Skip to main content
HardwareX logoLink to HardwareX
. 2021 Jun 17;10:e00209. doi: 10.1016/j.ohx.2021.e00209

PARA: A one-meter reach, two-kg payload, three-DoF open source robotic arm with customizable end effector

Albert Tai 1,⁎, Michael Chun 1, Yuqiu Gan 1, Mert Selamet 1, Hod Lipson 1
PMCID: PMC9123426  PMID: 35607683

Graphical abstract

graphic file with name ga1.jpg

Keywords: Hardware, Mechanics, Robotic arm, Robotics, Additive manufacturing, 3D printing

Abstract

This article presents a robotic arm that is more cost effective than existing models on the market while still maintaining sufficient torque and speed capabilities. Most industrial-grade high power and precision arms are often very expensive, while conversely, more low-cost arms targeted toward the education and hobby sectors are inadequate in power and robustness. The Creative Machines Lab’s three degree of freedom Printed Articulated Robotic Arm (PARA) can lift a 2 kg payload at a reach of 940 mm, while under a no-load case, it has exhibited a precision of about ±2.6 mm at an end effector speed of 250 mm/s. It costs about $3400 to build, an order of magnitude lower than market models with similar functionalities. This project is also meant to serve as a demonstration of the usage of 3D printed parts as practical tools in industry.

1. Hardware in context

PARA is a three degree of freedom robotic arm which can lift approximately 2 kg at a 940 mm reach. The primary goal of the PARA project was to create a mostly 3D printed open-source robotic arm that is more cost effective than similar-scale proprietary arms on the market while still maintaining sufficient torque, speed, and precision capabilities. Many existing open-source robotic arms and low-cost arms targeted towards the education and hobby sectors are often inadequate in size and power. Additionally, their designs and functionalities are often poorly documented so they cannot be easily replicated. By being bigger and stronger than the average open-source arm and cheaper than many industrial-grade proprietary models, PARA fills a niche for multiple sectors. Amateur or small-scale manufacturers can use PARA for simple manual operations like pick-and-place which do not require the extreme amounts of precision associated with industrial models and their high price markups. With custom end effector attachments, PARA can also be used for tasks requiring tools such as drilling, screwing, or applying paint or adhesive. Researchers and educators can use PARA as a testbed for their own creations like custom end effectors or new control schema, or just use it as an educational tool. The readily-available CAD files and build instructions included in this article encourage users to customize and/or improve PARA’s designs for their own purposes. Finally, being primarily 3D printed, PARA also serves as a demonstration of the potential of additive manufacturing in advanced applications.

Specifications table:
Hardware name Printed Articulated Robotic Arm (PARA)
Subject area Educational Tools and Open Source Alternatives to Existing Infrastructure
Hardware type Mechanical engineering and materials science
Open source license MIT
Cost of hardware $3400
Source file repository https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/5AF4V

PARA strives to achieve a balance between functionality (with regards to power and precision) and affordability. In order to assess its specifications relative to other existing robotic arm models, 32 other existing commercial or open-source robotic arms were assessed, comparing parameters such as payload, reach, repeatability, and cost.

Fig. 1 plots payload versus load-lifting capabilities for various robotic arms. These arms (the diversity of which can be seen in Fig. 2) were categorized into two groups: arms intended for hobby/educational purposes and arms intended for industrial tasks like welding or heavy lifting. From observing the trendlines for both categories of arms, one can observe the clear difference in expected load-lifting capabilities between the two categories, with PARA, touting a maximum payload of 2 kg at a 940 mm reach, falling solidly on the blue trendline for hobby/educational arms. Observing Fig. 1, one can easily observe the novelty of PARA’s scale: its reach and maximum payload outclass most arms in the hobby/educational category. Many 3D printed arms with freely available parts on the Internet have shorter reach and lower load-bearing capabilities because of the smaller motors that they utilize. PARA circumvents these shortcomings by implementing powerful motors and utilizing large, robustly-designed printed parts. For example, the BCN3D Moveo, a popular open-source model, uses NEMA 17 Steppers with an approximately 0.6 Nm output [1]. Trossen Robotics’ Interbotix arms use Dynamixel XM-series motors [2], [3], which while precise, feature stall torques less than 5 Nm [4]. In contrast, PARA’s NEMA 34 motors have a 13 Nm output.

Fig. 1.

Fig. 1

Payload versus reach for available robotic arms (2020) in terms of absolute values (top) and percentages of PARA’s values (bottom). See Appendix for individual robot information corresponding to labeled points.

Fig. 2.

Fig. 2

The diversity of existing robotic arms. Top row (left to right): Columbia CML PARA, Ufactory UArm Swift [6], Universal Robotics UR3e [7]. Middle row: BCN3D Moveo [1], Thor [8], Trossen Robotics ViperX 250 [3]. Bottomw row: EEZY Robots EEZYbotArm v2 [9], Fanuc LR Mate 200iD [10], Oz Robtoics Niryo One [11].

Conversely, industrial strength robotic arms are often capable of lifting much greater loads at similar reaches due to their usage of metallic components and custom motors/gearboxes. These higher-end components come at the expense of cost: industrial-grade robotic arms at the similar size class offered by major manufacturers such as FANUC, KUKA, or Universal Robotics often cost tens of thousands of dollars [5], and are not affordable for many. A KUKA sales representative provided the following approximate costs for several KUKA industrial robotic arms similar in size to PARA (M. Robey, personal communication, January 19, 2019):

KUKA Model Reach (mm) Payload Capacity (kg) Payload Capacity (% of PARA) Approx. Cost (USD) Approx. Cost (% of PARA)
Agilus KR 3 R540 541 3 150 24,000 700
Agilus KR 4 R600 600 4 200 23,000 680
Agilus KR 10 R1100-2 1101 11 550 33,000 970
LBR iiwa 7 R800 800 7 350 77,000 2260

For many, equally as important as strength and functionality is affordability: PARA achieves cost reduction compared to proprietary market models by using relatively cheap parts and being easy to assemble. The arm’s parts are primarily 3D printed, meaning the same (often inexpensive) machine can produce a majority of the parts, rather than relying on distinct tooling for each individual component. The usage of plastic parts also presents cost-savings when compared to metal. Parts which cannot be printed such as fasteners and bearings are readily available on the Internet. Most importantly, PARA is open-source and the hardware is not driven by a necessity for profit: for example, users skip assembly costs by assembling PARA themselves. The arm is designed to be manufactured with minimal fabrication effort: the only instances of manual fabrication are drilling the arm’s base plate and linkage body tubes, sawing the linkage body tubes, and heat-setting several brass inserts into 3D printed parts. Additionally, users can customize or even improve the open-source arm to serve their own needs.

PARA currently costs about $3400 to build, but this price point could be further lowered by replacing the arm’s Clearpath servo motors ($713 and $631) – which are expensive due to their sophisticated internal control functionalities – with standard NEMA 34 and 23 stepper motors and encoders. If each stepper motor costs approximately $100, PARA’s cost would be driven down to around $1500.

Nonetheless, compared to other non-industrial models, PARA features greater load lifting capabilities per dollar. As previously stated, industrial robotic arms are often capable of lifting 2–3 times PARA’s max payload, however their price point is an order of magnitude greater. For a more apples-to-apples comparison, Fig. 3 plots load lifting capabilities versus price for just the hobby/educational grade robotic arms researched in this study.

Fig. 3.

Fig. 3

Payload versus cost for available robotic arms (2020) in terms of absolute values (top) and percentages of PARA’s values (bottom). See Appendix for individual robot information corresponding to labeled points.

At around $3400 to build, PARA can lift 0.59 grams per dollar, approximately 33% higher than a robot of identical cost if it followed the observed trendlines from Fig. 3. This advantage can be further increased by replacing the arm’s expensive motors.

Besides robotic arms, the open-source community has devised several alternate non-robotic arm solutions capable of performing similar functions to PARA (pick-and-place, tool handling, etc.). However, these solutions often rely on end effectors mounted on Cartesian CNC router-style or delta-style frames (Fig. 4). The OpenPnP project has even compiled a list of such open-source Cartesian-style pick-and-place machines, such as its own OpenPnP OpenBuilds machine [12]. While oftentimes relatively cheap and simple in construction, these machines require space-consuming mounting infrastructure like rails and gantries, and cannot maneuver into tight areas like a robotic arm can. The frames required for a traditional Cartesian-style or delta-style pick-and-place machine with an identical workspace to PARA would be enormous, spanning over 2 meters in each dimension.

Fig. 4.

Fig. 4

OpenBuilds by OpenPnP [13] (left) and “Delta Robot Open Source Project” by TunMaker [14] (right).

By featuring payload-lifting capabilities just 2–3 times less than industrial-grade robotic arms at a price point cheaper by an order of magnitude while being much larger and more powerful than similarly-priced robotic arms, PARA attempts to distinguish itself in the current market of robotic arms and provide an affordable yet functional alternative. It also seeks to serve as an educational tool for the research community: with its functional capabilities and accessible design files and build instructions, users are encouraged to implement their own features on PARA such as additional degrees of freedom, custom end effector attachments like grippers or tools, or more complex control schemes.

2. Hardware description

Technical specifications and dimensions for PARA are as follows:

Degrees of Freedom 3
Payload 2 kg
Repeatability ± 2.6 mm at 250 mm/s
Reach 940 mm
Cost Approx. $3400

Fig. 5 and Fig. 6 showcase PARA's critical dimensions and workspace. PARA features three joints and three linkages, which are labeled in Fig. 7. In this article, the joint between the base and central linkage will be referred to as the base joint, the joint between the central and bicep linkages will be referred to as the shoulder joint, and the joint between the bicep and forearm linkages will be referred to as the elbow joint.

