Skip to main content
. 2022 May 17;19(10):6090. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19106090

Table 1.

Summary of data extracted.

Study Location Population Exposure Outcome & Sample Size Covariates
The Effects of Naturalness, Gender, and Age on how Urban Green Space is Perceived and Used
Sang, 2016, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening
[45]
Gothenburg, Sweden Households living close to six different urban green spaces in 2016 Perceived naturalness based on six areas of diverse character (urban park, woodland, nature area, residential, allotment) assessed by survey Self-report wellbeing assessed by WHO (ten) well-being index
n = 1347
age
gender
Residential Green Space and Birth Outcomes in a Coastal Setting
Glazer, 2018, Environmental Research
[33]
Rhode Island, United States Births occurring at Women & Infants Hospital of Rhode Island, to >17 years at delivery, singleton, living within RI, GA 22–44, birthweight 500–5000 g, with data on covariates from 2002–2004 & 2006–2012 Residential distance to and buffer density of green and blue spaces assessed by NDVI and linear distance Preterm, birthweight, and small for gestational age assessed by birth record and standard cut points (<37 weeks, grams, birth weight < 10th percentile)
n = 61,460
maternal age, race, number of prenatal visits, maternal education, marital status, insurance coverage, tobacco use, neighborhood SES, gestational age at birth,
town of residence, distance to major roadways
The Association Between Natural Environments and Depressive Symptoms in Adolescents Living in the United States
Bezold, 2018, Journal of Adolescent Health
[32]
United States GUTS (Growing Up Today) adolescents cohort 1999 Residential proximity and buffer density of green and blue space assessed by NDVI and linear distance Depressive symptoms assessed by McKnight risk factor survey
n = 9385
race, grade level, age,
gender, household income,
father’s education, maternal history of depression, median tract income,
home value, percent tract white, tract college education, region of country, urban/rural, PM2.5 average for July 1999
Natural Environments and Suicide Mortality in the Netherlands: a Cross-sectional, Ecological Study
Helbich, 2018, The Lancet Planetary Health
[44]
Netherlands National suicide register from 2005–2014 Proportion of greenspace/bluespace and coastal proximity per municipality assessed by Dutch land-use database Registered suicide deaths assessed by death certificate
n = 16,105
gender, divorce, unemployment, housing values, distance to nearest GP, voter alignment, urbancity
Are our Beaches Safe? Quantifying the Human Health Impact of Anthropogenic Beach Litter on People in New Zealand
Campbell, 2019, Science of the Total Environment
[48]
New Zealand
ACC insurance claims from 2007–2016 Reported insurance claims related to injury from beach litter per region Injury type noted in insurance claim
n = 161,261
age, gender, ethnicity, location

