Skip to main content
. 2022 May 17;13:876868. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2022.876868

TABLE 2.

Characteristics of observational studies included in the systematic review.

Study, year (country) Design Mean age (y) (Ex/Cn) Patients (Ex/Cn) a Treatment regimen Outcomes primary (P) secondary (S) TD DILI criteria/severity Events d (Ex/Cn) AE (Ex/Cn) Summary of conclusion
DILI prevention
Torres-Diaz et al., 2018 c (United States) Study type: retrospective 49 11 Ex: 600 mg oral NAC (b.d) P: INH-induced DILI incidence Average of 47 days DILI criteria: NA 2 0 NAC is a safe and effective measure to prevent INH-induced DILI
SSE: NA Cn: uncontrolled Severity: NA
DILI Treatment
Mumtaz et al. 2009 (Pakistan) Study type: ambispective 28/38.5 47/44 Ex: Oral NAC (140 mg/kg, followed by 70 mg/kg, for a total of 17 doses, 4 h apart within 6 h of admission P: Mortality 72 h DILI criteria: NA 25/32 6/NA NAC causes reduction in mortality and is safe to use in NAI-ALF patients
SSE: 88 Cn: Patients not treated with NAC (historical controls) S: AE and factors predicting mortality Severity: ALF: impaired liver function tests and encephalopathy
Darweesh et al. 2017 (Eqypt) Study type: ambispective 34/35 85/70 Ex: Infusion of 150 mg/kg in 100 ml GLC 5% over 30 min, followed by 70 mg/kg in 500 ml GLC 5% over 4 h, then 70 mg/kg in 500 ml GLC 5% over 16 h. Continuous infusion of 150 mg/kg in 500 ml GLC 5% over 24 h (until INR < 1.3, twice), then oral 600 mg NAC/d P: Mortality and LT 10 days (mean) DILI criteria: NA 1/16 b 96/NA NAC reduces mortality, LT, encephalopathy, hospital stay, ICU admission, and other organ failures in NAI-ALF patients
SSE: 88 Cn: Patients not treated with NAC (historical controls) S: length of ICU stays, hospital stays, organ system failure, hepatic encephalopathy Severity: ALF: TBil > 25 umol/L and INR > 1.5) with or without encephalopathy
Borlak et al. 2018 (Germany) Study type: retrospective 54/53 20/30 Ex: IV 5% GLC with NAC (10 g, 42 ml/h over 24 h × 7 days) and prednisolone (1 mg/kg/d until serum transaminases returned to normal) P: ALT, AST and TBil levels Average of 21 days DILI criteria: NA. 3.03/8.41 (ALT mean value at at 2 weeks) 0 NAC/prednisolone was well tolerated and led to significant ALT, AST and INR improvements within 2 weeks
SSE: NA Cn: sFILI not treated with NAC (external group) Severity: MELD score
Torres-Diaz et al., 2018 c (United States) Study type: retrospective 49 8 Ex: NA P: ALT and AST levels Variable duration DILI criteria: NA 100 (ALT mean value at 30 days) 0 NAC is a safe and effective measure to treat INH-induced DILI
SSE: NA Cn: uncontrolled Severity: NA
Bass et al. (2021) (United States) Study type: retrospective 52./52 13/40 Ex: IV NAC > 72 h P: Time (d) to INR <1.3 or 1.5 Ex:5 days (median) DILI criteria: NA 4/4 (median value) NA Extended duration of NAC leads to higher transplant-free survival, but does not appear to influence time to INR normalization or overall survival
SSE: NA Cn: IV NAC for 72 h S: All-cause mortality and transplant-free survival at 3 weeks Cn: 3 days Severity: ALF: Encephalopathy and coagulopathy (INR ≥ 1.5) in the absence of chronic underlying liver disease, caused by illness of duration <24 weeks
a

Patients included in the final analysis.

b

Number of patients who died.

c

This study evaluated NAC as prevention and treatment in the same study.

d

Related to primary outcome.

Abbreviations: AE, adverse events; ALF, acute liver failure; ALT, alanine aminotransferase; AST, aspartate aminotransferase; b.d., twice daily; Cn, control group; d, day; DILI, drug-induced liver injury; Ex, experimental group; h, hours; GLC, glucose; INH, isoniazid; IV, intravenous; INH, isoniazid; LT, liver transplantation; NA, not available; NAC, N-acetylcysteine; NAI-ALF, non-acetaminophen-induced ALF; INR, international normalized ratio; sFILI, severe flupirtine-induced liver injury; SSE, sample size estimation; TBil, total bilirubin; TD, treatment duration.