Broiler chickens |
With 10% molasses supplementation into dietary AP, BW, FI, FCR, and survivability of birds were not affected.
|
Bhat (2004) |
AP |
5, 10, and 15 |
Broiler chickens |
|
Ayhan et al. (2009) |
AP |
5 |
Turkey |
|
Juskiewicz et al. (2015) |
AP |
5 |
Turkey Poult |
-
i.
Maintained BW of birds.
-
ii.
Increased small intestine weight.
-
iii.
Increased maltase and sucrase activities in the small intestine.
-
iv.
Improved bacterial enzymes in the caecal digesta.
-
v.
Increased butyric, valeric and total putrefactive SCFA in the caecum.
|
Juskiewicz et al. (2016) |
Olive pomace/by-products |
Olive pulp ± xylanase (enzyme) |
9 |
Laying hens |
No report on gut health. |
Zarei et al. (2011) |
Olive pulp ± yeasture (probiotic) |
16 |
Laying hens |
-
i.
Dietary olive pulp at the inclusion level yielded a similar FI, % HDP, and EM, and a significantly increased FCR.
-
ii.
Probiotic supplementations into all the dietary treatments significantly reduce haugh unit and %HDP.
-
iii.
No significant interaction between olive pulp and probiotic supplementation.
No report on gut health. |
Afsari et al. (2013) |
Olive pomace |
10 |
Laying hens |
No report on gut health. |
Iannaccone et al. (2019) |
Olive pulp ± hemicell (enzyme) |
4.5 and 9 |
Laying hens |
-
i.
Non-significant improvement in the overall egg mass and FCR fed 4.5% olive pulp with or without enzyme supplementation.
-
ii.
A significant interaction effect of olive pulp and enzyme which increases egg weight when β-mannanase was included in the 9% olive pulp diet.
-
iii.
Diet containing 4.5% olive pulp increases antibody response against NDV.
-
iv.
Blood Serum hormones and metabolites were not affected by dietary olive pulp.
No report on gut health |
Zangeneh and Torki (2011) |
Olive pulp |
2.5 and 5 5 and 8 |
Male broiler chickens |
-
i.
Regardless of the inclusion level of olive pulp, FI, BW gain, and FCR of birds were not affected during the grower and finisher phase.
-
ii.
In addition, the proportion of total PUFA was not affected.
|
Papadomichelakis et al. (2019) |
Olive pulp |
2.5 and 5 5 and 8 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Overall FI and BW gain were not affected; however, FCR was significantly reduced among birds fed 8% olive pulp.
-
ii.
Mortality was reportedly similar across the treatment; however, it was zero when 5 and 8% olive pulp was fed.
-
iii.
No difference in the plasma SOD, CAT, GST, and GPx.
No report on gut health. |
Pappas et al. (2019) |
Olive pomace |
2.5, 5, and 7.5 |
Broiler chickens |
No report on gut health. |
Nasopoulou et al. (2018) |
Olive cake ± yeast |
5 and 10 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Similar FI, FCR, and EPEI were reported regardless of dietary olive cake and/or yeast supplementation inclusion levels.
-
ii.
Relative weight of spleen and bursa was similar across the treatments.
-
iii.
Olive cake diet at 5% and 10% without yeast supplementation reduces total plasma lipid, increases plasma TAG and cholesterol, HDL:LDL, and VLDL.
No report on gut health. |
Al-Harthi (2016) |
Olive cake |
5, 10, and 20 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
The best BW and FCR were achieved at 5% and 10% olive cake supplementation.
-
ii.
Decreased abdominal fat among birds fed olive cake.
-
iii.
Significant reduction in total plasma cholesterol in all birds fed olive cake.
-
iv.
Significant increase in breast muscle vitamin E and reduction in liver MDA in birds fed olive cake.
No report on gut health. |
Saleh and Alzawqari (2021) |
Olive pulp ± multi-enzyme ± processing (destoning) |
5 and 10 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
No difference in FI, WG, FE among birds fed 5% and 10% olive pulp. Enzyme supplementation also makes no difference in the growth performance parameters.
-
ii.
In addition, the destoning processing method yielded a significantly reduced WG and increased feed efficiency.
-
iii.
Feed cost was significantly lower in the 5% olive pulp diet compared to 10%. Processing and enzyme supplementation did not affect feed cost; however, they produced a significant interaction effect.
|
Sayehban et al. (2016) |
Olive cake ± citric acid |
10 and 20 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Feed intake and BW of birds fed 10% Olive cake or control with no citric acid, respectively, were better compared to the FI and BW obtained at 20% olive cake with or without citric acid.
-
ii.
RBC was significantly reduced in birds fed 20% Olive cake which increased following citric acid supplementation. However, in the 10% Olive cake treatment, RBC, PCV, haemoglobin, MCV, and MCH were favourably compared to control with or with citric acid.
-
iii.