Fig. 5.

Fig. 5

Engineering drawing of PARA with labeled dimensions.

Fig. 6.

Fig. 6

Workspace of PARA with labeled dimensions.

Fig. 7.

Fig. 7

High-Level overview of PARA parts.

The forearm linkage terminates at a mounting plate for the user to add custom actuators with additional degrees of freedom (see Fig. 8).

Fig. 8.

Fig. 8

PARA creating a watercolor artwork using a paintbrush mounted on its end effector mounting plate.

PARA’s linkages are actuated either by timing belt trains or individual timing belts, which are in turn driven by motors. A NEMA 23 motor actuates the base joint, while two NEMA 34 motors housed in the central linkage actuate the shoulder and elbow joints. The elbow joint motor actuates the forearm linkage completely independently of the rest of the arm, while the shoulder joint motor actuates both the shoulder and elbow joints at the same time (with PARA’s controls accounting for this interdependence by sending commands to the elbow joint motor and offsetting the forearm linkage’s motion while the shoulder joint is actuated, thus preserving the system’s three completely independent degrees of freedom).

The NEMA 23 motor which actuates the base joint is smaller than the NEMA 34 motors because it does not have to act against gravitational forces. The NEMA 34 motors were placed as close to the central axle of the arm as close as possible to minimize the system’s moment of inertia. The motors are powered by a 75 V power source and controlled by G-Code sent from a Smoothieware Smoothieboard 3D printer control board (these electonic components are easily replaceable with alternatives that are cheaper or more familiar to the user). Further detail on how PARA’s motors and power source were selected can be found in Section 2.6.

With a customizable end effector and considerable load-lifting capabilities, PARA can be customized for a variety of different tasks, such as:

  • •

    Small-scale automated pick and place operations

  • •

    Serving as a testbed for various robotics-related projects, such as novel end effectors or control systems

  • •

    Automated manufacturing operations such as drilling or bolt tightening via mounted power tools

  • •

    Manual task assistance for those with limited mobility

  • •

    Arts and entertainment

PARA was designed in imperial units due to the ubiquitous nature of hardware using that measurement system. Its various hardware and software components will now be described in detail in the following sections.

2.1. Linkage construction

With three degrees of freedom, PARA consists of three linkages: a forearm linkage, a bicep linkage, and a central linkage, which in turn is attached to a base. The central linkage, which primarily consists of printed parts, is by far the largest linkage in terms of print volume. Printing the body of this linkage in a single print process can be risky if left unattended, as the print could fail several hours into the job. Therefore, this central linkage body consists of several smaller pieces with shorter print times (Fig. 9) – if one of these smaller prints fails, the other portions of the linkage would still remain uncompromised. The pieces of the new central linkage are held together by 1/4–20 bolts and heat-set inserts.

Fig. 9.

Fig. 9

Several printed PARA pieces.

The bicep and forearm linkages each consist of two 3D printed end caps fastened to 12” long (304.8 mm) acrylic tubes with a 3.25” (82.6 mm) diameter and 1/8” (3.2 mm) wall thickness. These linkages are fastened to axles by set screws and to timing belt pulleys by bolts.

2.2. Linkage actuation system

PARA’s three degrees of freedom are actuated by a NEMA 23 motor and two NEMA 34 motors, which in turn drive 1” (25.4 mm) wide XL-series timing belt pulleys. The arm features both 3D printed and aluminum pulleys. The pulleys’ thickness ensures robustness through force distribution over a greater cross-sectional area (thus leading to less elastic deformation), while the large teeth characteristic of the XL profile help prevent belt slippage. A relatively large contact area between the system’s timing belts and timing belt pulleys also aid in preventing deformation of printed pulleys. How each linkage is actuated by pulleys and one or more timing belts can be seen in Fig. 10.

Fig. 10.

Fig. 10

Timing belts involved in actuating shoulder joint (top) and elbow joint (bottom).

Timing belts were chosen in favor of steel cables for two primary reasons. First off, the relatively small contact area of cables and the pulleys that drive them would lead to much greater stress concentrations on the pulleys, which would likely result in cables digging into the plastic pulleys. Additionally, anchoring cables to pulleys would require crimping the ends of those cables with ferrules – an extra manufacturing step not required for timing belts.

To increase load-lifting capabilities, gear ratios between driving and driven timing belt pulleys are maximized to the extent allowed by system packaging: a larger gear ratio would call for a larger driven pulley, which in turn would require greater axle distances between driven and driving gears. For the base joint, this axle distance is limited by the size of the base, which should be able to be printed on an approximately 8” × 8” (200 mm × 200 mm) baseplate. For the shoulder and elbow joints, axle distances are limited by the positions of the massive NEMA 34 motors that actuate those joints: the motors are placed as close to the base joint’s axle as possible to minimize the entire system’s moment of inertia. The base joint features a gear reduction of 1:2.7, while the shoulder and elbow joints feature gear reductions of 1:7.5.

For compact packaging and weight savings, PARA’s power transmission system shares axles between as many of the required timing belt pulleys as possible, though this is not without accompanying complications. From studying Fig. 10, one can observe how moving the bicep linkage will also move the elbow joint axle – and the 42 tooth timing belt that directly actuates forearm linkage – relative to the rest of the elbow joint’s power transmission system. Therefore, actuating the bicep linkage θ degrees will actually also actuate the forearm linkage by -θ. The controls for the arm compensate for this effect by applying power to the elbow joint while the shoulder joint is in motion. For example, if the forearm linkage has to remain a constant angle relative to the bicep linkage while the bicep linkage moves θ degrees, the control board will send commands to the elbow joint motor to also actuate that joint by θ degrees, thus cancelling out the -θ degree motion and resulting in zero net movement of the forearm linkage. Fortunately, this effect is not present the other way around – directly actuating the forearm linkage by itself will not actuate the bicep linkage. Therefore, if both the bicep and forearm linkage now have to move θ degrees, the control board would still actuate the shoulder joint by θ degrees, but now the elbow joint would be actuated by 2θ degrees. Thus PARA still maintains its three independent degrees of freedom.

A number of idler-based belt tensioners (Fig. 11) can be mounted adjacent to many of the system’s belts should those belts lose tension. These tensioners are loosened and tightened by turning and un-turning a bolt in the tensioner mechanism.

Fig. 11.

Fig. 11

CAD model showing tensioner assembly (left) and a detail view of the implemented tensioner mechanism on the central linkage (right).

2.3. Base joint

The arm’s central linkage is fixed to a 12” (304.8 mm)-long 5/8” (15.9 mm)-diameter bolt which is secured to two mounted bearings housed in the base (Fig. 12).

Fig. 12.

Fig. 12

CAD model showing PARA’s central axle assembly (left) and a detail view of the implemented thrust bearing mechanism (right).

PARA features a custom thrust ball bearing-like system which enables motion between the central linkage and the base. 21.5” (12.7 mm) ball bearing balls are placed in a circular track about 1.68” (42.7 mm) away from the central axle (Fig. 12). Two large steel washers sandwich the steel balls, thus all the load carried by the bearings is reacted by the washers rather than bare PLA plastic (which can deform due to the stress concentrations at the contact patch of the balls). 3D printed pieces guide the steel balls to ensure that they stay in their proper positions, however the majority of the load on these balls (vertical gravitational force) is still being reacted by the washers.

These steel balls aid in supporting the central linkage by reacting gravitational forces exerted on the bicep and forearm linkages at a radius relatively far away from the central axle. Actual ball or needle thrust bearings were not used because thrust bearings of a similar diameter are both rare and costly.

2.4. Shoulder and elbow joints

PARA’s shoulder joint consists of a 9” (228.6 mm) steel axle which passes through the bicep and central linkages. The bicep link is constrained to the axle via #10–32 thread set screws, while motion between the two linkages is enabled by ball bearings press-fit into the central linkage. Retaining rings hold the bearings in place (Fig. 13). Roller thrust bearings between the bicep linkage and timing belt pulley actuating the forearm linkage reduce friction between those parts.

Fig. 13.

Fig. 13

Detail view of PARA’s press-fit ball bearings with retaining rings.

The elbow joint consists of a 6” (152.4 mm) aluminum axle which passes through the bicep and forearm linkages. #10–32 set screws constrain the forearm linkage to the axle, while the bicep linkage is constrained to the axle via mounted bearings with embedded set screws.

2.5. Mounting plate

The end of the forearm linkage terminates in a mounting plate (Fig. 14) so that custom end effectors providing additional degrees of freedom can attach to PARA.

Fig. 14.

Fig. 14

Detail view of PARA’s end effector mounting plate.

2.6. Motor selection and electronics hardware

Although any NEMA 23 and 34 stepper motors should have the proper shaft and bolt mounting geometry to be compatible with PARA (albeit load-handling capabilities will be affected by using motors of differing holding torques), the version of PARA built by the Creative Machines Lab features Teknic Clearpath servo motors (CPM-SCHP-2341P-ELNB [1] with a max holding torque of 2.9 Nm for the base joint and CPM-SCHP-3441S-ELSB with a max holding torque of 13.0 Nm for the shoulder and elbow joints; see Fig. 15). While expensive, these motors were useful for prototyping due to their various built-in safety features, such as shutdown protocols for excessive current draw and operating temperature.

