Skip to main content
. 2022 May 11;19(10):5860. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19105860

Table 3.

Determinants of PIL.

No: Study ID Determinants
1 Gerwood (1996) [39] Depression
Spirituality
2 Gerwood (1998) [40] Spirituality
3 Bondevik (2000) [41] Religiousness
Loneliness
4 Greenfield (2004) [42] Role identity
(volunteering moderate PIL and role identity)
5 Frazier (2005) [43] Religious involvements
6 Nygren (2005) [44] Resilience, sense of coherence, self-transcendence and perceived mental health
7 Cicirelli (2006) [45] Fear of body loss
Health
8 Dixon (2007) [46] Overall wellness
Mattering to others
Depression
9 Triado (2007) [47] * Personal growth
Age
Education
Income
10 Moon (2007) [48] Subjective well being
11 Ottenbacher (2007) [49] Self-acceptance
Positive Relation
Environmental Mastery
Personal Growth
13 Krause (2009) [51] Self-rated Heath/fewer functional disabilities
Mortality
14 Ferguson (2010) [52] Optimism
Perception of control (mediates relation between optimism and PIL)
16 Hedberg (2010) [53,54] Attitude towards aging
Having family
Musculoskeletal symptoms
17 Hedberg (2011) [55] Gender (women)
Depression
18 Lundman (2012) [56] Resilience, sense of coherence, self-transcendence
20 Wilson (2013) [58] Global cognition/cognitive function
21 Pearson (2013) [59] Education
22 Zaslavsky (2014) [26] Health
Disability
Mortality
23 Windsor (2015) [60] Memory
Disability
Decline of speed
Health
Depression
Delayed mortality
24 Tomioka (2016) [61] Higher mortality
Instrumental activities of daily living
25 Woods (2016) [62] Higher education
Higher family income
Marital status (married)
Smoking status (non-smokers)
Alcohol use (<1 drinks week)
26 Sano (2016) [63] Achievement motive (Direct),
Social participation
Role expectation
28 Vanhove-Meriaux, (2018) [65] High satisfaction need
Low thwarting need
Competence (extend to which people interact with environment) and relatedness need satisfactions (extend of a secure sense of belongingness and connectedness)
29 Musich (2018) [66] High resilience
High social support
Strong alliance with faith
High health literacy
Good health
Financial stress, living alone and >80 y had negative relation with PIL
Reduced medical and drug expenditure
Utilisation and expenditure
Higher QoL
Compliance with medication protocols
Preventive service utilization
31 Polenick (2018) [68] Gender specific fewer Emotional caregiving difficulties (females)
Fewer physical care giving difficulties
32 Kim (2019) [22] Higher cognition
Decline in cognition
33 Oliveira (2019) [69] Life satisfaction
35 Sutin (2020) [71] Lower risk of concurrent motoric cognitive risk
37 Vanhove-Meriaux (2020) [73] Basic psychological need frustration (predictor)
Basic psychological need satisfaction
39 Lopez (2020) [75] Perceived health,
family functioning,
resilience, gratitude
and acceptance
Loss of a loved one
41 Bundick (2021) [77] Gender (female)
Race/ethnicity
Age
42 Alfonso-Benlliure (2021) [78] Positive relationship with others
Personal growth
Environmental mastery
Self-acceptance
Life satisfaction
Divergent thinking
43 Zhang and Chen (2021) [80] Intensity of physical activity (predicted)
Female gender,
married,
white/Caucasian,
older at baseline,
higher levels of education,
better self-rated health,
and fewer chronic conditions

* study has high risk of bias.