Skip to main content
. 2022 May 20;2022(5):CD013665. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013665.pub3

2. Study characteristics (cross‐sectional prospective studies only).

Study ID Target condition Sample size Prevalence Country Setting Population Reference standard
Alizadehsani 2021 COVID‐19 pneumonia 319 39% Iran ED All patients referred to the imaging department on suspicion of COVID‐19 (with flu‐like symptoms) Thin‐slice high‐resolution multi‐slice spiral CT scan in a supine position, and high‐resolution CT images
Bhattacharya 2021 COVID‐19 378 33% India ED Patients who were suspected of COVID‐19. From 1066 suspected patients who were tested during this period, 384 patients were enrolled in the study based on the availability of informed consent and successful telephonic communication. Suspicion based on the testing advisory developed by the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), Version 5, dated May 18, 2020. "ILI symptoms", defined as acute respiratory infection with fever ≥ 38 °C AND cough RT‐PCR for SARS‐CoV‐2 (nasal + throat swab)
Bouzid 2020 COVID‐19 596 45% France ED All consecutive patients presenting with an influenza‐like illness (ILI: fever with a temperature > 38.5°C, malaise, headache, and myalgia; and 1 respiratory symptom (cough, sore throat, and dyspnoea)) and admitted to the hospital through the ED Either with QIAstat‐Dx Respiratory SARS‐CoV‐2 Panel or with a combination of the RT‐PCR RealStar SARS‐CoV‐2 Kit RUO and rapid multiplex PCR FilmArray RP2; specimen not specified
Brendish 2020 COVID‐19 1054 33% UK ED All consecutive adults presenting with an acute respiratory illness or otherwise clinically suspected of having COVID‐19 Either laboratory RT‐PCR or MPOCT (QIAGEN) for SARS‐CoV‐2 (nasopharyngeal swab)
Buonafine 2020 COVID‐19 295 42% Brazil Outpatient setting HCW with self‐reported fever or any of the following: acute respiratory symptoms (cough, nasal congestion, sore throat, shortness of breath), loss or changed sense of smell or taste, ocular symptoms, headache, arthralgia, myalgia, fatigue, diarrhoea, nausea, and vomiting RT‐PCR for SARS‐CoV‐2 (nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal swab)
Clemency 2020 COVID‐19 961 23% USA Outpatient setting HCWs triaged by phone, tested at drive‐through site RT‐PCR on nasopharyngeal or oropharyngeal swabs
Drager 2020 COVID‐19 2257 7% Germany Outpatient setting All patients presenting themselves at the outpatient clinic: patients with symptoms (not further specified) + high‐risk contacts or returning from a high‐risk area were tested for SARS‐CoV‐2 Not specified (throat swab)
Fink 2021 COVID‐19/ COVID‐19 pneumonia 219 33% Germany ED Patients who presented at ED with signs of a respiratory infection suspicious for COVID‐19 and received radiological imaging as well as RT‐PCR for SARS‐CoV‐2 RT‐PCR for SARS‐CoV‐2 (nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal swab)
Gilbert 2020 COVID‐19 598 29% Belgium Outpatient setting Suspected patients sent to testing centres close to ED RT‐PCR on nasopharyngeal swabs
Haehner 2020 COVID‐19 500 7% Germany Outpatient setting Patients presenting with symptoms of a common cold to a corona testing centre RT‐PCR on throat swabs
Ishii 2021 COVID‐19 3540 5% Japan Outpatient setting All consecutive participants who underwent drive‐through nasopharyngeal swab testing at an outpatient clinic. Reason for testing: upon request of the participant or participants who had been confirmed to have contacted COVID‐19 patients based on contact tracing. No clinical suspicion needed per se, but 54% of individuals were symptomatic, suggestive of COVID‐19 RT‐PCR, nasopharyngeal swab
Jeyashree 2021 COVID‐19 277 21% India Outpatient setting All consecutive adults who visited COVID‐19 testing centres in Chennai city in Southern India RT‐PCR, nasopharyngeal swab
Just 2020 COVID‐19 374 11% Germany Primary care Convenience sample of patients who were tested in GPs' practices RT‐PCR, samples not specified