Fig. 15.

Fig. 15

Teknic Clearpath servo motors used in PARA: NEMA 23 CPM-SCHP-2341P-ELNB [15] and NEMA 34 CPM-SCHP-3441S-ELSB [16].

PARA’s motors were first selected via some simplified back-of-the-envelope calculations, assuming a desired capability to lift 1 kg of load at a 1 m reach (though after design iteration and empirical evaluation it surpassed this goal and proved capable of supporting 2 kg). Once the development of the robot progressed, these calculations were then further verified through more in-depth analysis incorporating the rest of the robot’s design.

Preliminary calculations assumed two 3 kg motors (the approximate mass of most NEMA 23 and 34 models) housed 100 mm away from a central axle. The length of the arm’s bicep (shoulder joint to elbow joint) and forearm linkages (elbow joint to end effector) were both assumed to be 500 mm. The mass of the rest of the robot (which would primarily consist of 3D printed and acrylic parts) was assumed to be negligible for now.

Fig. 16 details this rudimentary model. The joints have been denoted with a “prime” symbol. The moment of inertia about the elbow (θZ′), shoulder (θY′), and base (θX′) joints (accounting for the payload) can be calculated as follows:

IθZ′=1kg ·(0.5m)2=0.25kgm2 (1)
IθY′=1kg·(1m)2=1kgm2 (2)
IθX′=2·3kg ·(0.1m)2+1kg ·(1m)2=1.06kgm2 (3)

Fig. 16.

Fig. 16

Initial model for PARA linkage mass properties.

To approximate the arm’s desired angular accelerations, a desired end effector velocity of 250–1000 mm/s in each translational direction was established. Given the estimated robot dimensions, this range of end effector velocities would resolve to desired joint velocities of 0.25–1.00 rad/s (2.4–9.5 rpm) for θX′ and θY′, and 0.5–2.00 rad/s (4.8–19.0 rpm) for θZ′.

Assuming extremely rudimentary triangular velocity profiles for each joint across an angular sweep of π radians (Fig. 17):

Fig. 17.

Fig. 17

Triangular angular velocity profile with an average velocity of ωavg.

The desired angular acceleration for each joint would then equal 4/π*ωavg2. These values equal 0.08–1.27 rad/s2 for θX′ and θY′, and 0.32–5.09 rad/s2 for θZ′.

Using the simple relationship τ=Ia, the required torque ranges to accelerate the various joints to the desired values (neglecting the effects of gravity) would equal 0.08–1.34 Nm for θX′, 0.08–1.27 Nm for θY′, and 0.08–1.27 Nm for θZ′. Meanwhile, the torques required to counteract gravitational force at the worst case scenario would equal 4.91 Nm (0.5 m ⋅ 1 kg ⋅ 9.81 m/s2) at θZ′ and 9.81 Nm (1 m ⋅ 1 kg ⋅ 9.81 m/s2) at θY′. Combining these values yields maximum desired torque values of 1.34 Nm for θX′, 11.08 Nm at θY′, and 6.18 Nm at θZ′.

A NEMA 23 motor with a maximum torque of 2.9 Nm was chosen to actuate θX′, while a NEMA 34 motor with a maximum torque of 13.0 Nm was chosen to actuate θZ′ (for a factor of safety of about 2 for both motors). The same NEMA 34 motor was also chosen for θY′. Though the maximum desired torque (11.08 Nm) was close to the maximum operating torque of the NEMA 34 motor (13.0 Nm), any larger motor would’ve been impractical in terms of mass and cost. A gear ratio would have to be applied to increase the motor’s torque output.

After more practical design work was conducted on the arm, the efficacy of the selected motors was once again evaluated. Applying mass properties to various linkages of the arm in CAD yielded the mass and moment of inertia seen in Fig. 18:

Fig. 18.

Fig. 18

Refined model for PARA linkage mass properties informed by CAD data.

The moment of inertia about the elbow (θZ), shoulder (θY), and base (θX) joints for this practical model could then be calculated as follows:

IθZ=1.21kg  ·(0.20m)2+1kg ·(0.46m)2=0.26kgm2 (4)
IθY=2.77kg ·(0.22m)2+1.21kg ·(0.48m+0.20m)2+1kg ·(0.48m+0.46m)2=1.58kgm2 (5)
IθX=0.10kgm2+2.77kg ·(0.22m)2+1.21kg ·(0.48m+0.20m)2+1kg ·(0.48m+0.46m)2=1.68kgm2 (6)

Using these actual moment of inertia values and the previously-calculated desired angular acceleration values, the new desired torque ranges would equal 0.13–2.13 Nm for θX, 0.13–2.00 Nm for θY, and 0.08–1.32 Nm for θZ. Once again combining these values with worst-case gravitational forces yields maximum desired torque values of 2.13 Nm for θX, 11.81 Nm at θY, and 6.23 Nm at θZ.

Ultimately, end effector speed was sacrificed in favor of payload capacity for PARA, and the design sought to maximize the gear ratio of each joint within allowable packaging. As previously stated, θX features a gear reduction of 1:2.7, while θY and θZ feature gear reductions of 1:7.5. Therefore, for the initial 1 kg goal, the required output torque for the base joint would be 0.79 Nm, while the required output torques for the shoulder and elbow joints respectively would equal 1.57 Nm and 0.83 Nm. These values fall comfortably into the operating torque ranges for the selected motors – in fact, working through these calculations backwards and solving for the max load which can actuated by each joint with the provided motor torque capabilities yields theoretical maximum payloads of 6.1 kg for the base joint, 8.8 kg for the shoulder joint, and 16.3 kg for the elbow joint. Actual empirical testing, however, demonstrated that these axes could only operate payloads of about 2 kg before encountering other sources of mechanical failure such as belt slippage. Still, this value is greater than the designed payload of 1 kg.

PARA's required power capacity was determined by multiplying by the worst-case motor torques by worst-case angular velocities. The arm’s motors are daisy-chained together and powered by a Teknic IPC-5 75 V power supply [3]. Performing the previous calculations once more with a payload of 2 kg yields worst-case motor torques of 1.20 Nm for θX, 3.03 Nm for θY, and 1.63 Nm for θZ. The maximum joint angular velocities in these events were previously calculated as 1.27 rad/s2 for θX′/θX and θY′/θY, and 5.09 rad/s2 for θZ′/θZ. Taking gear ratios into account, the angular velocities at the motors would equal 3.43 rad/s for θX, 9.53 rad/s for θY, and 38.18 rad/s for θZ. Since P=τω, the maximum power required for each joint can be assumed to be 4.12 W for θX, 28.88 W for θY, and 62.23 W for θZ for a combined theoretical max power usage of 95.23 W. Thus, the 75VDC 300 W IPC-5 continuous power supply was chosen to satisfy this power requirement with a reasonable factor of safety of about 3.

The motors are controlled by a Smoothieboard control board [4] (Fig. 19). Intended for controlling 3D printers, the Smoothieboard was chosen for its on-board motor drivers and ease with interpreting commands. The Smoothieboard can support controlling up to six stepper motors at once for adding additional degrees of freedom to the arm, and its firmware can be easily modified to set motor parameters such as step size. Various free-to-download pieces of software, such as Pronterface from the Printrun suite, can be used to send G-Code commands to the Smoothieboard to control the motors.

Fig. 19.

Fig. 19

Smoothieboard used to control PARA.

Although alternatives for the Teknic motors and the Smoothieboard can be used, this article will focus on supporting these pieces of hardware.

An additional three-tiered electronics housing (Fig. 20) can also be printed and installed on PARA’s base to house the arm’s Smoothieboard controller and 75 V power supply. This housing also serves as a brace for the various cables linked to the Smoothieboard, which can be zip tied to the housing for strain protection.

Fig. 20.

Fig. 20

Various components of PARA electronics tower assembly (top-to-bottom): lid, control board, and power source.

2.7. Controls and software

As with most robots and robotic arms, the motor commands required to move PARA can be computed in several different ways.

This article presents two. The first method involves loading a URDF file for PARA in a software package with kinetic-simulating capabilities such as Pybullet or ROS (Fig. 21). For those who wish to write their own kinematics engine, the second involves directly using matrix operations to manually compute forward and inverse kinematics.

Fig. 21.

Fig. 21

PARA URDF file loaded in PyBullet kinematics engine.

These methods allow for translating Cartesian commands into desired angles and angular velocities for each motor. As the PARA project was primarily a study in hardware, the acceleration profiles for each joint were not extensively developed, and controls for PARA remain a topic of further study. Clearpath’s proprietary software was used to empirically “tune” each motor based on encountered loads and develop closed-loop control schema for each individual motor. However, much future work can still be performed in this area: rotary encoders and accelerometers mounted in various locations on the arm could allow for the development of more sophisticated PID or PIV control laws for PARA. The mass and moment of inertia information included with PARA’s CAD model could also be used to implement gravity compensation in PARA’s controls.

2.7.1. URDF

As PARA is an articulated robotic arm with three degrees of freedom (DOF), there are three links: the central link, bicep link, and forearm link, and three revolute joints to connect them: the base joint, shoulder joint, and elbow joint. These links and joints are defined in a provided URDF file.

In the URDF file, the kinematic information is encapsulated in the “joint” tags. The “origin” of joint tells where this joint is placed relative to the previous coordinate system.

