Table 1.
Reference | Social stress type (measure) | Substance use/disorder | Sample | Paradigm (social stress or other) | Imaging tool/procedure | Analysis type | Prime brain regions | Brain-behavior associations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Past social stress/trauma | ||||||||
(Van Dam et al. 2014) | Childhood maltreatment (CTQ) | Alcohol, cocaine, and/or cannabis | 79 in-treatment SUD; 98 CON | N/A | 3T MRI VBM | Whole-brain; ROI | CM (controlling for SUD): ↓L hippocampus, ↓parahippocampus, ↓anterior fusiform gyrus |
↓CM-related gray matter volume, ↑severity of substance use after initial relapse |
(Bachi et al. 2018) | Childhood maltreatment (CTQ) | Cocaine | 24 CUD + CM; 23 CUD-CM; 29 CON | N/A | 3T MRI VBM | Whole-brain | CUD + CM > CON| CUD-CM: ↓R lateral OFC CUD + CM > CON: ↓middle temporal gyrus | ↓R lateral OFC, ↑depression and ↓constraint |
(Elton et al. 2015) | Childhood maltreatment (CTQ) | Cocaine | 20 male CUD + CM; 18 male CUD-CM | Guided imagery induction. Post-task: anxiety, craving | 3T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain; ROI | Stress > neutral script (CUD + CM): ↓L dorsal-anterior precuneus, ↓L supplementary motor area CTQ score-by-craving rating interaction: ↓rostral ACC | ↓L precuneus and ↓L supplementary motor area, ↑physical and emotional abuse |
(Ieong and Yuan 2018) | Childhood maltreatment (Adverse Childhood Experiences; (Felitti et al. 1998)) | Heroin and/or nicotine | 7 heroin (abstinent >3 months)-nicotine dependence +CM; 7 nicotine dependence +CM; 7 CON | Reading the mind in the eyes | Continuous wave; functional near-infrared spectroscopy; Resting-state FC | ROI | Heroin-nicotine dependence > nicotine dependence: ↑OFC, ↑mPFC, ↓dorsolateral PFC | N/A |
(Casement et al. 2015) | Stressful life events in late adolescence (Life Event Questionnaire for Adolescents (Masten et al. 1994) and Interpersonal Problem Situations Inventory for Urban Adolescents; (Farrell et al. 1998)) | Alcohol (problematic use) | 152 males | Reward-guess task | 3T fMRI BOLD | ROI | Stress scores; severity of alcohol use, association with reward: Anticipation of reward and reward outcome = ↓mPFC | ↓mPFC, ↑cumulative life stress events and ↑severity of alcohol use |
(Poppa et al. 2019) | PTSD (lifetime sexual trauma; Life Stressors Checklist-Revised; (Wolfe and Kimerling 1997)) | Methamphetamine and/or cocaine | 14 female SUD-PTSD; 29 female SUD | Interoceptive-exteroceptive attention | 3T fMRI FC of task-modulated networks | Whole-brain | SUD-PTSD > SUD: ↓OFC network located in the mid-posterior insula, angular gyrus, precuneus, and lateral prefrontal cortex areas | ↓OFC network strength, ↑sexual violence exposure across all participants |
(Gawrysiak et al. 2017) | Trauma history (lifetime; Addiction Severity Index; (McLellan et al. 1992)) | Cocaine | 18 CUD-trauma; 16 CUD | N/A | 3T fMRI Resting-stateFC | Seed-based (amygdala) | Trauma: ↑amygdala and limbic-striatal regions connectivity | N/A |
Social stress induction | ||||||||
(Seo et al. 2011) | N/A | Alcohol (social drinking) | 20 males; 23 females |
Guided imagery induction | 3T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain | Stress script (both): ↑L dorsal striatum Stress script (male > female): ↑mPFC, ↑rostral ACC, ↑posterior insula, ↑putamen, ↑amygdala ↑hippocampus, ↑parahippocampal gyrus |
↑dorsal striatum, ↑craving in males |
(Li et al. 2005) | N/A | Cocaine | 17 male CUD; 10 female CUD |
Guided imagery induction. Post-task: Anxiety, craving | 1.5T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain; ROI | Stress script (both): ↑mid temporal gyrus Stress script (female > male): ↑middle, medial, inferior frontal cortical areas, ↑anterior cingulate, ↑insula, ↑middle and inferior frontal cortices, ↑R posterior cingulate cortex | ↑L anterior cingulate and ↑R posterior cingulate cortices, ↓craving rating during stress imagery in female CUDs |
(Li et al. 2006) | N/A | Cocaine | 17 male CUD; 10 female CUD |
Guided imagery induction | 1.5T fMRI BOLD | ROI | Stress script (both): ↑R inferior frontal cortex, ↑mPFC, ↑R anterior cingulate | ↑mPFC and ↓L posterior cingulate cortex, ↓socialization in female CUDs |
(Sinha et al. 2005) | N/A | Cocaine | 20 CUD; 8 CON |
Guided imagery induction | 1.5T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain | Stress script (CUD): ↓ medial orbitofrontal/anterior cingulate region, ↓R postcentral gyrus, ↓R fusiform gyrus, ↓L precentral gyrus, ↓medial FG, ↓L hippocampus, ↑caudate, ↑ dorsal striatum | ↑caudate and ↑dorsal striatum, ↑stress-induced cocaine craving ratings |
(Kober et al. 2017) | N/A | Nicotine | 11 smokers in mindfulness training; 12 smokers in freedom from smoking treatment |
