Skip to main content
. 2015 Sep 11;2015(9):CD011247. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011247.pub2
Level of child development, current
Study Outcome Mean in control group Mean in treatment group Number of participants Comments
Macours 2008 Level of language development, current
Z‐score of Denver Developmental Screening Test (general language sub‐scale) score. Scale: unclear.
(follow‐up: 8 to 9 months)
unclear 0.17 SDs higher
(0.05 to 0.29 higher)
1577 children Better indicated by higher values
Macours 2008 (follow‐up: 8 to 29 months after 12 months of the intervention) 0.10 SDs higher
(0.01 lower to 0.21 higher)
1469 children
Macours 2008 Level of short‐term memory development, current
Z‐score of McCarthy Scales of Children's Abilities score. Scale: unclear.
(follow‐up: 8 to 9 months)
unclear 0.18 SDs higher
(0.05 to 0.30 higher)
885 children Better indicated by higher values
Macours 2008 (follow‐up: 8 to 29 months after 12 months of the intervention) 0.07 SDs higher
(0.04 lower to 0.17 higher)
1454 children
Macours 2008 Level of fine motor development, current
Z‐score of Denver Developmental Screening Test (fine motor sub‐scale) score. Scale: unclear.
(follow‐up: 8 to 9 months)
unclear 0.09 SDs higher
(0.04 lower to 0.23 higher)
1568 children Better indicated by higher values
Macours 2008 (follow‐up: eight to 29 months after 12 months of the intervention) 0.15 SDs higher
(0.06 to 0.25 higher)
1467 children
Macours 2008 Level of social‐personal development, current
Z‐score of Denver Developmental Screening Test (social‐personal sub‐scale) score. Scale: unclear.
(follow‐up: 8 to 9 months)
unclear 0.11 SDs higher
(0.01 lower to 0.22 higher)
1585 children Better indicated by higher values
Macours 2008 (follow‐up: 8 to 29 months after 12 months of the intervention) 0.09 SDs higher
(0.03 lower to 0.22 higher)
1473 children