To aid in visual representation of the arm’s movements, also provided are.STL files representing the various robot links referenced by the URDF file.

Also provided is a sample Python script which uses the PyBullet library in order to translate Cartesian directions for end effector movement into motor angles. The script also translates these angles into GCode commands for the Teknic servos used in this article and sends these commands to the Smoothieboard.

2.7.2. Forward kinematics

Forward Kinematics solves the following question: given all the joint values in the kinematic chain, what is the transform from the base of the chain to each link?

Due to the simplicity of the 3-DOF PARA, the Cartesian position of the end effector frame as functions of joint angles can be computed using just basic trigonometry. LA,LB, and LG denote the length of the Central Link, Bicep Link, and Forearm Link. The base joint angle, shoulder joint angle, and elbow joint angle have been represented as (θX,θY,θZ).

Firstly, as joint X just rotates the arm in the vertical plane, one can simplfiy this 3D problem into a 2D problem by just analyzing the Y, Z joints (Fig. 22).

Fig. 22.

Fig. 22

Analysis of X, Y, an Z joint angles in 3D space (top) and simplification to just Y and Z joints in 2D space (bottom).

Consulting Fig. 22, b,c denote the y, z coordinates of the end effector in the 2D space. One can easily generate functions for the coordinates of the end effector:

b=cosθY·LB+cos(θY-θZ)·LGc=sinθY·LB+sin(θY-θZ)·LG

Now, back to the 3D space problem. In this case, parameters a, b, c denote the x, y, z coordinates of the end effector in 3D space.

r=cosθY·LB+cos(θY-θZ)·LGa=cosθX·rb=sinθX·rc=LA+sinθY·LB+sin(θY-θZ)·LG

One can also compute the position of the end effector frame via linear algebra. Using URDF notation:

  • •

    BTee: The transformation matrix from base-link’s coordinate to the end effector’s.

  • •

    qi: The joint value for joint i

  • •

    TLB: The translation of base-link

  • •

    TLi: The translation of link i

  • •

    TJi: The rotation matrix of joint i

  • •

    θi: the rotation angle of each joint

Thus:

BTee=TLB·TJX(qX)·TLa·TJY(qY)·TLb·TJZ(qZ)·TLg

Based on the inter-link translatio n and rotation matrices contained in the URDF file:

graphic file with name fx6.jpg

graphic file with name fx7.jpg

graphic file with name fx8.jpg

graphic file with name fx9.jpg

graphic file with name fx10.jpg

graphic file with name fx11.jpg

graphic file with name fx12.jpg

2.7.3. Inverse kinematics

Simplifying the problem to the 2D plane defined by the Y and Z linkages again, the end effector’s position X∈R2. Suppose once more X=(b,c) and LB,LG denote the length of Bicep Link and Forearm Link, as in Fig. 22. The aim is to compute the value of θ∈R2 which can satisfy the arm to achieve the point X. One can derive the following relations:

r=b2+c2
r2=(LB+cosθZ·LG)2+(sinθZ·LG)2
θZ=acosb2+c2-LB2-LG22LB·LG
θα=atan2(c,b)
θβ=acosLB+cosθZ·LGr
θY=θα+θβ

So, the problem in 2D is solved. Moving to 3D space, where X∈R3,θ∈R3 which satisfies the arm to achieve the point X∈R3 must be solved.

Suppose X=(a,b,c), as in Fig. 22:

θX=atan2(b,a)

Where LA denotes the length of the Central Link. Similarly, one can generate equations to compute θY and θZ if c is replaced in previous equations with c-LA and b is replaced with a2+b2.

Note: These equations use a function called atan2(y,x), which returns the angle from the origin to a point (x,y) in the plane. It is similar to the inverse tangent tan-1(yx), but whereas tan-1(yx) is equal to tan-1(-y-x), and therefore tan-1 only returns angles in the range (-π2,π2), the atan2 function returns angles in the range (-π,π).

3. Design files

3.1. Design files summary

Design filename File type Open source license Location of the file
PARA CAD Assembly .SLDPRT and.SLDASM CAD files MIT https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/5AF4V
PARA.STL Files .STL files MIT https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/5AF4V
PARA.URDF Files .URDF and.STL files MIT https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/5AF4V
PARA Servo Tune Files .MTR files MIT https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/5AF4V
PARA_CartesianControlsDemo .PY file MIT https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/5AF4V
Config .TXT file MIT https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/5AF4V

"PARA CAD Assembly" contains the complete CAD model of PARA as constructed in SolidWorks. For those without access to the SolidWorks software, Grabcad[5]offers free conversion services from sldprt to formats such as STEP and IGES.

"PARA.STL Files" contains .STL files of all the PARA components that require 3D printing.

"PARA.URDF Files" contains a .URDF file of the three-axis PARA for use with software packages with kinetic-simulation capabilities like PyBullet or ROS. It also contains .STL files for visual representation of PARA’s linkages.

"PARA Servo Tune Files" contains .MTR configuration files used with the Teknic Clearview Clearpath motor tuning software.

"PARA_CartesianControlsDemo" is a Python script which demonstrates serial communication with a Smoothieboard and implementing commands for end effector cartesian controls.

".Config" is a .txt file used to provide a Smoothieboard with the motor steps per mm travel and acceleration values used with the version of PARA presented in this article.

4. Bill of materials

PARA’s components can be split into off-the-shelf purchased components and custom printed components. All components listed total around $3400.

4.1. Purchased components

Component QTY Cost/Unit Total Cost Source Type
Mounted Roller Bearing with Two-Bolt Flange (for 1/2” Shaft Diameter) 2 $18.24 $36.48 https://www.mcmaster.com/1434k6 Metal
2024 Aluminum Keyed Rotary Shaft (Fully Keyed, 1/2” Diameter, 6” Long) 3 $13.67 $41.01 https://www.mcmaster.com/1570k41 Metal
Needle-Roller Thrust Bearing (for 1/2” Shaft Diameter, 15/16” OD) 2 $3.33 $6.66 https://www.mcmaster.com/5909k31 Metal
0.032” Thick Washer for 1/2” Shaft Diameter Needle-Roller Thrust Bearing 4 $1.10 $4.40 https://www.mcmaster.com/5909k44 Metal
Ball Bearing (Open, Trade Number R8, for 1/2” Shaft Diameter) 7 $6.27 $43.89 https://www.mcmaster.com/60355k505 Metal
L Series Timing Belt, Trade No. 420L100 1 $38.66 $38.66 https://www.mcmaster.com/6484k358 Polymer
L Series Timing Belt, Trade No. 158L100 5 $18.44 $92.20 https://www.mcmaster.com/6484k717 Polymer
Low-Profile Mounted Sealed Steel Ball Bearing (Two-Bolt Flange, for 1/2” Shaft Diameter, Fixed Alignment) 2 $33.30 $66.60 https://www.mcmaster.com/7208k52 Metal
304 Stainless Steel Keyed Rotary Shaft (Fully Keyed, 1/2” Diameter, 9” Long) 1 $20.99 $20.99 https://www.mcmaster.com/7398k6 Metal
316 Stainless Steel Washer (for Number 10 Screw Size, 0.203” ID, 0.438” OD) 31 $0.04 $1.13 https://www.mcmaster.com/90107a011 Metal
316 Stainless Steel Washer (for 1/4” Screw Size, 0.281” ID, 0.625” OD) 36 $0.07 $2.56 https://www.mcmaster.com/90107a029 Metal
316 Stainless Steel Washer (for 5/8” Screw Size, 0.688” ID, 1.5” OD) 1 $0.63 $0.63 https://www.mcmaster.com/90107a035 Metal
316 Stainless Steel Washer (for 3/8” Screw Size, 0.406” ID, 0.75” OD) 8 $0.35 $2.82 https://www.mcmaster.com/90107a127 Metal
Zinc-Plated Alloy Steel Socket Head Screw (10–24 Thread Size, 5/8” Long) 21 $0.14 $3.01 https://www.mcmaster.com/90128a221 Metal
Zinc-Plated Alloy Steel Socket Head Screw (10–24 Thread Size, 1–1/2” Long) 22 $0.22 $4.76 https://www.mcmaster.com/90128a226 Metal
Zinc-Plated Alloy Steel Socket Head Screw (1/4”-20 Thread Size, 1” Long) 46 $0.25 $11.72 https://www.mcmaster.com/90128a247 Metal
Zinc-Plated Alloy Steel Socket Head Screw (7/16”-14 Thread Size, 1–1/4” Long) 12 $0.86 $10.36 https://www.mcmaster.com/90128a406 Metal
Zinc-Plated Alloy Steel Socket Head Screw (3/8”-16 Thread Size, 1” Long) 4 $0.51 $2.05 https://www.mcmaster.com/90128a624 Metal
Low-Strength Steel Thin Nylon-Insert Locknut (Zinc-Plated, 7/16”-14 Thread Size) 4 $0.07 $0.27 https://www.mcmaster.com/90566a032 Metal
Low-Strength Steel Thin Nylon-Insert Locknut (Zinc-Plated, 5/8”-11 Thread Size) 1 $0.21 $0.21 https://www.mcmaster.com/90566a035 Metal
High-Strength Steel Nylon-Insert Locknut (Grade 8, 7/16”-14 Thread Size) 4 $0.39 $1.56 https://www.mcmaster.com/90630a112 Metal
High-Strength Steel Nylon-Insert Locknut (Grade 8, 3/8”-16 Thread Size) 9 $0.16 $1.44 https://www.mcmaster.com/90630a121 Metal
Low-Strength Steel Nylon-Insert Locknut (Zinc-Plated, 10–24 Thread Size) 16 $0.03 $0.53 https://www.mcmaster.com/90631a011 Metal
Low-Strength Steel Nylon-Insert Locknut (Zinc-Plated, 10–24 Thread Size) 6 $0.03 $0.19 https://www.mcmaster.com/90633A011 Metal
Black-Oxide Alloy Steel Socket Head Screw (5/8”-11 Thread Size, 12” Long) 1 $15.40 $15.40 https://www.mcmaster.com/91251a137 Metal
Alloy Steel Shoulder Screw (1/4” Shoulder Diameter, 5/8” Shoulder Length, 10–24 Thread) 1 $1.21 $1.21 https://www.mcmaster.com/91259A539 Metal
Alloy Steel Shoulder Screw (1/4” Shoulder Diameter, 1” Shoulder Length, 10–24 Thread) 3 $1.31 $3.93 https://www.mcmaster.com/91259A542 Metal
Alloy Steel Shoulder Screw (1/2” Shoulder Diameter, 3–3/4” Shoulder Length, 3/8”-16 Thread) 5 $4.96 $24.80 https://www.mcmaster.com/91259a727 Metal
18–8 Stainless Steel Socket Head Screw (M3.5 x 0.60 mm Thread, 14 mm Long) 5 $2.26 $11.31 https://www.mcmaster.com/91292A351/ Metal
Low-Strength Steel Cap Nut (Zinc-Plated, 1/4”-20 Thread Size) 4 $0.32 $1.29 https://www.mcmaster.com/91875A130 Metal
316 Stainless Steel SAE Washer (for 7/16” Screw Size, 0.469” ID, 0.922” OD) 16 $0.53 $8.52 https://www.mcmaster.com/91950a048 Metal
18–8 Stainless Steel Washer (for 1–3/4” Screw Size, 1.812” ID, 3.5” OD) 2 $2.31 $4.62 https://www.mcmaster.com/92141a044 Metal
18–8 Stainless Steel Cup-Point Set Screw (10–24 Thread, 1/2” Long) 17 $0.06 $1.02 https://www.mcmaster.com/92311a242 Metal
LDPE Unthreaded Spacer (3/4” OD, 3/4” Long, for 1/4” Screw Size) 3 $0.50 $1.51 https://www.mcmaster.com/92825A146 Polymer
LDPE Unthreaded Spacer (3/4” OD, 3/8” Long, for 1/4” Screw Size) 1 $0.39 $0.39 https://www.mcmaster.com/92825A415 Polymer
Tapered Heat-Set Inserts for Plastic (10–24 Thread Size, 0.225” Installed Length, Brass) 39 $0.20 $7.85 https://www.mcmaster.com/93365a150 Metal
Tapered Heat-Set Inserts for Plastic (1/4”-20 Thread Size, 0.3” Installed Length, Brass) 48 $0.40 $19.37 https://www.mcmaster.com/93365a160 Metal
Nylon Hex Nut (M3.5 x 0.6 mm Thread) 3 $0.12 $0.37 https://www.mcmaster.com/93800A450-93800A120/ Polymer
Hardened 440C Stainless Steel Ball (1/2” Diameter) 21 $0.81 $16.95 https://www.mcmaster.com/9529k22 Metal
Medium-Strength Steel Hex Nut (Grade 5, Zinc-Plated, 1/4”-20 Thread Size) 2 $0.05 $0.10 https://www.mcmaster.com/95462a029 Metal
Internal Retaining Ring (for 1–1/8” ID, Black-Phosphate 1060–1090 Spring Steel) 5 $0.24 $1.22 https://www.mcmaster.com/99142a480 Metal
VXB.625 in Square Flanged Cast Housing Mounted Bearing (UCF 201–8) 2 $12.95 $25.90 https://www.vxb.com/1-2-UCF-201-8-Square-Flanged-Cast-Housing-Mounted-p/kit16127.htm?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIr6_Ih4_L6AIVAo3ICh3S-wKDEAYYASABEgKGfPD_BwE Metal
13 Tooth, 1/2” Inside x 1.522” Outside Diam, Timing Belt Pulley (1” Belt Width, 1.552” Pitch Diam, Steel & Cast Iron) 4 $34.21 $136.84 https://www.mscdirect.com/product/details/35376375 Metal
13 Tooth, 3/8” Inside x 1.522” Outside Diam, Hub & Flange Timing Belt Pulley (1” Belt Width, 1.552” Pitch Diam, 1–1/4” Face Width, Aluminum) 1 $27.10 $27.10 https://www.mscdirect.com/product/details/86235058 Metal
Smoothieboard 1 $94.74 $94.74 https://www.amazon.com/Motherboard-Engraving-Smoothieboard-Firmware-Accessories/dp/B08D75ZZ2H
CPM-SCHP-2341P-ELNB Servo Motor 1 $631.00 $631.00 https://www.teknic.com/model-info/CPM-SCHP-2341P-ELNB/ Electronic
CPM-SCHP-3441S-ELSB Servo Motor 2 $713.00 $1,426.00 https://www.teknic.com/model-info/CPM-SCHP-3441S-ELSB/ Electronic
IPC-5 75 V Power Supply 1 $248.00 $248.00 https://www.teknic.com/ipc-5/ Electronic
DC Power Cable (CPM-CABLE-PWR-MS120) 1 $19.00 $19.00 https://www.teknic.com/accessories-wizard/ Electronic
24 Volt Power, 2-Pin Molex Cable (CPM-CABLE-M2P2P-120) 2 $19.00 $38.00 https://www.teknic.com/accessories-wizard/ Electronic
Controller Cable (CPM-CABLE-CTRL-MU120) 3 $23.00 $69.00 https://www.teknic.com/clearpath-accessories-guide/accessories-guide-sc-dc/#controller-cables Electronic
AC Power Cable for IPC-3 and IPC-5 (IPC35-CABLE110) 1 $14.00 $14.00 https://www.teknic.com/clearpath-accessories-guide/accessories-guide-sd-dc/#power-supplies Electronic
3.25” Diameter 12” Length Acrylic Tube 2 $7.32 $14.64 https://www.usplastic.com/catalog/item.aspx?itemid=32524 Polymer
Base Plate 1 $22.84 $22.84 https://www.homedepot.com/p/1-in-x-2-ft-x-2-ft-Pine-Edge-Glued-Panel-Round-Board-ZPRLR0124/204485287 Wood
Rubber Feet Bumper 6 $2.75 $16.49 https://www.amazon.com/Extra-Large-Round-Rubber-Bumpers/dp/B00S4HVES8
PLA Filament (1 kg) 6 $19.99 $119.94 https://www.matterhackers.com/store/l/300mm-pla-filament-red-1-kg/sk/MM8DY4PS Polymer

4.2. Printed parts

Note: Recommended support density is 8%. Print times were calculated assuming a 0.6 mm nozzle at 70 mm/s print speed.

Part Name QTY Layer Height (mm) Infill % Support? Est. Print Time Print Orientation

13T Elbow Timing Pulley 1 0.2 80 N/A 2:19:00 graphic file with name fx13.gif
34T Central Link Timing Pulley 1 0.2 60 N/A 10:23:00 graphic file with name fx14.gif
34T Shoulder Timing Pulley 1 0.2 60 N/A 7:45:00 graphic file with name fx15.gif
Base Body 1 0.3 40 Everywhere 22:31:00 graphic file with name fx16.gif
Base Lid 1 0.25 40 Touching Buildplate 11:16:00 graphic file with name fx17.gif
Base Rim 1 0.25 40 N/A 5:15:00 graphic file with name fx18.gif
Base Tensioner Housing 1 0.15 60 Touching Buildplate 2:20:00 graphic file with name fx19.gif
Base Tensioner Spacer 1 0.2 60 N/A 0:47:00 graphic file with name fx20.gif
Base/Central Link Tensioner Body 3 0.15 100 N/A 1:52:00 graphic file with name fx21.gif
Base Joint Inner Lower Race 1 0.15 80 Touching Buildplate 2:27:00 graphic file with name fx22.gif
Base Joint Outer Lower Race 1 0.15 80 Touching Buildplate 5:00:00 graphic file with name fx23.gif
Bicep Link Inboard Cap 1 0.25 60 Touching Buildplate 21:39:00 graphic file with name fx24.gif
Bicep Link Outboard Cap 1 0.25 60 Everywhere 12:53:00 graphic file with name fx25.gif
Bicep Link Tensioner Body 1 0.15 100 N/A 2:39:00 graphic file with name fx26.gif
Bicep Link Tensioner Housing 1 0.15 100 Touching Buildplate 4:40:00 graphic file with name fx27.gif
Central Link Base Plate 2 0.2 60 Touching Buildplate 9:19:00 graphic file with name fx28.gif
Central Link Base Timing Pulley 1 0.2 80 N/A 9:39:00 graphic file with name fx29.gif
Central Link Central Strut 1 0.25 80 N/A 13:25:00 graphic file with name fx30.gif
Central Link Side Plate 2 0.25 40 Everywhere 16:45:00 graphic file with name fx31.gif
Central Link Tensioner Body 2 0.15 100 N/A 2:29:00 graphic file with name fx32.gif
Central Link Tensioner Housing 2 0.15 60 Touching Buildplate 2:20:00 graphic file with name fx33.gif
Compound Timing Pulley 1 0.2 80 N/A 10:04:00 graphic file with name fx34.gif
Drill Jig 1 0.25 40 N/A 5:21:00 graphic file with name fx35.gif
Elbow Joint Coupler 2 0.15 80 N/A 1:27:00 graphic file with name fx36.gif
Electronics Tower Lid 1 0.15 20 Touching Buildplate 9:37:00 graphic file with name fx37.gif
Electronics Tower Spacer 4 0.25 20 N/A 0:04:00 graphic file with name fx38.gif
Forearm Link Inboard Cap 1 0.25 60 Touching Buildplate 15:00:00 graphic file with name fx39.gif
Mounting Plate 1 0.25 60 N/A 8:43:00 graphic file with name fx40.gif
Power Supply Housing 1 0.25 20 N/A 9:08:00 graphic file with name fx41.gif
Smoothieboard Housing 1 0.25 20 N/A 5:00:00 graphic file with name fx42.gif
Timing Pulley Cap 2 0.15 40 Touching Buildplate 4:00:00 graphic file with name fx43.gif

5. Build instructions

5.1. Safety concerns

Before preparing and assembling PARA’s components, note the following safety concerns. For concerns pertaining to operating PARA once it is built, see Section 6.1.

