Skip to main content
. 2021 Dec 14;116(4):201–219. doi: 10.1080/20477724.2021.2011579

Table 2.

Summary of TB studies

Study ID First Author Year of Publication Year of
Data
Collection^
WHO Region WHO
Mortality
Strata
Country Diagnostic Method* Population TB +ve Screening Screened
Screened# (n) Method Population
(n) % Male
Population
1 Bhat, 2009 2007–2008 SEAR D India Culture 22,284 83 Chest symptoms 48.6
2 Bhat, 2015 2012–2013 SEAR D India Culture 19,409 494 Chest symptoms  
3 Bhat, 2017 2013 SEAR D India Culture 12,123 348 Chest symptoms  
4 Bolton, 1975 1961–1971 WPR B Malaysia Smear 71,748 249 X-ray  
5 Chakma, 1996 <1996 SEAR D India Culture 11,097 142 Chest symptoms  
6 Damon, 1974 1968 WPR B Solomon Is Clinical 850 21 No pre-screening  
7 Datta, 2001 1989 SEAR D India Culture 16,017 126 Chest symptoms +/or x-ray 60.2
8 Haddad, 2012 <2012 SEAR D India Smear 1,660 346 Chest symptoms  
9 Hussain, 2020 2015–2017 SEAR D India Culture 5,145 35 Chest symptoms  
10 Kashyap, 2013 <2013 SEAR D India Culture 128 41 No pre-screening  
11 Kerketta, 2009 <2009 SEAR D India Clinical 314 12 No pre-screening 43.0
12 King, 1951 1950 WPR A Australia Clinical 3,209 15 Mantoux test  
13 Macken, 1952 1949–1951 WPR A Australia Clinical 5,472 177 Mantoux test  
14 Murhekar, 2004 2001–2002 SEAR D India Smear 10,570 77 Chest symptoms  
15 Purty, 2019 2015–2017 SEAR D India Smear 6,898 18 Chest symptoms 47.8
16 Rao, 2010A 2008 SEAR D India Culture 1,390 6 Chest symptoms  
17 Rao, 2010B 2007–2008 SEAR D India Culture 11,116 166 Chest symptoms  
18 Rao, 2011 2007–2008 SEAR D India Culture 9,538 133 Chest symptoms 47.6
19 Rao, 2015 2012–2013 SEAR D India Culture 9,653 318 Chest symptoms 46.5
20 Rao, 2019 2013 SEAR D India Culture 9,756 293 Chest symptoms  
21 Roy, 1969 1968 WPR B Malaysia Smear 1,055 108 X-ray 55
22 Sharma, 2010 2006–2007 SEAR D India Smear 50,000 266 Chest symptoms  
23 Vyas, 2019 2014–2015 SEAR D India Smear 65,230 964 Chest symptoms  
24 Yano, 1974 1972 WPR B Malaysia Clinical 562 12 No pre-screening  

Notes:^ If the study has not detailed the year of data collection, it is assumed < year of publication

*Diagnostic method: Smear = smear or uncategorized sputum methodology. Clinical = current TB treatment, self-report, X-ray. If a paper uses multiple methods, it is classified according to the most sensitive method according to the following descending order: culture, smear and clinical (e.g. if smear + culture classified as culture, if x-ray and smear classified as smear)

# Population figures are inclusive of non-indigenous participants in the comparative studies

Where studies utilize a screening method to determine the population to be tested, this is detailed. Chest symptoms include-persistent cough, chest pain, fever, hemoptysis.