Table 4.
Lesion characterization algorithms.
Authors | Classes | Algorithm | Dataset | Image Modality | Results | AI Impact (Clinical Setting) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wu et al., 2021 [58] | Invasion depth: mucosal and submucosal Differentiation Status: Differentiated and undifferentiated |
ResNet-50 |
(Private Dataset) * 3407 images of gastric cancer 1131 differentiated type images 1086 undifferentiated type images |
WLI Magnifying NBI |
EGC invasion WLI: Accuracy: 88%; Sensitivity: 91%; Specificity: 85% EGC differentiation M-NBI: Accuracy of 86%; Sensitivity: 79%; Specificity: 89% |
(Multi-center prospective controlled trial) EGC invasion Experts(n = 8): Sensitivity: 57%% Specificity: 76% Accuracy: 69% EGC invasion Seniors (n = 19): Sensitivity: 60% Specificity: 66% Accuracy: 64% EGC invasion Juniors (n = 19): Sensitivity: 61% Specificity: 61% Accuracy: 61% EGC invasion AI predictions: Sensitivity: 70% Specificity: 83% Accuracy 79% EGC differentiation Experts(n = 8): Sensitivity: 47% Specificity: 83% Accuracy 72% EGC differentiation Seniors (n = 19): Sensitivity: 53% Specificity: 74% Accuracy: 67% EGC differentiation Juniors (n = 19): Sensitivity: 56% Specificity: 60% Accuracy: 59% EGC differentiation AI predictions: Sensitivity: 50% Specificity: 80% Accuracy 71% |
Yoon et al., 2019 [56] | T1a T1b Non-EGC |
VGG-16 |
(Private Dataset) 1097 T1a-EGC 1005 T1b-EGC 9834 non-EGC |
WLI | Specificity: 75% Sensitivity: 82% | N/A |
Nagao et al., 2020 [63] | M-SM1 SM2 or deeper |
ResNet-50 |
(Private Dataset) 10,589 M-SM1 images 6968 SM2 or deeper images |
WLI NBI Indigo |
WLI Accuracy: 95% NBI Accuracy: 94% Indigo Accuracy: 96% |
N/A |
Zhu et al., 2019 [64] | P0 (M or SM1) P1 (deeper than SM1) |
ResNet-50 |
(Private Dataset) 545 P0 images 245 P1 images |
WLI | Accuracy: 89% Sensitivity: 76% Specificity: 96% |
CNN Accuracy: 89% Sensitivity:76% Specificity: 96% Experts(n = 8): Accuracy: 77% Sensitivity: 91% Specificity: 71% Junior (n = 9): Accuracy: 66% Sensitivity: 85% Specificity: 57% |
Xu et al., 2021 [65] | GA IM |
VGG-16 |
(Private Dataset) 2149 GA images 3049 IM images |
Magnifying NBI Magnifying BLI |
GA Accuracy: 90% Sensitivity: 90% Specificity: 91% IM Accuracy: 91% Sensitivity: 89% Specificity: 93% |
(Multi-center Prospective blinded trial) GA classification CAD System: Accuracy: 87% Sensitivity: 87% Specificity: 86% Experts(n = 4): Accuracy: 85% Sensitivity: 91% Specificity: 72% Non experts (n = 5): Accuracy: 75% Sensitivity: 83% Specificity: 59% IM classification: CAD System: Accuracy: 89% Sensitivity: 90% Specificity: 86% Experts(n = 4): Accuracy: 82% Sensitivity: 83% Specificity: 81% Non experts (n = 5): Accuracy: 74% Sensitivity: 74% Specificity: 73% |
* An external dataset of 1526 images has been used to test the performance of the model.