Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 20;30(6):645–652. doi: 10.1038/s41431-021-01022-5

Table 2.

Characteristics of final full-text articles included.

Author Year Location Methods Population Stated aim
Bernhardt 2011 Not stated: HHT Foundation based in USA Mixed: 1. Surveys and 2. Online discussion groups People from hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia families To identify barriers to genetic testing for HHT with the intention of developing recommendations to address some of the identified barriers.
Boothe 2020 USA Quantitative: Survey Genetic counsellors (members of National Society of Genetic Counselors) To characterise genetic counsellors’ perspectives regarding evaluation and implementation of service delivery models.
Bucio 2019 Mexico Mixed: 1. quantitative text analysis and 2. follow up interviews 2. Key informants: professionals in education, clinicians, or laboratory scientists who trained and currently worked in a medical genetics-related capacity in Mexico To describe the current state of genetic counselling services and potential need for genetic counselling as a separate profession in Mexico.
Burton 2010 UK Quantitative: Survey Heads of regional specialist genetic services To investigate the equity of specialist provision in the UK and make recommendations for service development
Cohen 2016 USA Qualitative: Interviews Participants who previously participated in the internet survey administered by the NSGC SDMTF (Cohen et al. 2013) To provide information regarding different service delivery models used in the practice of genetic counselling in the United States and to identify advantages and limitations of these models, as well as barriers to implementation.
Cohen 2013 USA Quantitative: Survey Genetic counsellors (members of National Society of Genetic Counselors) To describe the current landscape of GC service delivery by surveying professional practice nationally.
Harding 2019 Southeastern Ontario, Canada Qualitative: Interviews Primary care providers (PCPs) To explore genetics in primary care from the perspective of both rural and urban PCPs.
Harrison 2015 England, UK Mixed: 1. Review of national audit data and 2. telephone survey 1. National audit data (all test requests and results (n = 1839) issued between 2003 and 2011)2. Lead contacts (14 consultants, 5 GCs and 1 specialist registrar) from the nine healthcare regions of the NHS in England

To identify and quantify the extent of current variation in service provision for a specialist genetic testing service in the English NHS, specifically inherited retinal dystrophy.

To integrate quantitative findings with exemplars of current working practices and models of service delivery and funding.

Hawkins 2013 British Columbia, Canada Qualitative: Interviews People at risk of Huntington Disease (HD)

To understand and explore whether accessibility of Predictive Testing services is a barrier to testing, we conducted an interview study of individuals at risk for HD throughout BC.

To understand the obstacles to testing in terms of the accessibility of services in Vancouver, as well as exploring the mechanisms by which this issue may be addressed

Holloway 2010 South East Scotland, UK Quantitative: Secondary data analysis Families referred to the South East Scotland Clinical Genetics Service To make comparisons between the referral and attendance rates (and in particular the relationship of these rates to socio-economic status) of the families offered an appointment at the regional clinic and the families offered an appointment at one of the three satellite clinics.
Kaye 2020 USA Mixed: 1. In person and telephone based ‘sessions’ 2. Survey 1. American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics members, Family Voices members, American Academy of Pediatrics Genetics workgroup, regional genetics collaboratives, public health genetics professionals, and consumer organizations2. Consumers, genetics professionals, public health, and primary care professionals To outline structures for regional genetic services support centres that improve access to clinical genetic services
Penon-Portmann 2020 California, USA Quantitative: Analysis of geographical data Medical geneticists, biochemical medical geneticists, and genetic counsellors in the state of California

To assess the number of genetics providers and potential patterns in care, we examined the genetics workforce in California and the distances people travelled for in-person care.

To investigate the potential impact of the workforce shortage on vulnerable sociodemographic populations in California

Qian 2019 USA and Malaysia Quantitative: Survey Families with rare diseases To explore what areas of the current healthcare system are perceived as needing improvement by querying patients in genetics clinics.
Senier 2015 Wisconsin Mixed: 1. Quantitative analysis of geographical data 2. Interviews 2. Healthcare providers and policymakers who were instrumental in founding, operating, or administering Wisconsin’s genetic outreach clinics To examine one state’s experience sponsoring outreach clinics that provide clinical genetic services to improve access to specialty healthcare in underserved communities.
Shields 2010 UK Quantitative: Referral to genetic testing/census data People suspected to have maturity onset diabetes of the young To examine the referral patterns in the UK for genetic testing for maturity onset diabetes of the young
Smith 2015 USA Quantitative: Survey Parents of children with special health care needs To investigate whether access to genetic counselling improved over time and to examine the impact of child, family, and health system factors on access to genetic counselling.
Terry 2019 USA Quantitative: Survey Programmes delivering genetics by telegenetics To comprehensively describe of the current regional telegenetics landscape
Triebold 2020 USA Quantitative: Mapping of geographical data Certified genetic counsellors (CGCs) To map the distribution of all CGCs (patient-facing and non-patient-facing) across the nation at county level and assessed the number of CGCs per capita in U.S. metropolitan statistical areas.
Vieira 2013 Brazil Quantitative: Survey Survey completed by clinical geneticists in relation to people with/suspected to have 22q11.2 deletion To investigated some critical aspects of access to genetic testing in different services and concentrated the laboratorial diagnosis of patients with palatal abnormalities and suspicion of 22q11.2 DS sent from those genetic centres, which participated voluntarily in the study.
Villegas 2019 USA Quantitative: Geospatial analysis Genetic counsellors To examine the availability of genetic counsellors working in the Southern U.S. and the demographics in areas with and without practicing Certified Genetic Counsellors.