Guided imagery induction | 1.5T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain | Stress script (both): ↑↓cluster in amygdala, anterior insula, mid insula, hippocampus, parahippocampal gyrus, thalamus, middle occipital gyrus, midbrain, cerebellum, and R posterior insula; ↑↓cluster across cuneus/precuneus, posterior cingulate cortex | ↑neural activity during stress, ↓post-treatment cigarettes per day reduction. Protracted effect in similar brain regions at 3 months follow-up |
(Maurage et al. 2012) | N/A | Alcohol | 22 AUD; 22 CON |
Cyberball | 3T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain | AUD > CON (social exclusion): ↑R insula, ↓R ventral PFC, ↓L medial FG AUD > CON (re-inclusion post social exclusion): ↑L dorsal ACC, ↑parahippocampal gyrus |
N/A |
(Hanlon et al. 2018) | N/A | Cocaine | 18 CUD; 25 CON |
Cyberball | 3T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain | CUD > CON (social exclusion > inclusion): ↑R medial FG/pregenual cingulate ↑L ventral FG, ↑R caudate |
N/A |
(Bach et al. 2019a, b) | N/A | Opioid | 19 OMT; 20 CON |
Cyberball | 3T fMRI VBM | Whole-brain; ROI | OMT > CON (VBM): ↓anterior insula, ↓L inferior FG, ↓R frontal lobe, ↓R inferior FG | ↓L insula, ↓reduced feelings of inclusion during inclusion trial and ↑feelings of exclusion during inclusion trial. ↓L insula, ↑social interaction anxiety symptoms |
(Bach et al. 2019a, b) | N/A | Opioid | 17 OMT; 21 CON |
Cyberball | 3 T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain | OMT > CON (social exclusion and inclusion): ↓ superior and middle occipital and lingual gyri, ↓ cunei, ↓L fusiform gyrus | N/A |
(Beard et al. 2021) | N/A | Alcohol and/or cannabis use | 181 adolescents | Cyberball | 3T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain: ROI | Exclusion > inclusion: ↑dorsal ACC, ↑subgenual ACC, ↑anterior insula |
↓dorsal ACC and ↑anxiety, ↑substance use later in adolescence ↓dorsal ACC and ↑distress (game-related), ↑substance use later in adolescence ↑anterior insula, ↑substance use in females |
(Charlet et al. 2014) | N/A | Alcohol | 33 AUD; 33 CON |
Facial emotion recognition (aversive faces) | 3T fMRI BOLD & VBM | ROI | AUD > CON (BOLD): ↓ FG, ↑L rostral ACC, ↑L anterior cingulate cortex/ medial FG, ↑R precuneus AUD > CON (VBM): ↓FG, ↓ rostral ACC, ↓frontal regions (ACC, insula, temporal, occipital gyri) | ↑L rostral ACC, ↑days of abstinence and ↓days of binge drinking. ↑FG activation, ↑lifetime drinking |
(Bedi et al. 2009) | N/A | MDMA (administration) | 9 individuals with past MDMA use | Facial emotion recognition (aversive faces) | 3T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain; ROI | MDMA 1.5 mg/kg > MDMA 0.75 mg/kg |Placebo (angry > neutral faces): ↓L amygdala MDMA 0.75 mg/kg > MDMA 1.5 mg/kg|Placebo (happy > neutral): ↑R ventral striatum | ↑R ventral striatum, no effect on self-reported sociability in MDMA (0.75 mg/kg) |
(Flanagan et al. 2019) | N/A | Alcohol, cannabis and/or cocaine | 10 couples (n = 20) w/one partner w/ hazardous drinking or SUD | Relationship conflict | 3T fMRI BOLD | ROI | Female > male (conflict > neutral): ↑R amygdala-L inferior FG and mid-cingulate connectivity, ↑L OFC-R mid temporal gyrus connectivity Male > female (conflict > neutral): ↑R OFC-R, amygdala/hippocampus connectivity Group (conflict): ↑R OFC-R frontal pole connectivity | ↑R amygdala and L prefrontal cortex FC during the conflict or neutral cues, ↑intimate partner violence victimization and perpetration |
(Dagher et al. 2009) | N/A | Nicotine | 15 nicotine smokers | Montreal imaging stress task. Post-task: Cue-reactivity | 3 T fMRI BOLD | Whole-brain; ROI | Stressful > non-stressful: ↓hippocampus, ↓amygdala, ↓bed nucleus of the stria terminalis, ↓hypothalamus, ↓nucleus accumbens Stressful > non-stressful (smoking cue-reactivity): ↑dorsomedial PFC, ↑dorsal caudate, ↑dorsomedial thalamus, ↑hippocampus |
↑hippocampus, ↑amygdala, and ↑nucleus accumbens, ↑cue-reactivity and ↑ craving response |
Notes: Childhood Trauma Questionnaire (CTQ; (Bernstein et al. 2003)) Substance use disorder (SUD); Control (CON); Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI); Voxel-based morphometry (VBM); Childhood maltreatment (CM); Left (L); Cocaine use disorder (CUD); Right (R); Orbitofrontal cortex (OFC); Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI); Blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD); Region-of-interest (ROI); Anterior cingulate cortex (ACC); Functional connectivity (FC); Prefrontal cortex (PFC); Medial PFC (mPFC); Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD); Frontal gyrus (FG); Alcohol use disorder (AUD); Opioid methadone treatment (OMT); 3,4-Methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA)