Table II.
Overview of literature on life expectancy
Study | Type | Participants/age | n | Treatment | Outcome | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Linos et al. (7) 2013 | Prospective cohort study | Patients with KC, median age 69.0 years (IQR, 55.0-78.0 years) | 1,360 patients with 1,739 KC | No treatment, destruction 2 types of surgery; - Elliptical excision - MMS |
- Most patients were treated surgically - Choice of surgery was not influenced by the patients’ life expectancy - Higher incidences of complications were observed in the group of patients with LLE |
- Observational design patient preference was not measured - A significant part of patients with an estimated LLE lived longer than 5 years |
Linos et al. (8) 2016 | Cross-sectional study | Patients with KC, aged ≥65 years, mean age 79 years | 2,702 patients, 9653 KC | MMS, simple excision or electrodessication and curettage | - Most tumours were treated surgically - Type of treatment was not different between patients with normal life expectancy and LLE |
- KC treated with topical therapies, radiotherapy and untreated KC were not included - Information about patient preferences was not available |
Charles et al. (10) 2002 | Retrospective study | Nonagenarians (90-99 years) with KC | 99 patients | MMS | - Patients no comorbidities had a longer survival than patients with multiple comorbidities (measured with CCI). - Women survived longer than men. - No patient died within 30 days after surgery. |
The variability in survival among patients within a particular CCI was broad. Therefore, predictions of life expectancy for individual patients are not very reliable. |
Delaney et al. (11) 2013 | Retrospective study | Patients with KC aged ≥90 years, mean age 92.3 years | 214 patients | MMS | - No significant difference in survival in patients with different CCI scores. - Defect size, tumour characteristics, number of surgical stages and closure type did not affect survival rates. |
Data about follow-up and causes of death were not available. |
Pascual et al. (12) 2013 | Prospective study | Patients with KC aged ≥80 years | 130 patients | Surgery | Age, comorbidity (measured by the CCI), closure with a graft and the Barthel Index* before surgery were associated with increased mortality | An univariate analysis was performed, no multivariate analyses were performed |
Rogers et al. (13) 2018 | Retrospective study | Patients with KC aged ≥85 years, mean age 88.1 years | 488 patients | MMS vs no MMS | - ACE-27 and ACCI scores can predict LLE - Higher comorbidity scores were associated with decreased survival |
Retrospective study design |
KC: keratinocyte carcinoma; IQR: interquartile range; MMS: Mohs micrographic surgery; LLE: limited life expectancy; CCI: Charlson Comorbidity Index; ACCI: age-adjusted Charlson comorbidity index.
An instrument measuring disability in terms of a person’s level of functional independence in personal activities of daily living.