Table 1. Important details of the studies included in this systematic review.
DCSS: diffuse cutaneous systemic sclerosis. MRSS: modified Rodnan skin thickness score. CP: collagen peptide. TEWL: trans-epidermal water loss. BCP: bioactive collagen peptide. LMWCP: low molecular weight collagen peptide. H-CP: higher collagen peptide. L-CP: lower collagen peptide
Details of Authors | Details about Subjects (n) | Details of Groups of study subjects | Details about origin of collagen, form of collagen and dose of collagen | Duration of study | Analysis of Results | Variables analysed |
Postlethwaite and associates in year 2008 in population of USA [13] | DCSS patients (n = 168) | Intervention: type I collagen (n = 83) Placebo: acetic acid (n = 83) | Bovine/intact/500 µg per day | 12 months | Decrease in late-phase DCSS compared with placebo | MRSS |
Choi and associates in year; 2014 in population of the South Korea [25] | Healthy subjects | Group A: no supplement (n = 8) Group B: CP (n = 8) Group C: CP + vitamin C (n = 8) Group D: vitamin C (n = 8) | Hydrolysate/CP = 3 g and vitamin C = 500 µg | 12 weeks | Increase in CP group compared with controls | Stratum corneum hydration |
Decrease in CP group compared with controls | TEWL | |||||
Increase in CP group compared with controls | Skin elasticity | |||||
Kuwaba and associates in year 2014 [26] | Women with dry and saggy face | Intervention: CP/Placebo: | Fish/hydrolysate/5 g | 8 weeks | Decreased compared with placebo group | Wrinkle number |
Increased compared with placebo group | Skin dryness | |||||
Proksch and associates in year 2014 in population of Brazil [2] | Healthy females (n = 57) | Intervention: BCP Placebo: maltodextrin | NR/hydrolysate/2.5 g per day | 8 weeks | Decreased compared with placebo group | Skin wrinkle volume |
Increased compared with placebo group | BCP type I procollagen | |||||
Increased compared with placebo group | BCP elastin | |||||
Inoue and associates in year 2015 in population of China [14] | Healthy females | Intervention 1: H-CP (n = 28) Intervention 2: L-CP (n = 29) Placebo: maltodextrin (n = 28) | Fish gelatin/hydrolysate/5 g | 8 weeks | Increase in H-CP group compared with L-CP and placebo; increase in L-CP group compared with placebo | Facial moisture |
Increase in H-CP group compared with L-CP and placebo. | Facial elasticity | |||||
Decrease in H-CP group compared with L-CP and placebo; decrease in L-CP group compared with placebo | Facial roughness | |||||
Sugihara and associates in 2015 in population of China [27] | Healthy females | Intervention: CP (n = 28) Placebo: maltodextrin (n = 28) | hydrolysate/2.5 g | 8 weeks | Increased compared with placebo group | Facial hydration |
Increased compared with placebo group | Facial elasticity | |||||
Decreased compared with placebo group | Facial roughness | |||||
Mori and associates in year 2017in population of Japan [12] | Healthy females with nail fragile and or thinly peeled off | Intervention: CP (n = 10) Placebo: dextrin (n = 10) | Porcine skin/hydrolysate/5 g | 12 weeks | Increased compared with placebo group | Nail moisture |
Decreased compared with placebo group | Nail hardness | |||||
Increased compared with placebo group | Nail sphingosine | |||||
Increased compared with placebo group | Nail ceramides | |||||
Kim and associates in year 2018 in population of Korea [3] | Healthy females | Intervention: LMWCH (n = 32) Placebo: same formula except CP | Fish/hydrolysate/1 g | 12 weeks | Increase in LMWCH group compared with Placebo | Skin hydration |
Decrease in LMWCH group compared with placebo | Crow's-feet scores | |||||
Increase in LMWCH group compared with placebo | Skin elasticity | |||||
Koizumi and associates in year 2018 in population of Japan [15] | Healthy females | Intervention: beverage containing CP (n = 38) Placebo: beverage | Fish/hydrolysate/3 g | 12 weeks | Increased compared with placebo group | Facial moisture |
Increased compared with placebo group | Skin elasticity | |||||
Decreased compared with placebo group | Periorbital wrinkles | |||||
Yamamoto [28] and associates in year 2018 and population of Japan | Healthy subjects with dry skin | Intervention: drink containing CP (n = 18) Placebo: drink (n = 18) | Porcine skin/hydrolysate/10 g | 8 weeks | Decreased compared with placebo group | TEWL |