Liver ratio was significantly reduced compared to the 20% olive cake and control treatments.
|
Al-Harthi and Attia (2016) |
Olive pulp ± multi-enzyme ± processing (destoning) |
5 and 10 |
Broiler chickens |
|
Sayehban et al. (2020) |
Olive pulp |
5, 10, and 15 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Significantly reduced BW and FCR among birds fed 10% and 15% olive pulp. However, the reduction might be due to the significantly reduced abdominal fat in birds fed 10% and 15% olive pulp.
-
ii.
A significant linear increase in the percentage of gizzard as olive pulp inclusion increases.
-
iii.
Unlike other immune organs, the percentage of the thymus was significantly increased with increasing inclusion levels of olive pulp.
|
Elbaz et al. (2020) |
Olive pulp ± irradiation |
5 and 10 |
Quail |
-
i.
Live BW was significantly increased in all the olive pulp treatments with or without irradiation. However, WG was non-significantly improved in all olive pulp treatments.
-
ii.
Dietary olive pulp significantly increased WBC, Hb, MCH, MCHC, and AST.
|
El-Hady et al. (2018) |
olive pulp ± irradiation |
3 and 6 |
Quail |
-
i.
Egg production, EW, FE, fertility, embryonic mortality, hatching percentage, and weight of chicks at hatch were significantly improved at both 3% and 6% irradiated olive pulp (IOP); however, it was highest at the latter.
-
ii.
Significant improvement in RBC and PCV in all diets containing olive pulp regardless of processing. However, WBC and Hb were significantly higher in the IOP treatments.
-
iii.
Intestinal length was also highest in the IOP treatments.
|
Ibrahim et al. (2019) |
Grape pomace |
|
|
|
Red grape pomace (RGP) |
2.5 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Birds' FI was higher when 2.5% RGP was fed and was compared favourably to antibiotic-treated birds. Reduced BW was observed in RGP-birds during the grower phase; however, overall FCR was similar compared to antibiotics.
-
ii.
Significant improvement in gut histomorphometric on the RGP-fed birds and was better compared to antibiotic treatments.
-
iii.
Significantly decreases Firmicute to Bacteroidetes ratio and improves the population of beneficial microbes, including Lactobacillus spp.
|
Erinle et al. (2021) |
RGP |
1.5, 3, 4.5, and 6 |
Cockerels (chickens) |
-
i.
The increasing dietary RGP did not affect the overall FI, body WG, FCR and slaughtered weight of cockerels.
-
ii.
MCH and GLB increase significantly with increasing inclusion levels of RGP.
|
Jonathan et al. (2021) |
Grape pomace (GP) |
450, 350, and 250 mg/kg |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Similar BW was reported across the dietary treatments.
-
ii.
There was a significant reduction in LDL of birds at 450 mg/kg inclusion of GP.
-
iii.
Increased SOD at the highest dose of GP while GPx was not affected.
|
Dupak et al. (2021) |
GP ± fermentation |
1.5 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Fermented GP (FGP) improves final BW in the same capacity as the synthetic antioxidant treatment; however, it was better when compared to raw GP.
-
ii.
Raw GP at 1.5% significantly increased serum GPx and SOD, while CAT was increased when 1.5% FGP was fed.
-
iii.
FGP significantly decimates Clostridium perfringens population compared to other treatments; however, other bacterial species, including Lactobacillus were not affected.
-
iv.
Regardless of fermentation, the GP treatments significantly reduce VH and VH:CD.
|
Gungor et al. (2021) |
GP |
7.5 and 15 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Dietary GP significantly lower FI and FCR and higher BW and was compared favourably to birds fed vitamin C and E, respectively.
-
ii.
Dietary GP significantly lower AST, ALT, and TAG and higher TP, GLB, HDL; however, it was similar to the vitamin C, and E-fed birds. Additionally, 15% GP reduces TC and LDL compared to other treatments.
-
iii.
Dietary GP significantly increases IgG, IgM, IgA, and SOD, and lower MDA and were comparable to vitamins C and E.
|
Mankola et al. (2021) |
GP ± enzyme complex ± tannase |
5 and 10 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Dietary 5% GP significantly increases protein and total polyphenol digestibilities. However, supplementation of enzyme complex or tannase or a combination of both reduces the 2 digestibilities.
-
ii.
Significant increase in the plasma α-tocopherol and antioxidant capacity of birds fed 5% GP and vitamin E, respectively.
|
Chamorro et al. (2017) |
RGP |
2.5, 4.5, 5.5, and 7.5 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Average weekly FI and FCR significantly reduced when 7.5% RGP was fed compared to other RGP levels and control. However, overall WG was not affected.
-
ii.
Blood parameters and carcass characteristics were not affected.
|
Kumanda et al. (2019) |
GP |
5, 7.5, and 10 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
No difference in the performance of birds by the increasing inclusion levels of GP.
-
ii.
Blood antioxidants, SOD and GPx, were significantly higher while MDA was reduced among 5 and 7.5% GP-fed birds.
-
iii.
All inclusion levels of GP reduced serum TAG and LDL while HDL was increased.
-
iv.
Significantly increased antibody titre against NDV among birds fed 5% and 10% GP.
|
Ebrahimzadeh et al. (2018) |
RGP |
5, 10, and 20 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Increasing levels of GP increase FI particularly at the starter and grower phase; however, BW gain and FCR were not affected.
-
ii.
Increasing levels of GP reduce abdominal fat in heat-stressed birds.
-
iii.
Increasing levels of GP reduce plasma cholesterol, LDL, AST, MDA, and TAG while HDL, TP, GPx, and SOD were increased.
-
iv.
GP increases weights of immune organs, bursa and thymus.
|
Hosseini-Vashan et al. (2020) |
RGP and white grape pomace (WGP) |
20 RGP and 20 WGP |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Dietary WGP did not affect BW, daily WG, FI and FCR, while RGP increased overall FCR.
-
ii.
Dietary WGP increases the antioxidant capacity of breast and leg meat compared to the RGP and control treatments.
|
Reyes et al. (2020) |
GP |
1, 2, 3, and 4 |
Laying hens |
-
i.
Dietary GP at 3% and 4% improved FCR, %EP, EM, SOD, and GPx compared to control treatment.
-
ii.
The %EP, EN, and EM were significantly higher among 4% GP-fed birds compared to those fed Vitamin E.
|
Alm El-Dein et al. (2017) |
RGP |
1.5, 3.5, and 5.5 |
Quail |
-
i.
Overall, FI was significantly improved at 3.5% RGP compared to other treatments. However, overall BW gain, FCE, and final BW were not influenced by the varying inclusion level of RGP.
-
ii.
Similarly, the serum biochemical parameters of the birds were not affected.
|
Mnisi et al. (2021) |
Strawberry pomace |
|
|
|
Strawberry pomace (SP) and/or Seedless strawberry pomace |
5 |
Turkey |
-
i.
On overall, SP, seedless SP, and a combination of both maintained turkey's growth performance and carcass characteristics.
|
Juskiewicz et al. (2015) |
SP |
3 and 6% |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
No effect was observed for growth performance, gut histomorphometry, histopathology.
-
ii.
Significant increase in the intestinal SCFA concentrations among birds fed fruit pomace diets including SP.
-
iii.
In SP-fed birds, beta-diversity was significantly increased while alpha-diversity was unaffected. SP reduced the population of genus Lactobacillus compared to the non-fruit pomace treatment.
|
Colombino et al. (2020) |
SP |
5 |
Turkey Poult |
-
i.
Maintained BW of birds.
-
ii.
Decreased small intestine weight.
-
iii.
Reduced maltase and sucrase activities in the small intestine.
-
iv.
Improved bacterial enzymes in the caecal digesta.
-
v.
Increased butyric acid in the caecum.
|
Juskiewicz et al. (2016) |
Seedless strawberry pomace (SSP) |
5 |
Turkey Poult |
-
i.
Maintained BW of birds.
-
ii.
Decreased small intestine weight and increased digesta viscosity.
-
iii.
Reduced maltase and sucrase activities in the small intestine.
-
iv.
Improved bacterial enzymes in the caecal digesta.
-
v.
Increased butyric and propionic acids in the caecum
|
Juskiewicz et al. (2016) |
SSP |
5 |
Turkey |
-
i.
TBARS concentration in raw and frozen breast muscle of turkey fed 5% SSP was drastically reduced compared to some other fruit pomaces.
-
ii.
Similarly, vitamin E levels were highest in raw breast meat of Turkey.
|
Juskiewicz et al. (2017) |
Blueberry pomace |
|
|
|
Blueberry extract (BE) |
0.5, 1, and 2 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Significantly increased BW gain and reduced FI and FCR as BE inclusion levels increases.
-
ii.
Significantly increased slaughter weight and dressing and gizzard percentage among BE-fed birds compared to control.
|
Ölmez et al. (2021) |
Blueberry pomace |
1 and 2 |
Broiler chickens |
|
Das et al. (2020) |
Cranberry pomace |
|
|
|
Cranberry pomace |
1 and 2 |
Broiler chickens |
|
Das et al. (2021) |
cranberry pomace extract |
0.1, 0.2, and 0.4 |
Broiler chickens |
|
Islam et al. (2017) |
cranberry pomace |
1 and 2 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Decreased TAG and ALT.
-
ii.
Increased the relative abundance of Lactobacillaceae in the caecal of birds fed 2% cranberry pomace.
-
iii.
Upregulation of adaptive immune related genes.
-
iv.
Similar to antibiotic effect, 1% cranberry pomace reduced prevalence of necrotic enteritis
-
v.
Improved BW in the same capacity of Bacitracin-fed birds.
|
Das et al. (2020) |
cranberry pomace |
1 and 2 |
Broiler chickens |
-
i.
Improved blood serum iron while cholesterol was reduced.
-
ii.
Selective modulation of gut microbe by improving beneficial, SCFA-producing gut bacteria while reducing the pathogenic ones.
|
Islam et al. (2020) |