Table 3.
Summary table of the impacts on mammal cells of SAW. (↗: increase in, ↘: decrease in, N.A.: not available, AFM: atomic force microscopy, IDT: interdigital transistor, PDMS: polydimethylsiloxane, *: extrapolation based on the hypothesis that the electrode impedance is at 50 Ω).
Reference | Frequency (MHz) | Intensity or Electrical Power | Duty Cycle (%) | Time | Shear Flow | Device | Cells | Temperature Control | Biological Effects | Hypothesis |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[48] | 10 | 65–250 mW | N.A. | N.A. | N.A. | Slanted IDT, LiNbO3 chip | Human red blood cells (RBC) RBC infected by the malarial parasite Plasmodium falciparum |
None | Enrichment, separation of the cells depending on their pathological state | Cell density impacts their displacement with the shear flow |
[7] | 77–164 | 80–1000 mW cm−2 up to 13.6 mW |
100 or 0.00077 | 5 min–27 h | N.A. | LiNbO3 chip covered with a SiO2 layer (= substrate), PDMS well | Madin–Darby canine kidney (MDCK-II) Human osteosarcoma sarcoma osteogenic (SaOs-2) Human embryonic kidney (T-REx-293) |
Estimated rise of 2.4 °C | Wound healing ↗ cell migration ↗ cell proliferation |
Direct mechanical stimulation > flow field, or electrical field |
[49] | 101–204 | 380 mW | 100 | seconds | N.A. | 4 IDT, LiNbO3 chip | Human lymphocytes RBC infected by the malarial parasite Plasmodium falciparum |
Thermally controlled chamber | Patterning of spatially isolated individual cells in an acoustic field defined in 2D | N.A. |
[50] | 48.8 | 467 mW | 2.5 | 48 h | Shear stress 120–280 mN m−2 Shear velocity 600 ± 250 μm s−1 | LiNbO3 chip, titanium substrate, PDMS well | Human monocytes (U-937) | Rise ≤ 0.5 °C | ↗ cell proliferation (+36%) |
Shear stress linked to SAW has a more positive impact than stirring |
[51] | 14 | Up to18 V, 59.3 mW cm−2 and 0.23 µW for a single cell (400 µm2) order of magnitude up to 100 mW * |
100 | 4–8 h | Velocity up to 56 µm s−1, shear stress 3.8 mPa | LiNbO3 chip, glycerol as a coupling liquid with the PDMS cell culture chamber | Mouse embryonic fibroblasts (NIH-3T3) | Feedback loop to maintain the temperature of the medium flow | Cell migration first enhanced, then suppressed as the intensity rose No reduction in cell viability Thicker actin bundles |
Cell orientation alignment along the propagating wave, high traction forces activated the Rho signaling pathway |
[52] | 160 | 631 mW | 100 | 60 min | Shear rate distribution 1750–6900 s−1 | Gold IDT, LiNbO3 chip, a cylindrical PDMS chamber on top filled with culture medium, cells attached to a titanium implant on top | SaOs-2 | Temperature maintained at 37 °C, no precision | Correlation between shear flow and cell detachment from an implant | Cell density plays a key role |
[53] | 19.35 | 325–575 mW | 100 | 10 s | Velocity 0–9 mm s−1 | LiNbO3 chip, titanium layer, aluminum substrate, | none | / | ↗ penetration rate into a porous scaffold | N.A. |
[54] | 161–171 | 31.6 mW | N.A. | >330 µs per pulse | N.A. | Gold and titan LiNbO3 chip, covered with glass, PDMS microchannel device | Mouse melanoma cells (B16F10) | None. | Sorting rate of 3000 cells s−1 depending on their fluorescence (Calcein-AM) | N.A. |
[55] | 196.7 | 1 mW 10–20 kPa |
100 | 3–10 min | N.A. | Quartz (SiO2) chip, cells suspended in glycerin, SU-8 microprobe | Chondrosarcoma (JJ012) Breast cancer cells (MDA-MB-231, SKBR3, MCF7) |
None | US velocity measurement for single cell analysis 106 sensitivity in elasticity compared to AFM |
Cell elastic moduli is a possible biomarker for aggressiveness or metastatic potential |
[56] | 132 | 55–500 mW | 100 | 100 s | Velocity 0.42–1.80 m s−1 Shear stress 0.01–0.045 Pa |
Concentric gold IDT, LiNbO3 chip | Untreated, and non-infected human RBC Glutaraldehyde- treated RBC RBC infected by the malarial parasite |
None | Cell detachment behavior was different according to the RBC state of infection. | Specific mechanotransduction might be a biomarker |
[57] | 159 | 2–4 mW | 100 | 48 h | N.A. | LiNbO3 chip, SiO2 substrate, PDMS well | SaOs-2 | Rise ≤ 0.32 °C | ↗ wound healing as a function of US intensity no significant necrosis no preferred direction for migration/proliferation |
Unclear if the effect is due to mechanical or electrical stimulation, or a combination of both |
[58] | N.A. | 316–501 mW | 100 | 0–60 min | Shear flow 2 Pa |
LiNbO3 chip, titanium substrate | SaOs-2 | Thermally controlled chamber | No significant impact on cell adhesion, when T ≤ 37 °C | Decrease in cell adhesion is due to increase in temperature or decrease in pH |
[8] | 38.74 | 125.6 mW | 80 | 2 h | N.A. | Two circular IDT (and two straight IDT for SSAW), LiNbO3 chip, covered with Al, and PDMS channels | Human glioma cell lines (U87) Rat RBC |
None | Cell sorting depending on their virulence | Sorting of particles is dependent on their size |