  • •

    Though designed to be minimal, assembling PARA requires some drilling and cutting operations involving hand tools. Wear appropriate personal protective equipment (safety goggles) while performing these operations and ensure that parts are properly secured using clamps or a vice before being cut or drilled.

  • •

    NEMA 34 and 23 stepper motors have relatively high input voltages and operating currents compared to most motors used in the consumer electronics and hobby sectors (for example, the motors suggested in this article draw 4 amps per phase at up to 75 volts), thus appropriate caution should be exercised when handling them. Ensure power supply is off and/or disconnected from AC wall supply before plugging and unplugging cables from steppers. Ensure hands are dry when handling power electronics.

  • •

    The tip of a soldering iron can reach hundreds of degrees Celsius and leave serious burns if in contact with skin. Exercise caution when using a soldering iron to either connect wire leads or install heat-set inserts.

  • •

    Several of PARA’s subassemblies, such as the base and central link, are considerably heavy. If dropped, these parts can result in damages to the hardware, user, or both. During assembly and service, take care to prevent fingers and skin from being pinched near the arm’s joints.

  • •

    When assembling PARA, tighten all fasteners until a reasonable amount of resistance is encountered to ensure that the arm doesn’t fall apart during operation. All nuts used on PARA have thread locking features to ensure that they don’t loosen over time, but the arm’s set screws do not. Apply Loctite Threadlocker adhesive to these set screws for more secure retention.

5.2. Tools needed

  • •

    1/8” Hex Wrench

  • •

    5/32” Hex Wrench

  • •

    3/16” Hex Wrench

  • •

    1/4” Hex Wrench

  • •

    5/16” Hex Wrench

  • •

    3/8” Hex Wrench

  • •

    1/2” Hex Wrench

  • •

    2.5 mm Hex Wrench

  • •

    7/16” Wrench

  • •

    3/8” Wrench

  • •

    9/16’ Wrench

  • •

    Adjustable Wrench

  • •

    1/4” and 1/8” Drill Bits

  • •

    3D Printer (With at least 8” × 8” × 8” buidpltae)

  • •

    Soldering Iron

  • •

    Hand Saw or Bandsaw

  • •

    Rubber Mallet (Helpful)

5.3. Build instructions

Step 1: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into base lid.

graphic file with name fx44.jpg

Step 2: Fasten servo motor to base lid.

graphic file with name fx45.jpg

Step 3: Fasten square mounted bearing to base lid.

graphic file with name fx46.jpg

Step 4: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into base body.

graphic file with name fx47.jpg

Step 5: Fasten square mounted bearing to base body.

graphic file with name fx48.jpg

Step 6: Fasten assembled base lid onto assembled base body.

graphic file with name fx49.jpg

Step 7: Sandwich washer between lower race pieces and fasten assembly onto base lid.

graphic file with name fx50.jpg

Step 8: Insert bolt into mounted bearings and tighten set screws.

graphic file with name fx51.jpg

Step 9: Drill the indicated hole geometry in a 1” thick base plate.

graphic file with name fx52.jpg

Step 10: Fasten base body and base rim to base plate.

graphic file with name fx53.jpg

Step 11: Fix rubber feet.75” or longer on underside of base.

graphic file with name fx54.jpg

Step 12: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into side plates.

graphic file with name fx55.jpg

Step 13: Press-fit ball bearings into side plates.

graphic file with name fx56.jpg

Step 14: Snap retaining rings into grooves adjacent to ball bearings.

graphic file with name fx57.jpg

Step 15: Fasten motors to side plates.

graphic file with name fx58.jpg

Step 16: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into central strut.

graphic file with name fx59.jpg

Step 17: Fasten roller bearings to central strut. Take care to install fasteners in correct order.

graphic file with name fx60.jpg

Step 18: Fasten base plates to central strut.

graphic file with name fx61.jpg

Step 19: Slide nuts into sockets of base timing pulley.

graphic file with name fx62.jpg

Step 20: Press-fit washer onto base timing pulley.

graphic file with name fx63.jpg

Step 21: Place base timing pulley onto base with steel balls in between grooves.

graphic file with name fx64.jpg

Step 22: Place L series timing belt around timing pulleys and fix 13T steel timing pulley to base motor shaft with set screw.

graphic file with name fx65.jpg

Step 23: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into base tensioner housing.

graphic file with name fx66.jpg

Step 24: Assemble various components of base tensioner.

graphic file with name fx67.jpg

Step 25: Mount base tensioner and base tensioner spacer onto base. Turn tensioner bolt to tension timing belt.

graphic file with name fx68.jpg

Step 26: Fasten central link base plates and central strut to base timing pulley. Secure central link to central axle with nut and washer.

graphic file with name fx69.jpg

Step 27: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into compound elbow timing pulley.

graphic file with name fx70.jpg

Step 28: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into 34T shoulder timing pulley.

graphic file with name fx71.jpg

Step 29: Press-fit ball bearing into 34T shoulder timing pulley and snap retaining ring into adjacent groove.

graphic file with name fx72.jpg

Step 30: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into bicep link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx73.jpg

Step 31: Press-fit ball bearings into bicep link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx74.jpg

Step 32: Fasten 34T shoulder timing pulley to bicep link inboard cap. Ensure that L series timing belt rests between pulley flange and inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx75.jpg

Step 33: Pass keyed rotary shaft through bicep link inboard cap, compound elbow timing pulley, and indicated components. Take care to assemble with components in correct order.

graphic file with name fx76.jpg

Step 34: Fix compound elbow timing pulley to rotary shaft with set screws and loop 42T timing belt through bicep link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx77.jpg

Step 35: Pass rotary shaft through central link side assemblies.

graphic file with name fx78.jpg

Step 36: Fasten central link side assemblies to central link base plates and central strut.

graphic file with name fx79.jpg

Step 37: Engage 13T steel timing pulleys with timing belts and pass keyed rotary shafts through central link ball bearings, pulleys, and roller bearings. Fix 13T pulleys to rotary shafts with set screws.

graphic file with name fx80.jpg

Step 38: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into 34T central link timing pulley.

graphic file with name fx81.jpg

Step 39: Slide 34T central link timing pulley, 13T steel timing pulley, and timing belt onto each side of the central link. Use set screws to fix 13T steel timing pulleys to motor shafts.

graphic file with name fx82.jpg

Step 40: Use set screws to fix 34T central link timing pulleys to rotary shafts.

graphic file with name fx83.jpg

Step 41: Fasten timing pulley caps to 34T central link timing pulleys.

graphic file with name fx84.jpg

Step 42: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into central link tensioner housing.

graphic file with name fx85.jpg

Step 43: Assemble various components of central link tensioner.

graphic file with name fx86.jpg

Step 44: Mount central link tensioner onto central link. Turn tensioner bolt to tension timing belt.

graphic file with name fx87.jpg

Step 45: Saw 3.25” diameter acrylic tube into two 12” segments.

graphic file with name fx88.jpg

Step 46: Align drill jig with edge of acrylic tube and tighten with fasteners.

graphic file with name fx89.jpg

Step 47: Use hand drill and.25” drill bit to 6x drill holes in the locations indicated by the drill jig.

graphic file with name fx90.jpg

Step 48: Slide drill jig to other end of tube and repeat drilling operation. Ensure that holes are properly aligned and in the correct orientation.

graphic file with name fx91.jpg

Step 49: Repeat hole drilling process for other tube.

graphic file with name fx92.jpg

Step 50: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into bicep link outboard cap.

graphic file with name fx93.jpg

Step 51: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into bicep link outboard cap.

graphic file with name fx94.jpg

Step 52: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into 13T elbow timing pulley.

graphic file with name fx95.jpg

Step 53: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into forearm link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx96.jpg

Step 54: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into forearm link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx97.jpg

Step 55: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into elbow joint couplers.

graphic file with name fx98.jpg

Step 56: Partially fasten mounted bearings to bicep link outboard cap.

graphic file with name fx99.jpg

Step 57: Slide bicep link outboard cap and acrylic tube onto bicep link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx100.jpg

Step 58: Fasten acrylic tube to bicep link caps.

graphic file with name fx101.jpg

Step 59: Loop 13T elbow timing pulley into 42T timing belt and finish fastening mounted bearings to bicep link outboard cap.