Kalayjian 2020 COVID‐19 345 34% USA Outpatient setting Clients entering the health centre (walk‐in clinic) were screened for symptoms and triaged to the COVID‐19 clinic. Testing was performed for patients with a documented or subjective fever within the past 72 h. Labcorp’s nucleic‐acid amplification, threshold not specified, nasopharyngeal swabs
Kempker 2020 COVID‐19 283 18% USA Outpatient setting HCWs with a viral‐like illness, triaged to the employee health services staff for a virtual clinical assessment and then scheduled for SARS‐CoV‐2 testing RT‐PCR, nasopharyngeal swab
Krastinova 2020 COVID‐19 314 110 France Outpatient setting Symptomatic HCWs, defined as the presence of fever and/or respiratory symptoms RT‐PCR, nasopharyngeal swabs
Leal 2020 COVID‐19 1583 28% Brazil Outpatient setting Patients meeting the suspected COVID‐19 case definition (tested after initial screening questionnaire) RT‐PCR, samples not specified
Maechler 2020 COVID‐19 4333 8% Germany Outpatient setting Until 24 March 2020: symptomatic patients with high‐risk contacts or return from high‐risk area. From 24 March: also symptomatic people with risk factors and if the test capacity allowed also only symptomatic patients. Plus 2 subgroups of high‐risk patients in a nightclub and Charité employees SARS‐CoV‐2 RT‐PCR test (combined oro‐ and nasopharyngeal swab)
Mansella 2020 COVID‐19 4815 12% Switzerland Outpatient setting All patients presenting at the test centre with respiratory symptoms (such as shortness of breath), other flu‐like symptoms (fever, sore throat, cough) and self‐reported exposure to COVID‐19 RT‐PCR, 2 swabs from naso‐ and oropharyngeal sites combined into 1
Martin‐Sanz 2020 COVID‐19 355 61% Spain Outpatient setting HCWs with suspicion of COVID‐19 infection. Suspicion of COVID‐19 was determined by the presence of either cough, fever (> 37.5 °C), headache, or breathlessness, regardless of contact with a COVID‐19 patient SARS‐CoV‐2 next‐generation sequencing or real‐time (RT)‐PCR methods (nasal‐ and pharyngeal swabs)
Nazerian 2021 COVID‐19 838 23% Italy ED Patients with suspected COVID‐19 were prospectively enrolled in 2 EDs RT‐PCR, positive result within 5 days after ED presentation, or suggestive symptoms plus chest imaging (showing acute interstitial lung disease in the absence of an alternative diagnosis), or panel adjudication (for 3 cases without a positive PCR)
Olivar Lopez 2020 COVID‐19 510 15% Mexico ED All patients < 18 years who presented with a clinical picture compatible with COVID‐19 (= fever, respiratory symptoms or general malaise) at the ED of a COVID paediatric reference hospital RT‐PCR, nasopharyngeal swabs
O'Reilly 2020a COVID‐19 240 5% Australia ED Patients who meet the testing criteria for COVID‐19 and who present at the ED RT‐PCR, sample not specified
O'Reilly 2020b COVID‐19 1334 4% Australia ED All adult patients who met criteria for "suspected COVID‐19" and underwent testing for SARS‐CoV‐2 were eligible for inclusion. Testing criteria guided by various health jurisdictions and evolved throughout the project SARS‐CoV‐2 RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal swab)
Peyrony 2020 COVID‐19 391 58% France ED Patients tested at ED, decision to test based on clinician’s discretion RT‐PCR on nasal swabs
Pivetta 2020 COVID‐19 228 47% Italy ED All adults (≥18 years) who screened positive for acute symptoms associated with SARS‐CoV‐2 infection at triage (= fever, dyspnoea, new or worsening cough, sore throat, diarrhoea, ageusia, anosmia and asthenia) RT‐PCR (nasopharyngeal swabs), and in some cases other information including clinical, lab, imaging
