Skip to main content
. 2022 May 27;15(11):3827. doi: 10.3390/ma15113827
Ref. Beam ** TR,exp TR,thSiNiP18 TR,thACI89 TR,thACI19 TR,thMC90 TR,thMC10 TR,thEC2 TR,thCSA14 TR,thRahal TR,thProp
(kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm)
B110.3 * P 24.77 50.24 23.98 13.0 31.5 22.3 36.8 44.8 22.5 22.48
Koutchoukali, Belarbi (2001) B5UR1 P 19.40 16.42 18.14 16.0 14.5 22.4 17.4 18.8 18.1 19.46
B7UR1 P 18.90 16.87 20.50 18.4 15.0 25.7 18.0 19.4 20.0 22.11
B9UR1 P 21.10 16.42 20.12 17.8 14.5 24.8 17.4 18.8 20.0 22.36
B12UR1 P 19.40 16.87 21.28 18.4 15.0 25.7 18.0 19.4 20.8 23.21
B12UR2 P 18.40 17.04 21.41 18.6 15.2 26.0 18.2 19.6 20.8 23.10
B12UR3 P 22.50 19.10 22.29 21.6 17.6 30.1 21.2 22.8 22.9 25.15
B12UR4 P 23.70 19.09 23.28 22.1 19.5 33.3 23.4 25.2 24.7 27.03
B12UR5 P 24.00 25.70 27.89 22.2 22.2 37.7 26.6 29.3 27.5 29.83
B14UR1 P 21.00 16.64 21.43 18.1 14.8 25.2 17.7 19.1 21.0 23.74
Fang, Shiau (2004) H-06-06 P 92.00 57.90 85.00 76.0 57.8 113.1 70.1 80.1 87.4 95.25
H-06-12 P 115.10 66.14 84.79 96.4 73.3 135.1 88.9 101.6 103.1 110.75
H-07-10 P 126.70 86.66 85.35 99.6 75.8 128.9 91.8 104.9 103.2 109.71
H-07-16 P 144.50 122.53 85.35 113.5 97.8 109.1 118.5 135.5 123.4 129.06
H-12-12 P 155.30 80.31 133.52 121.6 103.7 158.3 125.7 143.6 131.5 138.06
H-12-16 P 196.00 140.15 133.52 121.6 137.0 146.3 166.0 189.7 159.7 164.77
H-14-10 P 135.20 97.96 124.21 113.5 100.3 149.9 121.5 138.9 125.6 131.16
H-20-20 * P 239.00 167.22 180.32 121.6 200.1 158.5 242.5 277.1 166.9 166.74
N-06-06 P 79.70 57.84 72.98 76.1 57.9 80.6 70.2 80.2 77.0 80.17
N-06-12 P 95.20 66.14 72.98 81.8 73.3 70.1 88.9 101.6 90.8 93.16
N-07-10 P 111.70 86.66 75.24 79.4 75.8 68.7 91.8 104.9 92.1 93.90
N-07-16 P 117.30 122.53 75.24 79.4 97.8 58.2 118.5 135.5 110.1 110.46
N-12-12 * P 116.80 80.31 121.26 81.8 103.7 82.1 125.7 143.6 115.8 116.13
N-12-16 * P 138.00 140.15 121.26 81.8 137.0 75.9 166.0 183.3 131.5 131.41
N-14-10 * P 125.00 97.96 114.11 79.4 100.3 79.9 121.5 138.9 112.0 112.26
N-20-20 * P 158.00 167.22 121.26 81.8 155.4 82.2 195.1 183.3 131.5 131.41
Chiu et al. (2007) HAS-51-50 P 84.90 40.48 73.94 54.7 37.9 82.9 50.6 57.7 68.6 76.34
NAS-61-35 P 74.70 48.22 56.00 50.2 34.8 75.0 46.3 52.8 60.0 65.34
HAS-90-50 P 104.23 63.51 74.50 73.0 50.6 109.1 67.4 76.9 84.2 92.19
NBS-43-44 P 60.60 34.20 54.67 45.8 34.8 69.1 42.2 48.2 53.8 57.82
HBS-74-17 P 62.20 65.76 52.24 52.7 40.1 78.5 48.6 55.5 65.9 72.85
HBS-82-13 P 56.30 68.29 47.26 47.1 35.8 70.1 43.4 49.6 60.9 67.83
NBS-82-13 P 52.90 68.29 38.02 47.1 35.8 47.5 43.4 49.6 54.9 58.88
HBS-60-61 P 93.70 52.35 76.14 63.7 48.5 94.8 58.8 67.2 75.3 82.25
HCS-52-50 P 73.54 40.26 63.60 44.9 37.4 65.8 41.1 47.3 64.5 72.11
HCS-91-50 P 95.86 59.72 63.93 59.9 49.9 86.1 54.8 63.1 79.2 87.07
Lee and Kim (2010) T1-1 P 32.90 23.41 30.99 26.4 19.3 38.6 24.5 27.8 29.6 32.32
T1-2 P 45.90 27.93 40.26 39.9 29.2 50.6 37.1 42.1 39.7 42.27
T1-3 P 54.10 30.94 47.99 41.6 38.5 48.2 49.1 55.6 47.8 49.85
T1-4 P 62.40 54.32 64.60 42.0 56.7 51.1 72.1 81.7 62.8 63.97
T2-2 P 38.10 41.82 30.76 36.8 26.9 42.2 34.2 38.8 37.2 39.67
* Fragile failure; ** P—Plain section; H—Hollow section.