Skip to main content
. 2022 May 27;15(11):3827. doi: 10.3390/ma15113827
Ref. Beam ** TR,exp TR,thSiNiP18 TR,thACI89 TR,thACI19 TR,thMC90 TR,thMC10 TR,thEC2 TR,thCSA14 TR,thRahal TR,thProp
(kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm)
T5 H 156.88 87.7 192.68 135.1 109.3 216.9 124.9 142.3 165.6 185.69
[19] VH1 H 21.79 12.84 21.04 20.1 12.7 14.5 16.9 21.2 19.6 20.82
VH2 * H 34.50 25.6 46.24 32.9 30.2 15.5 41.6 51.2 49.9 32.35
Bernardo, Lopes (2009) A1 H 150.79 108.5 122.50 101.7 67.9 150.9 90.6 107.1 134.7 147.43
A2 H 254.08 145.39 193.85 212.2 144.6 313.0 192.8 223.6 227.8 236.84
A3 H 299.92 185.31 239.37 239.4 192.6 317.6 256.7 298.2 277.2 281.58
A4 H 368.22 269.46 291.30 238.1 266.6 352.9 355.5 398.5 357.8 359.54
A5 * H 412.24 324.19 334.84 238.9 328.7 338.0 438.3 499.1 412.2 408.84
B2 H 273.28 152.10 216.87 223.3 152.7 329.1 203.6 235.3 251.7 266.80
B3 H 355.85 269.46 321.28 312.1 266.6 471.8 355.5 414.1 378.5 388.14
B4 * H 437.85 339.83 374.47 317.1 347.8 480.9 463.7 529.4 457.6 463.09
B5 * H 456.19 413.87 434.23 309.5 434.7 474.4 579.6 641.3 496.1 495.73
C1 H 151.76 109.4 146.65 102.5 67.9 151.5 90.6 108.0 149.2 169.46
C2 H 266.14 145.39 215.62 211.0 144.6 319.0 192.8 222.4 254.5 275.56
C3 H 351.17 263.00 314.00 326.1 257.6 508.0 343.5 407.3 379.2 393.43
C4 * H 450.31 324.19 374.22 330.7 328.7 506.0 438.3 524.1 449.6 460.21
C5 * H 467.26 407.83 436.52 338.1 398.9 532.7 531.9 629.1 519.5 526.94
C6 * H 521.33 487.91 464.52 309.2 521.6 494.1 695.5 798.7 516.7 516.31
Chiu et al. (2007) HAH-81-35 H 94.31 68.82 52.95 64.6 44.8 96.7 59.7 68.1 77.4 85.31
NCH-62-33 H 64.14 39.94 45.64 40.0 33.3 57.7 36.6 42.1 55.2 60.60
HCH-91-42 H 87.51 56.61 58.00 55.0 45.8 79.4 50.3 58.0 74.6 82.64
Jeng (2014) A095c H 209.98 184.5 142.52 108.4 79.9 137.5 96.8 114.3 134.4 168.97
A120a H 215.25 189.8 96.76 101.6 65.4 112.1 79.3 107.0 124.7 184.33
B065b H 278.00 252.2 128.27 187.4 174.4 151.5 211.9 250.3 237.8 286.31
B080a H 300.66 275.2 243.23 250.9 198.2 309.1 239.8 283.5 267.9 273.75
B110a H 237.48 212.0 127.34 117.3 83.7 143.6 101.6 123.6 149.4 208.45
C100a H 370.15 344.7 308.37 291.2 214.7 393.6 259.4 306.8 315.3 333.10
D075a H 339.48 314.0 251.86 272.3 201.1 418.3 242.2 287.0 305.0 324.75
D090a H 343.08 317.6 298.37 292.0 214.9 424.1 260.1 307.6 324.0 345.40
Kim et al. (2020) H08-3-65 H 128.00 79.94 112.05 104.0 91.2 146.4 109.5 111.1 123.1 127.15
H08-4-90 H 130.00 74.29 106.20 96.4 83.4 146.8 100.1 101.6 115.6 120.10
H08-5-100 H 117.00 76.27 111.77 104.0 90.7 146.5 108.9 110.5 122.6 126.70
H10-3-52.5 H 143.00 92.53 129.59 104.0 112.4 146.7 134.8 136.8 142.4 145.15
H10-4-72.5 H 127.00 94.04 122.35 104.0 103.7 146.6 124.4 126.2 134.6 137.91
H10-5-80 H 125.00 93.70 129.86 104.0 111.7 147.2 134.0 136.0 141.8 144.59
H06-3-90 H 102.00 47.39 91.44 76.5 66.2 122.2 79.5 80.6 98.3 103.69
H10-5-135 H 95.00 70.56 92.83 78.9 68.2 126.0 81.9 83.1 100.4 105.70
H08-3-72.5 H 114.00 75.47 104.53 95.6 82.7 145.9 99.3 100.7 114.9 119.46
H12-5-72.5 H 129.00 93.25 139.33 104.0 108.4 152.7 130.1 132.0 138.9 141.88
* Fragile failure. ** P—Plain section; H—Hollow section.