Skip to main content
. 2022 May 19;19(10):6198. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19106198

Table 4.

Safety management practices leading indicators extracted from reviewed articles.

Aspect Leading Indicators References
Management Commitment
 Safety policy
  • A clear safety vision and objectives;

  • Implementated by managers and workgroups;

  • Workers’ knowledge and awareness on safety policy;

  • Provision to establish procedures and control; and

  • The number of policy reviews and updates.

[38,41,46,49,52]
 Management leadership
  • Inspiring and motivating through words and actions;

  • Gaining trust through charisma and being exemplary;

  • Having committed and competent management; and

  • OSH issues are in top management meeting agendas

[38,41,46,49,52]
 Visible management
  • Active engagement and promotion;

  • Providing assistance and support for improvement;

  • Implementing workers suggestions;

  • Identifying and monitoring worker’s deviations and errors;

  • Informal interactions inside and outside the workplace;

  • Emphasis on safety procedures and policies;

  • Setting individual and company safety goals;

  • Regular two-way communication;

  • Safety walkthroughs by top managers; and

  • Rating of management commitment in OSH management.

[41,43,45,46,48,52,53,55,60]
 Core values
  • Provision of adequate funds and resources;

  • Procedures, training programmes, and competence selection;

  • High priority for safety; and

  • Budget spent on OSH improvement activities.

[39,42,43,48,53,55]
Workers’ Involvement
 Encouraging involvement
  • Leader engagement with workers;

  • Workers’ understanding and commitment on values and goals;

  • Sufficient budget allocation;

  • Workers’ are recognized, valued, and rewarded;

  • Open-door policy;

  • Management take serious on OSH issues and suggestions;

  • Having effective OSH committees; and

  • Meetings commissioned on OSH issues.

[38,41,42,44,46,48,51,55,58,62]
 Empowerment for safety
  • Active participation in safety decision making;

  • Shared responsibility and accountability with workers in making safety decision;

  • Workers participate proactively in safety efforts and monitoring of the workplace;

  • OSH improvements proposed by workers or their representatives; and

  • Risk assessment activities conducted with workers’ involvement.

[38,39,48,53,55]
 Worker consultation
  • Workers’ perceptions towards OSH;

  • Consulting on safety issues directly with workers;

  • Collaboration and shared planning;

  • Seeking information from workers;

  • Support to ensure task objectives is achieved;

  • Consultation in developing procedures; and

  • Allowing workers to make suggestions for the improvement.

[45,48,53,58]
 Removing barriers for involvement
  • Improving policy regarding workers’ participation in safety;

  • Equal status distinctions to all workers in giving input and information on safety;

  • Providing timely feedback;

  • Rating effectiveness involvement; and

  • Allocation on OSH incentives and budget.

[38,45,48,55,58,62]
Hazard Identification and Assessment
 Identifying existing hazards
  • Addressing workers’ to all hazards associated with the workplace;

  • Workers’ understanding on hazards and how to protect themselves;

  • Integrating OSH in pre-work briefings on identified specific hazards and risks;

  • Assessing hazards through job safety analysis;

  • Consideration of ergonomic factors, reviewing designs, standards and regulations; and

  • Identifying any risks before internal changes are made.

[41,55,61,62]
 Workplace inspections
  • Identifying hazards associated with work and production pressures which influence safety performance;

  • Identifying hazards associated with psychosocial, physical or physiological factors;

  • Verifying regular maintenance of all equipment; and

  • Ensuring hazards are controlled and equipments are installed correctly and safe.

[53,59,61]
 Accident investigation
  • Identified hazard through reports of accidents and safety issues;

  • Identifying root causes of the incident;

  • Evaluating the quality of the frameworks, procedures, or interventions implemented;

  • Adequate follow-up of reported unplanned events;

  • Increase in the reporting rate;

  • The quality of incident investigation and analysis;

  • How lessons learned are communicated; and

  • Measuring the ratio between accidents that occurred and near misses reported.

[41,44,50,59]
 Hazard assessment
  • Integrating risk management in the OSH management that includes risk assessments;

  • Workers’ involvement in hazard assessments;

  • Helping workers to perceive the risks associated with the job, the accident potential, physical hazards, and job safety;

  • Assessing safety levels on human, organizational and environmental indicators; and informing workers of the results of risk assessments due to changes introduced.

[43,48,53,55,59]
Hazard prevention and control
 Planning hazard controls
  • Proactively improving OSH from the design phase;

  • Integrating risk and OSH management;

  • Response to human performance problems; and

  • Planning for the job and task.

