Skip to main content
. 2022 May 18;10(5):1166. doi: 10.3390/biomedicines10051166

Table 3.

Summary table of the impacts on mammal cells of SAW. (↗: increase in, ↘: decrease in, N.A.: not available, AFM: atomic force microscopy, IDT: interdigital transistor, PDMS: polydimethylsiloxane, *: extrapolation based on the hypothesis that the electrode impedance is at 50 Ω).

Reference Frequency (MHz) Intensity or Electrical Power Duty Cycle (%) Time Shear Flow Device Cells Temperature Control Biological Effects Hypothesis
[48] 10 65–250 mW N.A. N.A. N.A. Slanted IDT, LiNbO3 chip Human red blood cells (RBC)
RBC infected by the malarial parasite Plasmodium falciparum
None Enrichment, separation of the cells depending on their pathological state Cell density impacts their displacement with the shear flow
[7] 77–164 80–1000 mW cm−2
up to 13.6 mW
100 or 0.00077 5 min–27 h N.A. LiNbO3 chip covered with a SiO2 layer (= substrate), PDMS well Madin–Darby canine kidney (MDCK-II)
Human osteosarcoma sarcoma osteogenic (SaOs-2)
Human embryonic kidney (T-REx-293)
Estimated rise of 2.4 °C Wound healing
↗ cell migration
↗ cell proliferation
Direct mechanical stimulation > flow field, or electrical field
[49] 101–204 380 mW 100 seconds N.A. 4 IDT, LiNbO3 chip Human lymphocytes
RBC infected by the malarial parasite Plasmodium falciparum
Thermally controlled chamber Patterning of spatially isolated individual cells in an acoustic field defined in 2D N.A.
[50] 48.8 467 mW 2.5 48 h Shear stress 120–280 mN m−2 Shear velocity 600 ± 250 μm s−1 LiNbO3 chip, titanium substrate, PDMS well Human monocytes (U-937) Rise ≤ 0.5 °C ↗ cell proliferation
(+36%)
Shear stress linked to SAW has a more positive impact than stirring
[51] 14 Up to18 V, 59.3 mW cm−2 and 0.23 µW for a single cell (400 µm2)
order of magnitude up to 100 mW *
100 4–8 h Velocity up to 56 µm s−1, shear stress 3.8 mPa LiNbO3 chip, glycerol as a coupling liquid with the PDMS cell culture chamber Mouse embryonic fibroblasts (NIH-3T3) Feedback loop to maintain the temperature of the medium flow Cell migration first enhanced, then suppressed as the intensity rose
No reduction in cell viability
Thicker actin bundles
Cell orientation alignment along the propagating wave, high traction forces activated the Rho signaling pathway
[52] 160 631 mW 100 60 min Shear rate distribution 1750–6900 s−1 Gold IDT, LiNbO3 chip, a cylindrical PDMS chamber on top filled with culture medium, cells attached to a titanium implant on top SaOs-2 Temperature maintained at 37 °C, no precision Correlation between shear flow and cell detachment from an implant Cell density plays a key role
[53] 19.35 325–575 mW 100 10 s Velocity 0–9 mm s−1 LiNbO3 chip, titanium layer, aluminum substrate, none / ↗ penetration rate into a porous scaffold N.A.
[54] 161–171 31.6 mW N.A. >330 µs per pulse N.A. Gold and titan LiNbO3 chip, covered with glass, PDMS microchannel device Mouse melanoma cells (B16F10) None. Sorting rate of 3000 cells s−1 depending on their fluorescence (Calcein-AM) N.A.
[55] 196.7 1 mW
10–20 kPa
100 3–10 min N.A. Quartz (SiO2) chip, cells suspended in glycerin, SU-8 microprobe Chondrosarcoma (JJ012)
Breast cancer cells (MDA-MB-231, SKBR3, MCF7)
None US velocity measurement for single cell analysis
106 sensitivity in elasticity compared to AFM
Cell elastic moduli is a possible biomarker for aggressiveness or metastatic potential
[56] 132 55–500 mW 100 100 s Velocity 0.42–1.80 m s−1
Shear stress 0.01–0.045 Pa
Concentric gold IDT, LiNbO3 chip Untreated, and non-infected human RBC
Glutaraldehyde- treated RBC
RBC infected by the malarial parasite
None Cell detachment behavior was different according to the RBC state of infection. Specific mechanotransduction might be a biomarker
[57] 159 2–4 mW 100 48 h N.A. LiNbO3 chip, SiO2 substrate, PDMS well SaOs-2 Rise ≤ 0.32 °C ↗ wound healing as a function of US intensity
no significant necrosis
no preferred direction for migration/proliferation
Unclear if the effect is due to mechanical or electrical stimulation, or a combination of both
[58] N.A. 316–501 mW 100 0–60 min Shear flow
2 Pa
LiNbO3 chip, titanium substrate SaOs-2 Thermally controlled chamber No significant impact on cell adhesion, when T ≤ 37 °C Decrease in cell adhesion is due to increase in temperature or decrease in pH
[8] 38.74 125.6 mW 80 2 h N.A. Two circular IDT (and two straight IDT for SSAW), LiNbO3 chip, covered with Al, and PDMS channels Human glioma cell lines (U87)
Rat RBC
None Cell sorting depending on their virulence Sorting of particles is dependent on their size