Effects of Freshwater Blue Spaces may be Beneficial for Mental Health: A First, Ecological Study in the North American Great Lakes Region
Pearson, 2019, PLoS ONE
[34]
Michigan, United States Michigan residents in the MIDB during 2014 Proximity/coverage of bluespace assessed by linear distance and zip code overlap MIDB reported anxiety/mood disorder
n = 30,421
age, gender,
median income, population density
Human Health Impacts from Litter on Beaches and Associated Perceptions: A Case Study of ‘clean’ Tasmanian Beaches
Campbell, 2016, Ocean & Coastal Management
[47]
Tasmania, Australia Tasmania beach users from 2010–2011 Frequency of attendance to any of nine beaches across Tasmania assessed by survey Survey self-reported injury occuring at beaches related to litter
n = 173
NA
Using Deep Learning to Examine Street View Green and Blue Spaces and their Associations with Geriatric Depression in Beijing, China
Helbich, 2019, Environment International
[39]
Beijing, China Elderly population residing in Haidian district during 2011 Neighborhood green/blue space measured by Landsat, NDVI,NDWI, and street view
neighborhood green/blue space measured by Landsat, NDVI,NDWI, and street view
Depressive symptoms assessed by geriatric depression scale (GDS-15)
n = 1190
gender, age,
education, marital status, ADL score, multiple chronic diseases,
air pollution
Designing Urban Green Spaces for Older Adults in Asian Cities
Tan, 2019
[38]
Hong Kong and Tainan Elderly population of Hong Kong and Tainan 2016–2018 Attendance to one of 31 small scale urban greenspaces General health survey
n = 326
NA
Neighbourhood Blue Space, Health and Wellbeing: The Mediating role of Different Types of Physical Activity
Pasanen, 2019, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
[46]
England, United Kingdom English households from 2008–2012 Coastal proximity to bluespace and present/absent freshwater bluespace assessed by land use database and linear distance Self-reported general health assessed by standardized health survey
n = 21,097
quantity/quality of blue and greenspace, urban/rural, deprivation index,
age, gender, education, marital status, household income, employment, car availability, number of children, long-term illness, year
The neighborhood effect of exposure to blue space on elderly individual’s mental health: A case study in Guangzhou, China
Chen & Yuan, 2020, Health and Place
[40]
Guangzhou, China Elderly adults sampled from 18 neighborhoods in 2018 Remote sensed neighborhood blue space (characteristics, nearness, visitation) Self-reported mental health assessed by 36-item Short Form Health Survey
n = 966
age, gender, education, marital status, hukou status, monthly household income, employment information
Green and Blue Space Availability and Self-Rated health among Seniors in China: Evidence from a National Survey
Lin & Wu, 2021, International journal of environmental research and public health
[41]
China Chinese Social Survey respondents aged 60 years or more from 2011 Neighborhood green and blue space assessed by linear distance and buffer area coverage via NDVI/Lansat, Inland Surface Water Dataset Self-reported overall health assessed via Chinese Social Survey
n = 1773
age, marital status, ethnicity, insurance, lifestyle education, household registration location, occupation, income, assets, distance to major roadway, population density, GDP production per km2
The effect of urban nature exposure on mental health—a case study of Guangzhou
Liu, 2021, Journal of Cleaner Production
[42]
Guangzhou, China Survey respondents from 23 residential communities across Guangzhou from 2020 Nearest park and network distance to park and buffer area coverage of blue space using Open Street Map Self-reported mental health assessed by the Mental Health Inventory
n = 933
age, gender, education, income, education, income, occupation, marital status, and residence location, urban, life events
General health and residential proximity to the coast in Belgium: Results from a cross-sectional health survey
Hooyberg, 2020, Environmental research
[43]
Belgium Respondents of the Belgian Health Interview Survey as of 2013 Network distance to the coast assessed via Open Street Map Self-reported general health via Belgian Health Interview Survey
n = 60,939
age, sex, chronic disease, body mass index, employment, income, smoking, urbanization, year, season, green space, blue space
Different types of urban natural environments influence various dimensions of self-reported health
Jarvis, 2020, Environmental research
[37]
Vancouver, Canada Respondents of the Canadian Community Health Surveys from 2013–2014 Buffer landcover type via 2008–2015 LiDAR and aerial photography plus access to public greenspace via presence of greenspace within 300 m Self-reported general health and mental health assessed via the Canadian Community Health Survey
n = 2,183,170
age, gender, race/cultural background, education, household income, urbancity
Cross-sectional association between the neighborhood built environment and physical activity in a rural setting: the Bogalusa Heart Study
Gustat, 2020, BMC public health
[35]
Bogalusa, United States Questionnaire respondents of the Bogalusa Heart Study from 2012–2013 Built environment scores for buffer area surrounding residence assessed via the Rural Active Living Assessment and Google Street View Physical Activity Questionnaire data weekly metabolic equivalent minuets for leisure, transport, and total physical data.
n = 1245
age, race, body mass index, education, income, smoking, alcohol consumption, percent census block below poverty, population density
Perceived biodiversity, sound, naturalness, and safety enhance the strotive quality and wellbeing benefits of green and blue space in a neotropical city
Fisher, 2021, Science of the Total Environment
[49]
Georgetown, Guyana Survey respondents from 15 natural sites across Georgetown in 2019 Live birdsong and species diversity assessed via recordings and photography Self-reported wellbeing assessed via the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule
n = 409
age, ethnicity, religion, education, household income, location of residence
Greenspace Inversely Associated with Risk of Alzheimer’s Disease in the Mid-Atlantic United States
Wu & Jackson, 2021, Earth
[36]
United States Centers for Medicaid and Medicare recipients 65 years and older residing in Mid-Atlantic Region from 1999–2013 Landcover type assessed via aerial photography and classified at the zipcode level Diagnosis of Alzheimer’s Disease via ICD-9 code in patient record.
n = 109,405
monthly average PM2.5, percent greenspace, percent water area, houshold income, zip code area, population density, road density
The Restorative Health Benefits of a Tactical Urban Intervention: An Urban Waterfront Study
Roe, 2019, Frontiers in Built Environment
[31]
West Palm Beach, United States Pedestrians along West Palm Beach Promenade Spring 2017 Crossover trial comparing normal promenade conditions (i.e., no changes) to one with minor aesthetic changes Real-time heart rate variability, subjective mood, and perceived restorativeness assessed via wearable device and surveys
n = 23
NA

Abbreviations (in order of appearance): WHO, World Health Organization; RI, Rhode Island; GA, Gestational Age; g, Grams; NDVI, Normalized Difference Vegetative Index; SES, Socioeconomic Status; PM2.5, Particular Matter (≤2.5 μm in diameter); GP, General Practitioner; ACC, Accident Compensation Corporation; MIDB, Michigan Inpatient Database; NDWI, Normalized Difference Water Index; ADL, Activities of Daily Life; GDP, Gross Domestic Product.