[41,53,57,61]
 Implementing hazard controls
  • Selective hiring based on fitness for the job;

  • Implementing working procedures or interventions;

  • Executing temporary control;

  • Timely corrective actions, maintenance and checking false reports; and

  • Numbers of controls implemented based on hierarchy.

[38,43,44,48,53,55,58,59]
 Managing hazard controls
  • The awareness of employees of current risk levels, controls, and conditions;

  • Written OSH procedures and safe working;

  • Assessing behaviour and human error;

  • Equipment maintenance to safe standards; and

  • The number of safety grievances addressed and resolved.

[39,43,48,51,55,58,61,62]
 Verifying hazard controls
  • Enforcing non-compliance; standardization of work procedures;

  • Supplying workers with personal protective equipment, correct tools and equipment, using precisely installed equipment; and

  • Reviewing and evaluating corrective actions.

[48,50,55,61,62]
Training and education
 Management roles in training
  • Training provisions that inspire positive attitudes and an energetic environment;

  • Time allocation and planning for safety training; providing adequate safety training;

  • Maintaining training records;

  • Investing in workers’ training and knowledge;

  • Managers participated in OSH courses; and

  • Workers are trained on their duties and responsibilities.

[42,43,44,46,50,51,53,55,60]
 Effectiveness of workers’ training
  • The numbers of workers trained;

  • Safety induction for new recruits and contractors;

  • Improvement in qualifications through skills, competency, and knowledge;

  • Continuous development with regular and refresher training; and

  • Workers are trained for critical positions and qualified before commencing work.

[41,43,44,46,50,55,58,63]
 Training on hazard identification and control
  • The ability of workers to assess hazards and control measures in the workplace;

  • Workers familiarization with procedures, standards, practices, and equipment;

  • Adequate training for responses and anticipation to a variety of threats or emergencies; and

  • Safety skills across multiple domains.

[39,42,46,48,58,60]
 Safety awareness
  • Workers level of awareness of hazards;

  • Workers’ participation in safety OSH courses;

  • Workers attitudes towards safety;

  • Safety performance enhancement; and

  • Workers awareness on their duties and responsibilities.

[38,42,45,46,55,61]
Evaluation and improvement
 Performance evaluation of safety programmes
  • The effectiveness of management targeted processes and programmes on safety goals;

  • Safety standards compliance performance;

  • OSH improvement goals in delivering results;

  • Budget spent on plans, quality and effectiveness of OSH improvement; and

  • Safety data collection.

[38,41,43,44,48,55]
 Safety audits
  • Structured process in gathering information on pre-determined protocols;

  • Evaluate OSH programs and management systems;

  • Validating workers competency to ensure the sustainability of preventative and control measures;

  • Compliance on OSH regulations and standards; and

  • Audit conducted by external, experienced and assertive auditors.

[38,43,49,50,55,56]
 Identification of weaknesses
  • Investigations to uncover causes of incidents and near misses;

  • Investigations into nonconformities for corrective actions;

  • Completion of corrective measures in due time; and

  • Statistical reviews of occupational injuries.

[42,43,44,49,57,64]
 Identification of opportunities
  • Evaluating high-quality work to improve job security and role overload;

  • Measuring the effectiveness and sustainability of OSH promotions and sharing lessons learned;

  • Periodically reviewed and improved operational procedures and OSH instructions;

  • Positive feedback and recognition for past performance given;

  • Nonconformities investigated for the potential for improvement; and

  • Assessments made for technological solutions available.

[38,41,43,45,48,49,53,55]
Communication and coordination
 Management communication
  • Regular communication and interaction on safety goals;

  • Sharing safety information by two-way and open discussions;

  • Information flow and dissemination on work management and actual practices;

  • Quantification of the communicational capacity of workers;

  • Communication through verbal instruction, brochures, emails, or bulletins;

  • Communication and consultation through formal and informal; and

  • External OSH informational materials distributed internally.

[38,39,43,46,48,53,55,62]
 Safety reporting
  • Applying scrutiny and transparency in reporting;

  • Protection for workers reporting OSH issues or problems;

  • The number of external OSH reports;

  • Sharing information on accidents or near misses; and

  • Communicating workers’ ideas and views on solutions for improving safety.

[49,50,53,55,61]
 Supervisory communication
  • Regular interactions and guidance;

  • Supervisors trained on hazards; and

  • Supervisors valuing safety as reflected in communication, encouragement, and consequences.

[42,46,59,61]
 OSH coordination
  • Pre-planning, planning and organization of work;

  • Evalution of OSH risks during procurement;

  • Managing contractor; monitoring contractor safety performance; and

  • The quality of communication between the workgroup and stakeholders.

[41,44,50,59,62]