Skip to main content
. 2022 May 27;15(11):3827. doi: 10.3390/ma15113827
Ref. Beam ** TR,exp TR,thSiNiP18 TR,thACI89 TR,thACI19 TR,thMC90 TR,thMC10 TR,thEC2 TR,thCSA14 TR,thRahal TR,thProp
(kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm)
T2-3 P 50.20 44.88 39.14 42.1 40.1 42.8 51.0 57.7 49.3 51.36
T2-4 P 56.40 62.46 43.55 42.0 47.1 43.4 60.0 68.0 55.2 56.94
Peng, Wong (2011) SW12-1 P 74.00 66.82 43.22 39.7 48.7 59.0 50.3 57.8 87.3 91.40
SW10-1 P 50.70 54.79 33.97 26.4 39.8 30.7 41.3 47.5 63.9 65.62
SW10-2 P 68.00 58.02 49.70 31.0 52.2 59.0 54.3 64.5 76.3 76.21
SW10-3 P 74.30 62.29 40.61 25.3 66.5 39.8 69.1 51.7 67.6 67.51
SW10-4 * P 80.50 76.05 43.46 24.9 87.1 44.2 91.6 54.5 70.4 70.32
SW8-1 P 40.40 30.61 26.43 21.1 30.8 24.6 32.3 35.3 44.8 46.59
SW8-2 P 60.10 34.63 32.48 19.5 50.2 31.7 52.7 39.8 52.3 52.30
Joh et al. (2019) RA-SD4-3.2-0.3-3.28 * P 86.80 97.32 58.91 75.6 74.0 60.9 91.1 110.0 86.5 90.30
RA-SD5-3.2-0.3-3.21 * P 88.00 103.65 59.32 75.6 78.2 58.9 96.2 116.2 89.8 93.41
RA-SD6-3.2-0.2-3.21 * P 89.40 126.46 59.32 75.6 87.8 53.7 108.1 130.5 93.5 93.41
RA-SD4-3.2-0.5-2.13 * P 76.30 63.56 60.39 78.1 55.4 80.1 68.1 82.3 72.2 77.41
RA-SD5-3.2-0.7-1.63 * P 74.50 53.42 60.80 70.4 49.9 82.7 61.4 74.2 67.1 72.47
RA-SD6-3.2-0.6-1.63 * P 70.00 61.20 60.80 76.7 54.3 79.0 66.9 80.8 71.2 76.49
RA-SD4-3.2-1.1-1.33 * P 74.20 35.28 60.18 53.0 37.5 78.8 46.2 55.8 54.8 60.21
RA-SD5-3.2-1.0-1.26 * P 67.70 37.83 60.59 55.9 39.6 83.1 48.7 58.9 56.9 62.29
RA-SD6-3.2-0.8-1.26 * P 69.90 54.08 60.59 62.6 44.4 86.2 54.6 66.0 61.6 66.96
Ju et al. (2019) MR30-0.77 P 55.00 39.38 50.92 49.2 37.4 55.3 45.4 51.9 55.0 58.27
MT30-1.32 * P 57.00 80.08 50.92 74.3 56.9 43.7 69.0 78.8 73.8 76.05
MT40-1.32 * P 58.30 80.08 54.73 74.8 56.9 64.7 69.0 78.8 77.6 81.52
MT40-1.89 P 98.40 93.65 106.57 87.1 94.1 89.9 114.1 130.4 110.4 112.27
Ibrahim et al. (2020) NSC-S1-C30 * P 19.70 24.21 23.08 17.0 20.8 20.9 24.9 27.9 23.1 24.34
NSC-S1-C45 * P 12.50 24.21 18.54 10.2 16.9 21.1 20.3 21.9 22.9 23.99
HSC-C30 * P 19.90 24.21 24.13 20.5 20.8 28.0 24.9 27.9 24.5 26.37
HSC-C45 * P 13.80 24.21 19.75 12.6 16.9 28.7 20.3 21.9 24.5 26.37
Kim et al. (2020) S08-3-65 P 123.00 71.29 107.84 95.8 82.9 143.1 99.4 100.9 114.5 118.81
S08-4-90 P 124.00 63.67 111.18 102.4 89.6 149.3 107.5 109.0 120.9 124.81
S08-5-122.5 P 89.00 80.78 103.94 95.4 82.5 142.5 99.1 100.5 114.2 118.51
S10-3-52.5 P 126.00 77.60 124.27 102.4 103.7 150.3 124.4 126.2 133.9 136.98
S10-4-72.5 * P 109.00 99.74 128.72 102.4 110.7 149.5 132.8 134.7 140.2 142.79
S10-5-100 * P 108.00 90.17 118.70 102.4 101.6 147.7 121.9 123.7 132.1 135.24
S06-3-90 P 101.00 43.20 88.35 70.4 60.9 105.2 73.1 74.2 92.3 97.71
S10-5-90 * P 106.00 95.94 127.61 102.4 113.0 147.6 135.6 137.6 142.3 144.70
S08-3-72.5 P 106.00 66.73 100.60 86.3 74.7 129.0 89.7 91.0 106.5 111.23
S12-5-72.5 * P 120.00 123.96 149.33 102.4 140.4 147.6 168.5 170.9 165.6 166.13
Hsu (1968) D3 H 39.11 66.5 27.11 28.3 26.2 23.6 31.5 35.8 32.1 38.97
D4 * H 47.93 75.27 45.20 29.4 44.9 29.6 53.9 61.2 47.3 47.92
[17,38] T0 H 185.50 116.4 91.25 112.2 99.9 139.4 133.3 146.6 146.8 161.65
T1 H 140.01 70.87 106.45 110.6 83.8 132.0 111.7 133.4 124.7 128.92
T2 H 143.10 74.0 87.13 99.3 76.2 127.2 101.6 111.8 116.7 128.99
* Fragile failure. ** P—Plain section; H—Hollow section.