graphic file with name fx102.jpg

Step 60: Fasten elbow joint couplers to forearm link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx103.jpg

Step 61: Slide keyed rotary shaft through forearm link inboard cap, mounted bearings, and 13T elbow timing pulley.

graphic file with name fx104.jpg

Step 62: Secure forearm link inboard cap to rotary shaft with set screws.

graphic file with name fx105.jpg

Step 63: Secure 13T elbow timing pulley to rotary shaft with set screws.

graphic file with name fx106.jpg

Step 64: Slide acrylic tube onto forearm link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx107.jpg

Step 65: Fasten acrylic tube to forearm link inboard cap.

graphic file with name fx108.jpg

Step 66: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into bicep link tensioner housing.

graphic file with name fx109.jpg

Step 67: Assemble various components of bicep link tensioner.

graphic file with name fx110.jpg

Step 68: Mount bicep link tensioner onto bicep link. Turn tensioner bolt to tension timing belt.

graphic file with name fx111.jpg

Step 69: Use soldering iron to set heat-set inserts into mounting plate.

graphic file with name fx112.jpg

Step 70: Slide mounting plate into forearm link acrylic tube.

graphic file with name fx113.jpg

Step 71: Fasten mounting plate to forearm link acrylic tube.

graphic file with name fx114.jpg

Step 72: Fasten power supply to power supply housing.

graphic file with name fx115.jpg

Step 73: Fasten Smoothieboard to Smoothieboard Housing.

graphic file with name fx116.jpg

Step 74: Fasten power supply housing to base.

graphic file with name fx117.jpg

Step 75: Fasten Smoothieboard housing and electronics tower lid to power supply housing.

graphic file with name fx118.jpg

Step 76: Connect power supply cables between motors, power source, and wall AC power. If using the Teknic Clearpath servo system, follow the instructions provided on the Teknic website [6].

graphic file with name fx119.jpg

Step 77: Connect motor control signal wires to control board. For the provided software files, the base joint corresponds to the X-axis on the Smoothieboard, the shoulder joint the Y, and the elbow joint the Z. If using Clearpath servos/Teknic control cables and a Smoothieboard, the following wires on the cable correspond to the following pins on the Smoothieboard:

graphic file with name fx120.jpg

Teknic Control Cable Cable Color Control Board
HLFB + Green N/A
Input B + Black ST1
Input A + White Dir1
Enable + Blue EN1
HLFB − Red/Fuscia N/A
Input B − Yellow GND
Input A − Brown GND
Enable − Orange GND

More info can be found on the Teknic [7] and Smoothieware [8] websites.

6. Operation instructions

6.1. Safety concerns

Before operating PARA, note the following safety concerns. For safety concerns pertaining to assembling PARA prior to operation, see Section 5.1.

  • •

    PARA is not designed to operate beyond the specifications presented in this article. Exceeding these specifications by, for example, attaching a heavier payload or instructing the arm to move faster than the recommended max speed, will result in PARA not functioning as intended (e.g. exhibiting jerky motions, excessive motor noise, or timing belt slippages). PARA’s components may also become permanently damaged through breaking or overheating. If PARA begins to exhibit clearly improper behaviors immediately power down the arm.

  • •

    If PARA’s components begin to smell of burnt plastic/metal or even start smoking immediately power down the arm.

  • •

    Even without an attached payload, PARA’s various hard plastic linkages can deliver a substantial amount of impact force, especially when moving at high speeds. The version of PARA presented in this paper does not contain obstacle-detection capabilities, thus if the arm encounters an object in its path of motion either PARA or the obstructing object may suffer damages. Note PARA’s workspace detailed in Fig. 6 and ensure that when the arm is powered on, any humans or animals (including the operator) are a safe distance away. Remove any unnecessary obstacles in the workspace and take note of those which must remain when controlling the arm. For operation around fragile objects consider wrapping PARA’s linkages in protective padding for extra safety.

  • •

    As a continuation of the previous point, PARA’s components are not designed to withstand high-energy or repeated impacts. The acrylic tubes used in the arm’s linkages can be brittle, while the arm’s 3D printed components can be prone to layer separation if impacted with sufficient force. Avoid high-speed collisions with obstacles and dropping PARA or any of its various components.

  • •

    PARA contains many live joints, timing belts, and toothed pulleys which could potentially pinch the user’s fingers or skin. Avoid touching or servicing these components while PARA is powered on.

  • •

    PARA’s motors utilize a considerable amount of power and can become hot after prolonged use. Exercise caution if touching these motors with bare skin during or right after using PARA.

  • •

    The Teknic Clearpath motors suggested in this article have fail safe measures to ensure that they do not draw power greater than what they – and the accompanying power supply – are rated for. If using substitute motors that do not have these features, ensure that the motors are operating within the recommended electrical specifications. Exceeding these specifications can permanently damage the motors. Also ensure that the selected power source can provide enough power for all motors at worst-case conditions. If the power source cannot supply a sufficient amount of power the arm may fail midway through performing a critical task.

  • •

    As a general safety principle for mobile robotics, when developing a new action for PARA, always test this action several times at a slower speed (the authors recommend an end effector speed of 100 mm/s) before running it at full speed.

6.2. Operation instructions

  • 1.

    If using the proposed Teknic motors, use Teknic ClearPath-SC Series Motor Setup (Clearview) software to tune PARA’s motors under the load of the arm itself. The software can be downloaded from the Teknic website [9]. Ensure there is sufficient room around the arm for its various linkages to move without obstruction during the tuning process. Example tunes for PARA’s motors have been provided.

    Performance of stepper motors may be enchanced by tightening tensioner bolts.

    A more comprehensive guide for Teknic Clearpath motor operation can be found on the Teknic website [7].

  • 2.

    If using the Smoothieboard, load the provided.config file onto the microSD card, re-insert the card back into the board, and press the ”RESET” button while the board is powered. This.config file contains correct settings for motor steps per mm travel and acceleration.

    A more comprehensive guide for Smoothieboard operation can be found on the Smoothieboard website [10].

  • 3.

    Operate the arm by sending G-Code to the Smoothieboard. Many pieces of open-source software like the Printrun Suite [11] can facilitate this process. One can also communicate with and send code directly to the Smoothieboard, which is exemplified in the provided Python code.

    Below are some useful G-Code commands for operating PARA:
    • •
      M17: Turns on all motors.
    • •
      G91: Sets motor positioning to relative rather than absolute.
    • •
      G92 X0 Y0 Z0: Zeros all motors.
    • •
      G0 XN YN ZN FN: Moves X, Y, and Z motors by N amount at a speed of N.
    • •
      M584 X0 Y1 Z2 A3 B4: If implementing additional axes in a custom end effector for example, will map additional axes to motors connected to the control board.

7. Validation and characterization

7.1. Strength assessment

PARA’s payload-handling capabilities were assessed empirically by hanging progressively heavier weights off of the end of the arm’s forearm linkage and actuating each joint independently, noting the maximum amount of weight which could be manipulated until the joints began to behave erratically (Fig. 23).

Fig. 23.

Fig. 23

PARA lifting two 1-kg weights during an assessment of the elbow joint’s strength (top), and an early test setup for the capabilities of the base joint without the bicep and forearm links attached (bottom).

For the base joint/central linkage axis, past approximately 2 kg of load the base joint motor began to exhibit signs that it was being pushed near its operating limits: it produced excessive vibrations, and began to turn at different rates at different angles throughout each revolution. Such motor issues were possibly exacerbated by the fact that loads on the central axle were being transmitted to the motor axle in the radial direction through the timing belt linking them (theoretically, the ball bearings around the central axle should’ve reacted any moment exerted on the axle by gravitational forces acting on the tip of the arm, but slop in the arm’s construction and deflection of the printed parts under excessive loads could easily result in a portion of these forces shifting to the axle itself). Additionally, while accelerating to high speeds (approx. 1000 mm/s end effector speed) the base joint timing belt would slip due to deformation of the belt’s rubber teeth in response to the excessive inertia of the payload.

For the shoulder and elbow axes actuating the bicep and forearm linkages, the timing belts would also begin to slip past 2 kg of load, mostly due to excessive gravitational force. Tensioning the timing belts assisted in preventing belt slippage to a certain degree (most prominently in the long 42-tooth timing belt linking the final two pulley gears in the elbow joint timing belt system, as shown in Fig. 24), but excessive belt tensions risked breaking the arm’s plastic parts (either through deforming them through excessive bending moments, cracking the parts, or separating the parts’ 3D printed layers) and damaging the motors through excessive radial thrust forces on their axles.

Fig. 24.

Fig. 24

Indentation of elbow joint timing belt tensioner (highlighted in red in CAD screenshot) required to lift select payload values without belt slippage. Elbow joint velocity and acceleration values used in each test were approximately 3 rad/s and 3 rad/s2, respectively. Note the interestingly linear relationship (R2 =.97).

Stronger, more robust materials for the structural elements of PARA such as metal or solid injection-molded plastic parts would undoubtedly improve the payload capabilities of the arm by minimizing part deflection and unwanted load paths in the assembly. However, such parts would also prompt much higher material and tooling costs (part-specific injection/casting molds and stamping dies, for example), which is a trade-off PARA makes to drive down cost. Automated means of assembling PARA could also potentially allow for extremely tensioned timing belts (much tighter than what the average person could assemble by hand) to prevent belt slippage, but such means of assembly would also incur higher costs.

When performing these strength assessments for each joint, maximum joint acceleration values which would also allow each degree of freedom to operate reliably at a variety of payloads were chosen. These values were about 3 rad/s2 for the base and shoulder joints and 6 rad/s2 for the elbow joint.

Running the theoretical maximum payload calculations from Section 2.6 while assuming operating accelerations of 3 rad/s2 for the base and shoulder joints and 6 rad/s2 for the elbow joint yields values of 2.1 kg for the base joint, 7.7 kg for the shoulder joint, and 15.8 kg for the elbow joint. The theoretical base joint max load aligns with the observations from this study: the corresponding motor was indeed operating at values close to its peak torque while manipulating the 2 kg payload. The large discrepancies in the shoulder and elbow joints’ theoretical max payload and actual max payload can be accounted for by the points of mechanical failure discussed throughout this section (there is also more potential for power loss and sources of failure for these axes due to the more elaborate nature of their power transmission mechanisms). Future work with PARA should consist of finding methods to increase the tension in PARA’s timing belts while distributing these forces in a mechanically sound way.

Axis Acceleration (rad/s2) Theoretical Max Payload (kg) Actual Max Payload (kg) Efficiency
Base (θX) 3 2.1 2.0 95%
Shoulder (θY) 3 7.7 2.0 26%
Elbow (θZ) 6 15.8 2.0 13%

7.2. Repeatability assessment

PARA’s repeatability was assessed by mounting a 0.7 mm mechanical pencil to the end effector, repeatedly having the arm dot four corners on a 100 mm by 100 mm square (alternating between different corners of the square), and measuring the range of pencil marks produced at each of those four corners (Fig. 25, Fig. 26, Fig. 27). Four assessments were conducted, each with the end effector traveling at a different cartesian velocity: 250 mm/s, 500 mm/s, 750 mm/s, and 1000 mm/s. For each assessment, 36 points were produced at each corner of the square (meaning 144 data points were collected for each assessment). The end effector’s cartesian acceleration for each test was 250 mm/s2.

Fig. 25.

Fig. 25

PARA performing precision assessment.

Fig. 26.

Fig. 26

Markings from 250 mm/s assessment.

Fig. 27.

Fig. 27

Detail view of upper right corner from various assessments. Note scale and differing proximity of points to one another.

The geometric mean of the x and y ranges for each corner in the assessments were as follows:

Speed (mm/s) Top Left Range (mm) Top Right Range (mm) Bottom Left Range (mm) Bottom Right Range (mm)
250 4.47 6.40 5.83 3.61
500 5.83 7.07 7.07 5.83
750 10.30 7.07 6.40 5.66
1000 10.30 11.18 10.77 9.85

Using Student’s t-distribution and assuming 35 degrees of freedom for each sample set, the standard deviation for each corner was as follows:

Speed (mm/s) Top Left SD (mm) Top Right SD (mm) Bottom Left SD (mm) Bottom Right SD (mm)
250 2.65 3.79 3.45 2.13
500 3.45 4.18 4.18 3.45
750 6.09 4.18 3.79 3.35
1000 6.09 6.62 6.37 5.83

Note that two assumptions were made in obtaining these values: 1) because the points at each corner were so close to each other, it was impractical to measure the actual distribution of the points from the mean, and it’s assumed that all points conform to Student’s t-distribution, and 2) the measured ranges at each corner encompass 95% of all points at those corners.

Treating each corner as a sample set from a total population (the population being all points corresponding to a certain end effector velocity), the pooled standard deviation and range with 95% confidence for each assessment are as follows:

Speed (mm/s) Total SD (mm) Total Range at 95% Confidence (mm) Repeatability (mm)
250 3.07 5.20 mm ±2.60
500 3.83 6.48 mm ±3.24
750 4.48 7.57 mm ±3.79
1000 6.23 10.54 mm ±5.26

Interestingly, at this range of end effector speeds, end effector speed and repeatability display a linear relationship, with an R-squared value of 0.94 obtained when plotting the two variables together (Fig. 28).

Fig. 28.

Fig. 28

Repeatability demonstrated by PARA during various trials with different end effector speeds. Note trendline.

It must be stressed that these values were obtained with no payload attached to the end effector; repeatability and precision can be assumed to decrease as the arm payload increases.

Human and animal rights

No humans or animals were harmed in this study.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Albert Tai: Conceptualization, Methodology, Software, Validation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Writing - original draft, Writing - review & editing, Visualization. Michael Chun: Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigation, Writing - original draft. Yuqiu Gan: Software, Validation, Writing - original draft, Writing - review & editing. Mert Selamet: Methodology, Investigation, Writing - review & editing. Hod Lipson: Conceptualization, Resources, Writing - review & editing, Supervision, Project administration, Funding acquisition.

Declaration of competing interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported in part by DARPA MTO grant HR0011-18-2-0020. The authors would like to thank the Columbia University Fu Foundation School of Engineering and Applied Science and the Department of Mechanical Engineering for its funding and support. We thank Bob Stark, Bill Miller, and Mohamed Haroun for their assistance in component fabrication. We thank Aixa Rosado for assistance in material procurement.

Biographies

graphic file with name fx1.jpg

Albert Tai received his Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering from Columbia University in 2020. He is currently a Mechanical Design Engineer at Tesla in Palo Alto.

graphic file with name fx2.jpg

Michael Chun received his Master of Science in Mechanical Engineering from Columbia University in 2017. He is currently a Mechanical Engineer at SCIEX in the San Francisco Bay Area.

graphic file with name fx4.jpg

Yuqiu (Kevin) Gan received his Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering from Columbia University in 2017 and his Master of Science from the University of Michigan in 2019. He is currently an Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS) Development Engineer at Honda R&D Americas.

graphic file with name fx3.jpg

Mert Selamet received his Master of Science in Mechanical Engineering from Columbia University in 2021. He is currently a Research Assistant at Siemens Healthineers.

graphic file with name fx5.jpg

Professor Hod Lipson is the director of Columbia University’s Creative Machines Lab. The James and Sally Scapa Professor of Innovation at Columbia University’s Fu Foundation School of Engineering and Applied Science, Professor Lipson has written books and given TED talks on artificial intelligence and next-generation additive manufacturing.

Contributor Information

Albert Tai, Email: albert.tai@columbia.edu.

Hod Lipson, Email: hod.lipson@columbia.edu.

Appendix: Robotic arm models consulted for hardware in context

Note: ? = Not provided by source.

Name/Source DoF Payload (kg) Repeat-ability (mm) Reach (mm) Cost No. inFig. 1 No. inFig. 3
UFACTORY uArm Swift Pro [6] 4 0.5 0.2 320 749 1 1
Thor [8] 6 0.75 ? 422.15 379 2 2
BCN3D MOVEO [1] 5 0.8 ? 538 400 3 3
LittleArm BIG [17] 5 0.11 ? 292 119 4 4
3D Printable Robot Arm (A. Hoelldorfer) [18] 6 2 ? 600 ? 5 N/A
Zortrax Robotic Arm [19] 5 0.1 ? 378 ? 6 N/A
ViperX 250 Robot Arm [3] 5 0.45 1 650 3795.95 7 5
ReactorX 200 Robot Arm [2] 5 0.15 2.5 550 1695.95 8 6
Niryo One - 6-Axis Robotic Arm [11] 6 0.3 1 440 1999 9 7
RobotDigg SCARA [20] 6 2 0.1 650 3890 10 8
RobotAnno V6PLUS [21] 6 1 0.5 480 1390 11 9
Innfos Gluon [22] 6 1 ? 421 579 12 10
Tinkerkit Braccio [23] 5 0.4 ? 800 218 13 11
xArm 5 Lite [24] 5 3 0.1 700 5068 14 12
Meca500 [25] 6 0.5 0.005 260 15000 15 N/A
Fanuc ARC Mate 50iD/7L [26] 6 7 0.03 911 >25000 16 N/A
Fanuc LR Mate 200iD [10] 6 7 0.01 717 >25000 17 N/A
Fanuc LR Mate 200iD/4S [27] 6 4 0.01 550 >25000 18 N/A
Fanuc LR Mate 200iD/4SH [28] 5 4 0.01 550 >25000 19 N/A
Fanuc LR Mate 200iD/7H [29] 5 7 0.01 717 >25000 20 N/A
Fanuc LR Mate 200iD/7L [30] 6 7 0.01 911 >25000 21 N/A
Fanuc M-10iA/12S [31] 6 12 0.01 1098 >25000 22 N/A
Fanuc M-10iA/10 M [32] 6 10 0.01 1422 >25000 23 N/A
KUKA Agilus KR 3 R540 [33] 6 3 0.02 541 24000 24 N/A
KUKA Agilus KR 4 R600 [34] 6 4 ? 600 23000 25 N/A
KUKA Agilus KR 10 R1100-2 [35] 6 11.1 0.02 1101 33000 26 N/A
KUKA LBR iiwa 7 R800 [36] 7 7 .1 800 77000 27 13
UR3e [7] 6 3 ? 500 >25000 28 N/A
UR5e [37] 6 5 ? 850 >25000 29 N/A
UR10e [38] 6 10 ? 1300 >25000 30 N/A
UR16e [38] 6 5 ? 900 >25000 31 N/A
RobotAnno RS900 [39] 6 5 0.05 900 ? 32 N/A
PARA 3 2 ? 876 3400 33 13

References

References

Further Reading


Articles from HardwareX are provided here courtesy of Elsevier

RESOURCES