Table 1.
Summary of data extracted.
Study | Location | Population | Exposure | Outcome & Sample Size | Covariates |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
The Effects of Naturalness, Gender, and Age on how Urban Green Space is Perceived and Used Sang, 2016, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening [45] |
Gothenburg, Sweden | Households living close to six different urban green spaces in 2016 | Perceived naturalness based on six areas of diverse character (urban park, woodland, nature area, residential, allotment) assessed by survey | Self-report wellbeing assessed by WHO (ten) well-being index n = 1347 |
age gender |
Residential Green Space and Birth Outcomes in a Coastal Setting Glazer, 2018, Environmental Research [33] |
Rhode Island, United States | Births occurring at Women & Infants Hospital of Rhode Island, to >17 years at delivery, singleton, living within RI, GA 22–44, birthweight 500–5000 g, with data on covariates from 2002–2004 & 2006–2012 | Residential distance to and buffer density of green and blue spaces assessed by NDVI and linear distance | Preterm, birthweight, and small for gestational age assessed by birth record and standard cut points (<37 weeks, grams, birth weight < 10th percentile) n = 61,460 |
maternal age, race, number of prenatal visits, maternal education, marital status, insurance coverage, tobacco use, neighborhood SES, gestational age at birth, town of residence, distance to major roadways |
The Association Between Natural Environments and Depressive Symptoms in Adolescents Living in the United States Bezold, 2018, Journal of Adolescent Health [32] |
United States | GUTS (Growing Up Today) adolescents cohort 1999 | Residential proximity and buffer density of green and blue space assessed by NDVI and linear distance | Depressive symptoms assessed by McKnight risk factor survey n = 9385 |
race, grade level, age, gender, household income, father’s education, maternal history of depression, median tract income, home value, percent tract white, tract college education, region of country, urban/rural, PM2.5 average for July 1999 |
Natural Environments and Suicide Mortality in the Netherlands: a Cross-sectional, Ecological Study Helbich, 2018, The Lancet Planetary Health [44] |
Netherlands | National suicide register from 2005–2014 | Proportion of greenspace/bluespace and coastal proximity per municipality assessed by Dutch land-use database | Registered suicide deaths assessed by death certificate n = 16,105 |
gender, divorce, unemployment, housing values, distance to nearest GP, voter alignment, urbancity |
Are our Beaches Safe? Quantifying the Human Health Impact of Anthropogenic Beach Litter on People in New Zealand Campbell, 2019, Science of the Total Environment [48] |
New Zealand |
ACC insurance claims from 2007–2016 | Reported insurance claims related to injury from beach litter per region | Injury type noted in insurance claim n = 161,261 |
age, gender, ethnicity, location |
Effects of Freshwater Blue Spaces may be Beneficial for Mental Health: A First, Ecological Study in the North American Great Lakes Region Pearson, 2019, PLoS ONE [34] |
Michigan, United States | Michigan residents in the MIDB during 2014 | Proximity/coverage of bluespace assessed by linear distance and zip code overlap | MIDB reported anxiety/mood disorder n = 30,421 |
age, gender, median income, population density |
Human Health Impacts from Litter on Beaches and Associated Perceptions: A Case Study of ‘clean’ Tasmanian Beaches Campbell, 2016, Ocean & Coastal Management [47] |
Tasmania, Australia | Tasmania beach users from 2010–2011 | Frequency of attendance to any of nine beaches across Tasmania assessed by survey | Survey self-reported injury occuring at beaches related to litter n = 173 |
NA |
Using Deep Learning to Examine Street View Green and Blue Spaces and their Associations with Geriatric Depression in Beijing, China Helbich, 2019, Environment International [39] |
Beijing, China | Elderly population residing in Haidian district during 2011 | Neighborhood green/blue space measured by Landsat, NDVI,NDWI, and street view neighborhood green/blue space measured by Landsat, NDVI,NDWI, and street view |
Depressive symptoms assessed by geriatric depression scale (GDS-15) n = 1190 |
gender, age, education, marital status, ADL score, multiple chronic diseases, air pollution |
Designing Urban Green Spaces for Older Adults in Asian Cities Tan, 2019 [38] |
Hong Kong and Tainan | Elderly population of Hong Kong and Tainan 2016–2018 | Attendance to one of 31 small scale urban greenspaces | General health survey n = 326 |
NA |
Neighbourhood Blue Space, Health and Wellbeing: The Mediating role of Different Types of Physical Activity Pasanen, 2019, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health [46] |
England, United Kingdom | English households from 2008–2012 | Coastal proximity to bluespace and present/absent freshwater bluespace assessed by land use database and linear distance | Self-reported general health assessed by standardized health survey n = 21,097 |
quantity/quality of blue and greenspace, urban/rural, deprivation index, age, gender, education, marital status, household income, employment, car availability, number of children, long-term illness, year |
The neighborhood effect of exposure to blue space on elderly individual’s mental health: A case study in Guangzhou, China Chen & Yuan, 2020, Health and Place [40] |
Guangzhou, China | Elderly adults sampled from 18 neighborhoods in 2018 | Remote sensed neighborhood blue space (characteristics, nearness, visitation) | Self-reported mental health assessed by 36-item Short Form Health Survey n = 966 |
age, gender, education, marital status, hukou status, monthly household income, employment information |
Green and Blue Space Availability and Self-Rated health among Seniors in China: Evidence from a National Survey Lin & Wu, 2021, International journal of environmental research and public health [41] |
China | Chinese Social Survey respondents aged 60 years or more from 2011 | Neighborhood green and blue space assessed by linear distance and buffer area coverage via NDVI/Lansat, Inland Surface Water Dataset | Self-reported overall health assessed via Chinese Social Survey n = 1773 |
age, marital status, ethnicity, insurance, lifestyle education, household registration location, occupation, income, assets, distance to major roadway, population density, GDP production per km2 |
The effect of urban nature exposure on mental health—a case study of Guangzhou Liu, 2021, Journal of Cleaner Production [42] |
Guangzhou, China | Survey respondents from 23 residential communities across Guangzhou from 2020 | Nearest park and network distance to park and buffer area coverage of blue space using Open Street Map | Self-reported mental health assessed by the Mental Health Inventory n = 933 |
age, gender, education, income, education, income, occupation, marital status, and residence location, urban, life events |
General health and residential proximity to the coast in Belgium: Results from a cross-sectional health survey Hooyberg, 2020, Environmental research [43] |
Belgium | Respondents of the Belgian Health Interview Survey as of 2013 | Network distance to the coast assessed via Open Street Map | Self-reported general health via Belgian Health Interview Survey n = 60,939 |
age, sex, chronic disease, body mass index, employment, income, smoking, urbanization, year, season, green space, blue space |
Different types of urban natural environments influence various dimensions of self-reported health Jarvis, 2020, Environmental research [37] |
Vancouver, Canada | Respondents of the Canadian Community Health Surveys from 2013–2014 | Buffer landcover type via 2008–2015 LiDAR and aerial photography plus access to public greenspace via presence of greenspace within 300 m | Self-reported general health and mental health assessed via the Canadian Community Health Survey n = 2,183,170 |
age, gender, race/cultural background, education, household income, urbancity |
Cross-sectional association between the neighborhood built environment and physical activity in a rural setting: the Bogalusa Heart Study Gustat, 2020, BMC public health [35] |
Bogalusa, United States | Questionnaire respondents of the Bogalusa Heart Study from 2012–2013 | Built environment scores for buffer area surrounding residence assessed via the Rural Active Living Assessment and Google Street View | Physical Activity Questionnaire data weekly metabolic equivalent minuets for leisure, transport, and total physical data. n = 1245 |
age, race, body mass index, education, income, smoking, alcohol consumption, percent census block below poverty, population density |
Perceived biodiversity, sound, naturalness, and safety enhance the strotive quality and wellbeing benefits of green and blue space in a neotropical city Fisher, 2021, Science of the Total Environment [49] |
Georgetown, Guyana | Survey respondents from 15 natural sites across Georgetown in 2019 | Live birdsong and species diversity assessed via recordings and photography | Self-reported wellbeing assessed via the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule n = 409 |
age, ethnicity, religion, education, household income, location of residence |
Greenspace Inversely Associated with Risk of Alzheimer’s Disease in the Mid-Atlantic United States Wu & Jackson, 2021, Earth [36] |
United States | Centers for Medicaid and Medicare recipients 65 years and older residing in Mid-Atlantic Region from 1999–2013 | Landcover type assessed via aerial photography and classified at the zipcode level | Diagnosis of Alzheimer’s Disease via ICD-9 code in patient record. n = 109,405 |
monthly average PM2.5, percent greenspace, percent water area, houshold income, zip code area, population density, road density |
The Restorative Health Benefits of a Tactical Urban Intervention: An Urban Waterfront Study Roe, 2019, Frontiers in Built Environment [31] |
West Palm Beach, United States | Pedestrians along West Palm Beach Promenade Spring 2017 | Crossover trial comparing normal promenade conditions (i.e., no changes) to one with minor aesthetic changes | Real-time heart rate variability, subjective mood, and perceived restorativeness assessed via wearable device and surveys n = 23 |
NA |
Abbreviations (in order of appearance): WHO, World Health Organization; RI, Rhode Island; GA, Gestational Age; g, Grams; NDVI, Normalized Difference Vegetative Index; SES, Socioeconomic Status; PM2.5, Particular Matter (≤2.5 μm in diameter); GP, General Practitioner; ACC, Accident Compensation Corporation; MIDB, Michigan Inpatient Database; NDWI, Normalized Difference Water Index; ADL, Activities of Daily Life; GDP, Gross Domestic Product.