Skip to main content
. 2022 May 9;14(5):e24856. doi: 10.7759/cureus.24856

Table 1. Important details of the studies included in this systematic review.

DCSS: diffuse cutaneous systemic sclerosis. MRSS: modified Rodnan skin thickness score. CP: collagen peptide. TEWL: trans-epidermal water loss. BCP: bioactive collagen peptide. LMWCP: low molecular weight collagen peptide. H-CP: higher collagen peptide. L-CP: lower collagen peptide

Details of Authors Details about Subjects (n) Details of Groups of study subjects Details about origin of collagen, form of collagen and dose of collagen Duration of study Analysis of Results Variables analysed
Postlethwaite and associates in year 2008 in population of USA [13] DCSS patients (n = 168) Intervention: type I collagen (n = 83) Placebo: acetic acid (n = 83) Bovine/intact/500 µg per day 12 months Decrease in late-phase DCSS compared with placebo MRSS
Choi and associates in year; 2014 in population of the South Korea [25] Healthy subjects Group A: no supplement (n = 8) Group B: CP (n = 8) Group C: CP + vitamin C (n = 8) Group D: vitamin C (n = 8) Hydrolysate/CP = 3 g and vitamin C = 500 µg 12 weeks Increase in CP group compared with controls Stratum corneum hydration
          Decrease in CP group compared with controls TEWL
          Increase in CP group compared with controls Skin elasticity
Kuwaba and associates in year 2014  [26] Women with dry and saggy face Intervention: CP/Placebo: Fish/hydrolysate/5 g 8 weeks Decreased compared with placebo group Wrinkle number
          Increased compared with placebo group Skin dryness
Proksch and associates in year 2014 in population of  Brazil  [2] Healthy females (n = 57) Intervention: BCP  Placebo: maltodextrin NR/hydrolysate/2.5 g per day 8 weeks Decreased compared with placebo group Skin wrinkle volume
          Increased compared with placebo group BCP type I procollagen
          Increased compared with placebo group BCP elastin
Inoue and associates in year 2015 in population of China [14 Healthy females Intervention 1: H-CP (n = 28) Intervention 2: L-CP (n = 29) Placebo: maltodextrin (n = 28) Fish gelatin/hydrolysate/5 g 8 weeks Increase in H-CP group compared with L-CP and placebo; increase in L-CP group compared with placebo Facial moisture
          Increase in H-CP group compared with L-CP and placebo. Facial elasticity
          Decrease in H-CP group compared with L-CP and placebo; decrease in L-CP group compared with placebo Facial roughness
Sugihara and associates in 2015 in population of  China [27] Healthy females Intervention: CP (n = 28) Placebo: maltodextrin (n = 28) hydrolysate/2.5 g 8 weeks Increased compared with placebo group Facial hydration
          Increased compared with placebo group Facial elasticity
          Decreased compared with placebo group Facial roughness
Mori and associates in year 2017in population of Japan [12] Healthy females with nail fragile and or thinly peeled off Intervention: CP (n = 10) Placebo: dextrin (n = 10) Porcine skin/hydrolysate/5 g 12 weeks Increased compared with placebo group Nail moisture
          Decreased compared with placebo group Nail hardness
          Increased compared with placebo group Nail sphingosine
          Increased compared with placebo group Nail ceramides 
Kim and associates in year 2018 in population of Korea [3] Healthy females   Intervention: LMWCH (n = 32) Placebo: same formula except CP Fish/hydrolysate/1 g 12 weeks Increase in LMWCH group compared with Placebo Skin hydration
          Decrease in LMWCH group compared with placebo Crow's-feet scores 
          Increase in LMWCH group compared with placebo Skin elasticity
Koizumi and associates in year 2018 in population of Japan [15] Healthy females Intervention: beverage containing CP (n = 38) Placebo: beverage Fish/hydrolysate/3 g 12 weeks Increased compared with placebo group Facial moisture 
          Increased compared with placebo group Skin elasticity
          Decreased compared with placebo group Periorbital wrinkles 
Yamamoto [28] and associates in year 2018 and population of Japan     Healthy subjects with dry skin Intervention: drink containing CP (n = 18) Placebo: drink (n = 18) Porcine skin/hydrolysate/10 g 8 weeks Decreased compared with placebo group TEWL