Pokorska‐Śpiewak 2021 COVID‐19 319 5% Poland Mixed in/outpatient paediatric setting All consecutive paediatric patients referred to a tertiary healthcare department (referral based on clinical symptoms (WHO definition) of the disease or positive epidemiological history (international travel or contact with infected person) RT‐PCR (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Porto 2021 COVID‐19 1297 32% Brazil Outpatient setting All patients presenting at the Piquet Carneiro Polyclinic, test indication not specified, but high proportion of symptomatic individuals in recruited population RT‐PCR (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Romero‐Gameros 2020 COVID‐19 139 52% Mexico ED Patients who sought a respiratory triage assessment at ED of tertiary care hospital due to COVID‐19 suspicion RT‐PCR (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Romero‐Gameros 2021 COVID‐19 2137 54% Mexico ED Adults > 17 years, with high clinical probability of SARS‐CoV‐2 and confirmatory RT‐PCR available RT‐PCR (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Rutten 2020a COVID‐19 1969 44% The Netherlands Nursing home Patients with at least 2 of the following symptoms: fever/feverish feeling, cough and shortness of breath ‐ later on (from 10 April 2020) patients with atypical symptoms were added RT‐PCR test (specimen not specified)
Rutten 2020b COVID‐19 4007 38% The Netherlands Nursing home All nursing home residents with a clinical suspicion of COVID‐19 based on the physician's assessment and for whom they had the result of the RT‐PCR RT‐PCR test (specimen not specified)
Saegerman 2021 COVID‐19 2152 27% Belgium ED All suspected patients directed to the triage centres of 2 university hospital EDs (no definition of 'suspected') RT‐PCR test (specimen not specified)
Salmon Ceron 2020 COVID‐19 1824 47% France Outpatient setting Patients suspected of SARS‐CoV‐2 infection, tested at screening centre RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Trubiano 2020 COVID‐19 2935 4% Australia Outpatient setting Patients presenting at a COVID‐19 rapid assessment screening clinic, meeting DHHS screening criteriaa RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Tudrej 2020 COVID‐19 816 24% France Primary care/ outpatient setting Patients referred by GPs for PCR testing at lab RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Van Loon 2021 COVID‐19 373 50% Belgium Outpatient setting All hospital HCWs self‐reporting mild symptoms of an acute upper or lower respiratory tract infection were tested in a large non‐academic hospital RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal swab)
Van Walraven 2021 COVID‐19 9172 6% Canada Outpatient setting Presence of symptoms including rhinorrhoea; fever symptoms including rigor, chills, perceived fever, or documented fever at home or at the screening clinic; cough; and shortness of breath. Any infection risk factor including close contact with a person with known or presumed COVID‐19 disease or recent travel outside of Canada. In the absence of these indications, HCWs were included if they had symptoms of sore throat, sputum production, or rhinorrhoea. RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal and throat swabs)
Villerabel 2021 COVID‐19 809 7% France Outpatient setting All HCWs and adult patients presenting themselves at the COVID‐19 screening facility of the university hospital of Montpellier RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Wee 2020 COVID‐19 870 18% Singapore ED Patients presenting with respiratory symptoms or travel history RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Wernhart 2020 COVID‐19 80 6% Germany Primary care All patients with respiratory symptoms reporting to 3 rural GP offices in North Rhine‐Westphalia, Germany RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal swabs)
Yonker 2020 COVID‐19 174 28% USA Mixed in/outpatient paediatric setting Paediatric patients 22 years of age; symptoms concerning for COVID‐19 or admitted for acute symptoms related to COVID‐19 or multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children RT‐PCR test (nasopharyngeal or oropharyngeal swabs)
CT: computed tomography; ED: emergency department; GP: general practitioner; HCW: healthcare worker; MPOCT: molecular point‐of‐care test; RT‐PCR: reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction; WHO: World Health Organization

aDHHS (Victorian Department of Health and Human Services) criteria for SARS‐CoV‐2 testing: fever OR chills in the absence of an alternative diagnosis that explains the clinical presentation OR acute respiratory infection symptoms (e.g. cough, sore throat, shortness of breath, runny nose, loss of smell or loss of taste)