Table I.
Endometriosis classification/staging system | Publication year | Classification/staging based on | Intended purpose | Details | Reference | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Diagnosis/Pre-op assessment | Description | Staging | Treatment selection | Prediction of difficulty of surgery | Prediction of pain remediation/improved QoL | Prediction of conception | |||||
#ENZIAN classification | 2021 | Surgical observation or imaging | √ | √ | Non-invasive and surgical description system for endometriosis | (Keckstein et al., 2021) | |||||
Adhesion scoring system | 2020 | US | √ | √ | Pre-operative prediction of the pelvic adhesion status | (Ichikawa et al., 2020) | |||||
ENDOGRAM | 2019 | Disease markers in biopsy sample | √ | Analysis of endometriotic tissues supporting therapeutic decisions | (Bouquet de Joliniere et al., 2019) | ||||||
ENDORECT | 2019 | Clinical examination, US, MRI | √ | Preoperative score to predict rectosigmoid involvement | (Chattot et al., 2019) | ||||||
Bowel Endometriosis Syndrome (BENS) score | 2017 | Symptoms | √ | Identify bowel endometriosis syndrome based on patient reported symptoms and QoL | (Riiskjaer et al., 2017) | ||||||
Preoperative ultrasound-based endometriosis staging system (UBESS) | 2016 | US | √ | √ | Pre-operative staging and prediction of the level of complexity of laparoscopic surgery. | (Menakaya et al., 2016) | |||||
Classification of ureteral endometriosis | 2015 | Surgical observation | √ | √ | √ | Clinical classification of urinary tract endometriosis | (Knabben et al., 2015) | ||||
EPHect SSF - EPHect MSF (surgical form) | 2014 | Surgical observation | √ | Recording of surgical phenotypic information and related sample collections obtained at laparoscopy | (Becker et al., 2014) | ||||||
Clinical score | 2014 | Symptoms | √ | √ | Predict DE presence before endometrioma surgery | (Lafay Pillet, et al., 2014) | |||||
LSD/MURO Classification | 2013 | Modified Virtual Colonoscopy | √ | Descriptive imaging classification, with implied severity for rectogenital and disseminated endometriosis | (van der Wat et al., 2013) | ||||||
ECO system | 2012 | Extent, symptoms and objectives | √ | Determine most appropriate management | (Lasmar et al., 2012;2015) | ||||||
Deep endometriosis staging form | 2011 | US | √ | Staging system for DE based on ultrasonographic finding | (Coccia and Rizzello, 2011) | ||||||
Endometriosis Fertility Index (EFI) | 2010 | Surgical observation + Patient parameters | √ | Prediction of (non-IVF) pregnancy after surgery | (Adamson and Pasta, 2010) | ||||||
ENZIAN classification | 2005 | Surgical observation (or MRI) | √1 | √ | Surgical classification for DE | (Keckstein et al., 2021, Tuttlies et al., 2005) | |||||
Chapron classification | 2003 | Surgical observation | √ | √ | Surgical classification for DE with suggested operative procedure | (Chapron et al., 2003a;2003b) | |||||
Revised ASRM classification | 1997 | Surgical observation | √ | √ | Adapted from rAFS score | (American Society for Reproductive Medicine, 1997) | |||||
TOP classification | 1993 | Surgical observation | √ | √ | Evaluate the severity of endometriosis by site, i.e., fallopian tubes (T), ovaries (O) and the peritoneum (P) and impact on PR | (Kurata et al., 1993) | |||||
Revised American Fertility Society (AFS) classification | 1985 | Surgical observation | √ | Point system to determine stage/degree of endometriosis involvement | (American Fertility Society, 1985) | ||||||
American Fertility Society (AFS) classification | 1979 | Surgical observation | √ | (American Fertility Society, 1979) | |||||||
Buttram classification | 1978 | Surgical observation | √ | √ | Classification of endometriosis in the infertile female (expanded from (Acosta, et al., 1973)) | (Buttram, 1978) | |||||
Kistner classification | 1977 | Surgical observation | √ | √ | Classification as a tool to link pregnancy rates with the presence/extent of disease | (Kistner et al., 1977) | |||||
Acosta classification | 1973 | Surgical observation | √ | √ | Classify the extent of disease and relationship with pregnancy rate | (Acosta et al., 1973) |
DE, deep endometriosis; ECO, disease extent complaints, objectives system, QoL, Quality of life; PR, pregnancy rate; US, ultrasound, #ENZIAN: the recently updated ENZIAN classification, which incorporates all types of endometriosis
1In case of ENZIAN score based on MRI.